The Old Laughing Lady
"The Old Laughing Lady" is a song written by Neil Young that was first released on his 1968 debut solo album Neil Young. Music and lyricsAllmusic critic Matthew Greenwald describes "The Old Laughing Lady" as a "striking mood piece."[1] He describes the music as being "built on some simple, downcast chord changes, in a modal D guitar tuning," which he says gives the song depth and grandeur.[1] Music critic Johnny Rogan describes the song's use of string instruments and a "ghostly girl chorus" as giving it an "eerie effect."[2] Young biographer Jimmy McDonough remarks on the song's "sweet, sad countermelodies passing from strings to French horn with beautiful restraint."[3] According to music critic Nigel Williamson, the production by Jack Nitzsche helps give the song a sense of mystery.[4] The song contains four verses but no refrain.[5] The changes in mood and tone over the course of the song are reminiscent of Young's earlier song "Broken Arrow" that he wrote and performed as a member of Buffalo Springfield.[6] Rolling Stone Magazine critic Gary Von Tersch considers "The Old Laughing Lady" to be the more effective of the two, because he considers it to be "tighter, more mature and [have] more of the quiet explosion to it that Young obviously intends.[6] The themes of "The Old Laughing Lady" include love, death, alcoholism and alienation.[1][7] The old laughing lady of the title can be a metaphor for either death or alcohol.[2][4][8] The song describes how the old laughing lady affects the lives of those she interacts with.[5] Writing and recording"The Old Laughing Lady" was written earlier than most of the songs on Neil Young. According to Young, he wrote it one day on a napkin while drinking coffee in a coffee shop without knowing what prompted it.[3][8] A version was recorded by Buffalo Springfield for their 1968 album Last Time Around in January 1968.[1][4] An even earlier version was tried out during the sessions for Buffalo Springfield's earlier album Buffalo Springfield Again.[4] In the version on Neil Young, Nitzsche used a vocal muting technique that makes Young sound "a million miles away, but right there."[3] ReceptionNeil Young FAQ author Glen Boyd described "The Old Laughing Lady" as having "stood the test of time" since Neil Young was released.[9] Pitchfork contributor Mark Richardson describes the song as having "echoes of the great music to come" from Young's later career.[10] In 2014 the editors of Rolling Stone Magazine ranked it as Young's 63rd all time greatest song, describing it as "California psychedelia with the sun sucked out."[8] Young included "The Old Laughing Lady" on his 1977 compilation album Decade.[2][11] A live version was released on Young's 1993 album Unplugged, although Rogan felt that version lacked the mystery and sadness of the original.[2][5][12] References
|