DOKUMEN123.COM

are large number of articles on Wikipedia dealing with the subject of "Criticism" and "Critique", many seem to be written without knowledge of others,...

self-criticism and will focus on the history and development of the idea. This page will also provide information in regards to the self-criticism as a...

(UTC) Criticism of Israel → Criticism of the State of IsraelCriticism of the State of Israel – In a previous RM, this article was moved from Criticism of...

page back to Higher criticism? It was moved here last summer with no discussion I don't think, and an independent higher criticism article was started...

may be unfavourable to one's religious views. This article is about the criticism of religion which included arguments which demonstrate societies with...

unbiased discussion of the various criticisms leveled against the 'War on Terror'. Instead what I got were criticisms of the war on terror. Let me make...

anti-evolutionist views of the Muslims today aren't rooted in Qur'an, and the criticism of these ideas don't belong in this article. I propose, that this part...

There is a move discussion in progress on Talk:Criticisms of socialism which affects this page. Please participate on that page and not in this talk page...

critiques of the religion. It should also not be a place where someone lists criticisms and each one gets the "Baha'i response" to the issue. What I deleted in...

theory' or 'Criticism of Jesus' rather than a broad critique of Christianity. This content is not directly related to general criticisms of Christianity...

subject to criticism throughout its history for its beliefs and practices. Subject to criticism by who? This sentence needs to cite sources. Criticisms of the...

Joschka Fischer, and Abba Eban focus on anti-Zionism (rather than general criticisms of Israel or Israeli policies), and assert that much of anti-Zionism is...

extremely short summaries of the EP's criticisms. We find some of the paragraphs are dedicated to explaining a criticism, but it is always written to be about...

delved more specifically into themes. One subarticle idea was this one: criticism of U.S. foreign policy. So I researched it. While I'm highly critical...

(classical) Marxist (not Marxist–Leninist) criticisms as a theory, not practice; there's already Criticism of communist party rule for that. Furthermore...

be split into pages entitled "Criticism of Walt Disney Studios" (splitting the "Walt Disney Studios" section), "Criticism of Walt Disney Television" (splitting...

the apartheid analogy. There is no [[Criticism of the US government], Criticism of the Syrian government, Criticism of the Russian government, etc...even...

disambiguation page. It had prominent links to the articles Criticism of communist party rule and Criticisms of Marxism, and a brief three-paragraph explanation...

I want to merge the Criticism of Science article with the Antiscience article because they are both highly critical of the scientific method, scientism...

viewpoints. addition: I am also confused as to whether this article cites criticism of SUVs or the SUV owners themselves.. Many points are about how statistically...

grew out of a discussion on the Talk page for Criticism of Mormonism. That article has a section "Criticism of Joseph Smith". That section is (now) rather...

@Nigelj: Hi, I just checked the Criticism_of_the_IPCC_Fourth_Assessment_Report#Open_letter_from_scientists section you added a long time ago and I have...

updated criticisms of Ubuntu and Linux desktops in general. The main problem is that, especially in the case of Ubuntu, Canonical has taken criticisms seriously...

government, has enough to be its own page. Also, more importantly, the Criticisms of the U.S. government page currently has a number of issues that I would...

Faro0485 (talk) 15:29, 20 September 2009 (UTC) It's an explanation of the criticism, the explanation of the glorification can be found in the opposite article...

P.S. Criticism of Christianity; Criticism of Coca-Cola; Criticism of Holocaust denial; Criticism of Microsoft; Criticism of Muhammad; Criticism of Wikipedia(...

This also belongs in the Criticism of Java article, but it should be noted that the lawsuit Sun brought against Microsoft hurt the consumer. Since the...

Wikipedias that have sections on their articles on Neopaganism talking about Criticism of Neopaganism https://pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neopoga%C5%84stwo#Kontrowersje...

We need to be careful that the criticisms and links concern Christianity specifically, and not religion in general (there are other articles for that)...

to lower criticism to the textual criticism article. Stephen C. Carlson 02:13 Dec 13, 2002 (UTC) Items I'd like to mention: higher criticism got a bad...

Reliable sources are those that report notable criticism. Its not our job to determine that Spencer's criticism of Islam is notable but Bal Thackeray's is...

linguistic Biblical criticisms? In addition, I can't help feeling that "Linguistic Biblical Criticism" or "Linguistic Criticism of the Bible" would be...

are plenty of articles devoted to solely criticism of subjects, such as Criticism of Facebook and Criticism of religion. If you have suggestions for changes...

12 November 2025 (UTC) The redirect Criticism of Islam/Sub article: Alleged intolerance of Islam to criticism has been listed at redirects for discussion...

Is the following paragraph sourced to J. N. Farquhar, considerable as criticism of Sikhism ? The tragedy in the history of these sects which, under the...

November 2024 (UTC) What laws in specific monarchy systems lead to so much criticism? POUSHOO (talk) 19:41, 22 October 2024 (UTC) Norway: I added background...

references in wikilinked articles. I have found content for some of Viacom criticisms and controversies's orphans, the problem is that I found more than one...

article on criticism of the Israeli government? This is a very broad topic, and not suitable for one article. I am not aware of articles on criticism of any...

Perhaps criticism of evangelism should be moved here? Removed this: For example, following the death of the Catholic Pope John XXIII in 1963, the Protestant...

interesting to see this article in comparison to criticism of Islam article, or article on criticism of Christianity. Most of all it's amazing how we...

title of this article states it as a biased view point, containing only criticism of Walmart. In this article numerous complaints against Walmart are described...

The following text belongs in criticism of Muslims/Islam or criticism of Iran. This is not criticism directed at the Quran so should be deleted or made...

opposition. That being said, my considered opinion is that all articles about "Criticism of Religion XYZ" should be nuked for serving little useful purpose. TrangaBellam...

it denies the obvious and admitted reality that psychological biblical criticism is as old as the Bible. For starters, what about Philo? (Shouldn't Philo...

article is about criticism of the Quran. As in all other similar articles, we have criticism follows by response. You preface criticism with excessive quotations...

the criticisms section? If so, this discussion should be coordinated with the discussion on the Criticism of Facebook talk page here: Talk:Criticism...

non-admin page mover) SilverLocust 💬 23:11, 28 July 2023 (UTC) Criticism of value-form → Criticism of value-form theory – Very briefly: the value-form is a...

shouldn't even mention this claim in the article unless we can find a notable criticism of it. - Merzbow 02:12, 19 December 2006 (UTC) There is mistakes to say...

June 2010 (UTC) Oppose: The article Criticism of patents potentially covers a very wide range of kinds of criticism. Patentleft covers a particular recent...

is about criticism of fractional reserve banking. As such, it seems unnecessary and even inappropriate to include criticisms of the criticisms of fractional...

49.204.54 (talk • contribs) 00:56, 9 August 2014‎ (UTC) The "Status of criticism" section cites Mansuripur, M. (2012), "Trouble with the Lorentz Law of...

form. ·Maunus·ƛ· 13:04, 29 July 2008 (UTC) Have you looked at Source criticism#Literature and references? I'd agree that the article in general and section...

by others 86.22.108.123 (talk) 20:00, 29 October 2025 (UTC) Earilest criticism of Muhammed for his marriage to Aisha was in 1574. refrence: https://books...

agree with you that this is a better title under which to gather omnibus criticism than "ex-premies," which is too limiting. I urge patience on the whole...

PrimeBOT (talk) 21:23, 16 January 2022 (UTC) I think this definition of film criticism is pretty narrow -- the distinction between critics and reviewers is sometimes...

generic, and generative criticism to criticism approaches section. Added citation as well (Sonja K. Foss, Rhetorical Criticism: Exploration and Practice...

I propose that it list criticisms by category. This is listed as a separate page because of the continual removal of criticisms of the bbc on the BBC page...

February 2024 (UTC) This page appears to discuss criticism of Mormonism more generally as well as criticism of the Church of Later Day Saints specifically...

It's also talking about criticism of some very specific U.S. political controversies, and is not even discussing a criticism of Christianity in general...

In no sense is the current section on unemployment a criticism of capitalism. I'm going to re-write this to explain why unemployment is necessary, in...

13.2 (talk) 15:43, 22 November 2008 (UTC) Should it also be noted the criticism of Yahoo getting rid of Personals ebing repaced by match.com and Yahoo...

See also Talk:Criticism of the BBC/Archive1 which contains posts relating to previous incarnations of this article. Compare these two statements: "On...

on Wikipedia. As proof just check the sources for Criticism_of_Windows_Vista#Reaction_to_criticism. LordShard (talk) 08:18, 4 August 2008 (UTC) I can't...

WTO has received more criticism then most other international organizations and deserve an article that deals with the criticism. I think it follows policy...

such as Chiropractic) does not define the term but jumps straight to criticism. Is there an accepted definition? --Quantum7 08:23, 5 August 2022 (UTC)...

This section seems superfluous? Literary criticism is a huge academic discipline (or its popular version in book reviews but that’s a very different thing)...

other articles of "Criticism of X" such as Criticism of the Kyoto Protocol, Criticism of the IPCC Fourth Assessment Report, or Criticism of the World Trade...

redundant categories. It starts fine with aesthetic, logical, and factual criticisms as a good initial triplet of categories; but then it goes on to list a...

about criticism articles, but a sub-article on criticism of a particular company for a particular issue is highly unusual. The existing criticism article...

I noticed that there was a page "criticism of Windows XXX" for every release of windows. But none for Linux. So I created one in the interest of keeping...

is supposed to be a criticism of monotheism or criticism of monotheism that originated from judaism? As I don't see here criticism of pagan monotheisms...

Constructive criticism, is it constructive? in who's opinion? there must be a defined set of rules for constructive criticism. Firstly the criticism must have...

Hello fellow Wikipedians, I have just modified 7 external links on Criticism of college and university rankings (North America). Please take a moment...

of this article Biblical criticism I started work on Biblical criticism in May of 2018. It went to FA review in October of 2018. Then these people copied...

CNN source to write about conservatives criticism of about the firing of James Damore. What about criticism published in Newsweek and the Independent...

consideration Islamqa answer in English from Muhammad Al-Munajjid regarding some criticism of Twelver Shia .Ahendra (talk) 13:11, 3 August 2024 (UTC) @StarkReport...

request was: moved. Dr vulpes (Talk) 02:18, 23 March 2026 (UTC) Criticism of Twitter → Criticism of X (social network) – Move to reference X, with or without...

deleting the following: Some political or religious cults also promote "self-criticism sessions" but these are more in the nature of a (possibly guilt-laden)...

Hinduism, Criticism of Mormonism, Criticism of the Seventh-day Adventist Church, Criticism of Christianity, Criticism of religion, Criticism of atheism...

including Criticism of Islam, Criticism of Hinduism, Criticism of Buddhism, Criticism of Mormonism, Criticism of Christianity, etc. See also Criticism of Religion...

lying to the users... would this be appropriate to put in the Youtube criticism article? 198.53.41.16 (talk) 20:43, 6 May 2008 (UTC) Actually, I just...

Shakespearean criticism? — Preceding unsigned comment added by 128.42.225.242 (talk) 14:13, 9 September 2011 (UTC) for an article named CRITICISM, where exacly...

Wikipedia:Criticism#Philosophy, religion, or politics and Wikipedia:Criticism#Separate articles devoted to criticism, Dedicated "Criticism of ..." articles...

cases the existence of an article seems to inherently promote its topic, "Criticism of ...." articles/sections would seem to inherently advocate the critics'...

and popular criticism is really about relativity in general(NPI), and the current title still allows for describing technical criticisms on general relativity...

NPOV. Hopefully the criticism section on the main page can evolve into a reasonable precis of the criticism. I find the criticism article itself far too...

opinion on X, Y and Z. Finally, I divided the criticisms of Communist states in two paragraphs: Generic criticisms first, death statistics second. The reason...

respect to the Jewish denial of Jesus... surely you cannot take that as "criticism of Judaism?" First of all, for Jews there was no denial per se, merely...

some criticism of this method. Propose to delete the section from the article? 87.194.252.95 (talk) 22:10, 24 April 2009 (UTC) I merged the Criticism section...

psychopathology of criticism refers to the study of unhealthy forms of criticism, and of unhealthy kinds of response to criticism. Psychologists often...

notice that there are two very different definitions of form criticism - biblical form criticism is interested in the literary genre, the identification of...

Like all Criticism articles for corporations, this page just got filled with huge amounts of content, a large amount of undue cruft, and ended up becoming...

The tone of this article is slanted. While there are valid criticisms of Jainism, this page contains a lot of seemingly deliberately incorrect anti-Jain...

impossible to move Talk:Criticisms of communism/Archive, the page with the full page history]] back to where it was (Talk:Criticisms of communism) before...

particular, I noticed that it does not contain a dedicated section addressing criticism or controversies, despite the fact that her public role and the nature...

the several criticisms in the Criticism of Judaism#Criticism of traditional Judaism by reform movement, because several of those criticisms are also made...

--Janneman 13:39, 6 March 2007 (UTC) Agreed. The assumption that New Criticism is politically conservative smacks of dull bias. In my edit, I left this...

11:08, 6 December 2019 (UTC) The majority of the article text is not criticism at all, and that which seemingly is, represent editors original research...

Nick Levinson (talk) 04:36, 12 November 2011 (UTC) Despite referenced criticisms of Marriage, this article needs to elaborate more on the referenced articles...

(diff) which was (apparently) sourced to critical commentary. Where the criticism comes from notable people such sourcing might be acceptable and the extent...

I don't know if this is helpful but his is a search on criticism of Judaism and there is one by Zeitlin on cast doubts on the scriptural account of the...

see Talk:Second_Life#WP:SIZE.3B_Dividing_out_Second_Life.2FIssues_and_criticisms, Talk:Second_Life/Archive3#Cutting_down_article_bloat. Signpostmarv 07:37...

(UTC) Criticisms of Marxism → Criticism of Marxism Criticisms of anarchism → Criticism of anarchism Criticisms of communist party rule → Criticism of communist...

Read Criticism of Islam, Criticism of Christianity, Criticism of Jainism, Criticism of Muhammad and Criticism of Jesus before commenting how criticism of...

the pages on the Federal Reserve (for criticism specific to the Fed) and central banks (for generic criticism of the concept of central banking)? Right...

Any sort of 'criticism of' page is extremely susceptible to garbage and needs a lot of sources. There are many good critiques of postmodern theory, but...

If you know of reliable sources which discuss this as it relates to criticism of the Bible, please feel free to propose them here. Grayfell (talk) 05:08...

I must say that development criticism, as explained here, has almost nothing to do with Antimodernism, as aesthetical tendency in Europe between 1890s...

THE APRIL 7, 2010 version of the article. Modifications include: adding criticism from Uriel da Costa; adding a section on Slavery; grouping the sections...

state' that it's a criticism: it doesn't need to say 'here it is: a criticism'. It's criticism; it doesn't have to say it's criticism. Why is it notable...

very odd constriction on the topics that the entry covers. It says that criticisms of Judaism are those made "on theological grounds." I understand that...

July 2008 (UTC) Some links revealed after a search on "criticism of the arts" and "arts criticism". Some may only be of use to prove the term has the meaning...

Criticism of Christianity, Criticism of Mormonism, Criticism of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Criticism of Catholicism, Criticism of...

compilation of assumed opinions about vanilla ice cream. Certainly there are criticisms of Judaism, of the American Constitution, of incandescent light bulbs...

mover) SITH (talk) 14:20, 29 December 2018 (UTC) Criticism of the Work Capability Assessment → Criticism of Employment Support Allowance – The scope of...

methodology of the "Criticism of" articles. Stereotypes are not criticism. Myths are not criticism. Misunderstandings are not criticism. Criticism is more noble...

regarding the general criticism of the book. - which would be fine if this was 'Criticisms of The Da Vinci Code', but it isn't. 'Criticisms of The Da Vinci...

since, so their current contents would not represent what is currently in Criticisms of globalization (since they were responded to after they were moved to...

September 2020 (UTC) @Alexandraaaacs1989 I'm going to try to clean up the ICE criticism section. I'll try to make the changes small and explain each one. Let...

the miscellaneous criticism points; due to growing size of "personal lifestyle" section, promoted it out of miscellaneous criticism to its own section...

Responses to criticism 5.4.1 Q and A websites 6 Notes 7 References 7.1 Further reading And here is the outline of Criticism of Catholicism 1 Criticism of Catholic...

com/2/Refuting_Infidels_Org_Cosmology.html this will also show that the criticism is very biased and does not fulfill aspects of neutrality — Preceding...

yes it fails WP:V sadly. --GracieLizzie (talk) 08:51, 7 May 2008 (UTC) Criticism here is only listed from the (really rather poor) 1st series. The show...

Christianity), Islam (Criticism of Islam), Judaism (Criticism of Judaism), Hinduism (Criticism of Hinduism) and Buddhism (Criticism of Buddhism) are handled...

/Archive 3 • /Archive 2 • /Archive 1 This article was merged into Prem Rawat#Criticism, but the Prem Rawat page no longer has a section with that title. 86.15...

suitable title would be "Justifications for the Criticisms of the Talmud". This is because not one criticism goes without a justification, which distorts...

determine which criticisms are included? 1a) Subject matter: criticisms of doctrines? practices? texts? laws? actions of leaders? 1ai) If "criticism of texts"...

used as evidence in it. The discussion below has been archived at Talk:Criticism of communist party rule/Archive 1, but I believe it should also remain...

Renamed Marxist criticism and removed reference to political orientation of proponents as irrelevant and arguably non-NPOV. Acanon 02:37, 2 Sep 2004 (UTC)...

delineate the subject matter in a written encyclopedic manner. Our criticism of the criticism article however is necessary for those with good attested examples...

from Talk:Criticism of the Catholic Church Where is this article (Criticism of Judaism)? 75.3.4.54 04:01, 8 May 2006 (UTC) There are "criticism of" articles...

redundant to the excellent security criticisms in the individual (Criticism of Windows Vista#Security, Criticism of Windows XP#Security, Internet Explorer#Security...

unless a WP:RS makes a criticism, we can't include simple facts on a criticism page; it's WP:OR for us to declare it a criticism. -M.Nelson (talk) 16:58...

promotes fraud and deception. Many of the socialist criticisms seem to be 'arts student' level criticisms, blaming free markets for any perceived ill - I...

March 2020 (UTC) Hello there, I would suggest to add information about criticism about the national quarantines imposed in China, Italy and Spain among...

14:37, 15 July 2014 (UTC) Is this better? "Feminist literary criticism is literary criticism informed by both feminism and feminist theory. Using feminist...

2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 Whoever added the Tim Tebow section under the criticism of ESPN section, was not AT ALL to Wikipedia standards. They even used...

Cantabrigensia are not mentioned in the article, and their relevance to textual criticism is not explained. In other words, the image seems to be decorative rather...

Personally, the bulk of this article seems to be poor. It seems to be a criticism of the actions and beliefs of sects in Christianity and does not present...

in your comment you say "per talk page Hitchens discussion". But that criticism was not supported by a Hitchens source, it is from many other sources...

to criticism of Islam, religious criticism is strongly tied to criticism of Islam and general criticism of religion is strongly tied to criticism of Islam...

referenced was Islam and slavery, not Muhammed and slavery (fixed) Comparing Criticism_of_Muhammad#Ownership_of_slaves to Islam_and_slavery#Muhammad.27s_traditions...

Arab-Israeli conflict. Generally "criticism" articles are POVFORKs that should be deleted, or in this case perhaps merged to Criticism of the Israeli government...

page moved. Andrewa (talk) 02:56, 5 May 2025 (UTC) Criticism of Unification Church in Japan → Criticism of the Unification Church in Japan – This seems to...

article does not reveal which textbooks are at issue. Shouldn't it be retitled: "2017 Bangladesh textbook criticism"? Bill (talk) 23:22, 11 May 2025 (UTC)...

threads: criticism of schooling as a public institution criticism of schooling as bad anthropology — e.g. age segregation of children criticism of schooling...

too many papers that do not recognize architecture criticism as a legitimate field of arts criticism - that still put architecture writing in with real...

This is from a discussion during the March 16thish AfD for Criticism of George W. Bush. I have no interest in writing this article, but an editor asked...

after a period. Has anyone suggestions to a more reputable source of criticism of atheism? Centrepull (talk) 00:15, 19 March 2022 (UTC) I replaced him...

this page. Biographical criticism is, of course, an essential and important dimension of any fully informed literary criticism, and I was shocked when...

that is just criticisms, without at least a brief acknowledgment of the opposing view for NPOV, and without acknowledging that many criticisms apply to only...

This article concentrates all the criticism of the concondats without noting the possible positive aspects nor the arguments in their favour, thus compromising...

removed. But if a topic is something like "Criticism of Islam", it is not inappropriate to mention or quote criticisms of Islam, even if you think they're wrong...

December 2008 (UTC) The article is about criticisms of Ebay, this is an established and widespread criticism of Ebay. Ebay is hardly going to state "yes...

What about adding sections on criticisms of FG for being overrated, cheesy, post ironic hipster-wannabe humor, that is primarily targeted at those who...

removals, one can see that 1) some of the statements are clearly are not criticisms, for instance the claims that Islam permits rape when the report mentioned...

The article must note the difference between social criticism, generally an informal term used to refer to commentary outside of social science, more...

Trilobite (Talk) 22:21, 30 May 2005 (UTC) This section first mentions the criticism about PJPII, but then goes off on some tangents about (1) what was done...

put criticism of individual persons on this page. In addition, this page is Criticism of atheism, not Criticism of the New Atheism, so criticisms that...

suggest changing the headings to include, for instance, Contemporary Art Criticism. Notable critics working today in the UK include Sarah Kent, Brian Sewell...

where are we at. I think that any material which isn't a direct and clear criticism be removed. Iβn Kᾱτhir τᾱℓк 09:57, 10 March 2011 (UTC) Hey, welcome back...

Dwain (talk) 21:18, 9 November 2010 (UTC) Obviously, a page relating criticism is displaying POVs. But they are not an author's POV. You can't say that...

Wiki series on Criticism of Religion. Please help develop this page with a neutral point of view, presenting the phenomenon of criticism of Haredim - as...

• I did it!) 20:33, 15 April 2012 (UTC) It also seems to be more of a criticism of the livestock practices associated with fast food instead of the industry...

terrorist who kidnapped and murdered a soldier. Many pro-Israel organization criticism them for that. this is a statement from israel official page https://twitter...

is "Criticisms of Marxism". The article is not WP:QUOTEFARM of criticisms. What is important is identifying the most notable substantial criticisms of...

Ultramarine, much of the stuff is repeated from Criticisms of communism. Could you at least remove from one of the articles? Also, Bryan Caplan is not...

article is an editorial by Isi Leibler, a journalist. There is some online criticism of HRW's position on recent (2019/2020) developments in Bolivia, but none...

need" to have references for the phrase modern religious and secular criticism of Islam, check out the main page, there's plenty of it. That's why i...

Bishop's criticism of non-standard analysis in an undergraduate calculus textbook, largely confined to a single book review? Connes' alleged criticism of something...

certain criticism. Perhaps if one were to divide the article into groups Criticism of Abrahamistic religions (Christian, Islamic, Jewish) Criticism of other...

a request from Talk:Criticism of the BBC. It matches the following masks: Talk:Criticism of the BBC/Archive <#>, Talk:Criticism of the BBC. This page...

English does not. I wonder why even in the article "Esperanto" theres's a criticism part (and this one is linked to it) and in the English one there's not...

of criticism can overwhelm the page.Historicist (talk) 18:05, 14 June 2009 (UTC) This is not really criticism, but an article about such criticism, as...

irrelevant with the subject of criticism to Christianity. No author of the two papers is articulating or answering criticism to Christianity. Cherry picking...

outline, with sections on history of biblical criticism, higher criticism, and lower or textual criticism. Some subsections are also suggested. The links...

that start with "Criticism of" how about starting with something that has a lot more attention, eg Criticism of Christianity or Criticism of Wikipedia. Or...

closure) (t · c) buidhe 10:03, 30 November 2021 (UTC) Criticism of Facebook → Criticism of MetaCriticism of Meta – Facebook as a company have changed their...

conformity with WP:NPOV. it would probably have been better to start a criticism section on Islamism and then fork it out if there was sufficient content...

I don't understand what any of this has to do with Criticism of atheism. Has any reliable source cited these studies as an argument against atheism? If...

Wittgenstein and Tolstoy learned their Kant by reading Schopenhauer's criticism. When Kant positioned the faculty or power of judgment between understanding...

a request from Talk:Criticism of Muhammad. It matches the following masks: Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive <#>, Talk:Criticism of Muhammad. This page...

October 2013‎ "Criticism of Comcast" does not seem to be an appropriate title for this article; there are almost no claims of criticism throughout the...

Shouldn't this be "criticisms of welfare statism" or "criticisms of welfare states" instead? byelf2007 (talk) 17 October 2011 Seconded: the section dealing...

like a criticism of an approach to criticism. We could create a section after 'history of criticism of Islam' called 'modern approaches to criticism of Islam'...

paragraph of the Criticism from Orthodox Judaism section reasonably summarizes the key specific arguments made in individual criticisms which follow, all...

link" Atheist Murderers. I don't think this is appropriate, as it's not criticism of atheism; it's a list of murderers who happened to be atheists. It looks...

I note that there's a bunch of missing criticism's - specifcally, those from individuals who believed the IPCC was not alarmist enough. Why aren't those...

on a request from Talk:Criticism of Google. It matches the following masks: Talk:Criticism of Google/Archive <#>, Talk:Criticism of Google. This page was...

2007 (UTC) Criticisms of Anti-Scientific Viewpoints was moved from Scientism per the example set in Allopathy that was used to delete [criticisms of modern...

back to its original content, which was on Genre Criticism, a specific approach to Rhetorical Criticism prominent in Rhetorical Studies in both the Communication...

those claims and can be cited. Any meta-criticism, that is aggregation of criticism, criticism of criticism should be cited to avoid OR in this article...

I refer to '6. Redaction Criticism has determined in advance what it will discover and therefore it is not a question of whether the writer will be found...

--DanielPharos (talk) 07:41, 14 April 2014 (UTC) I suggest a new article of "Criticism of Windows 8". A starter for information: a lot of people tend to criticize...

is correct in that 1) criticism of criticisms are not a necessary requirement in order to insert into this or any other "Criticism of..." article in Wikipedia...

other religious figures. So why does the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) get criticism. This article is TERRIBLE, and must be removed. Xtremeownage should sign...

241.218.107 (talk) 04:02, 10 September 2009 (UTC) there should be some criticism available in this article, as a response, and for a more detailed argument...

We don't have "Common Criticisms of General Motors", "Common Criticisms of Apple" or "Common Criticisms of Thimbles" so why should we have this page?...

the Vox Day prose. It was not a criticism of religion, or even a rebuttal to a criticism of religion. It was a criticism of atheism and specifically communist...

includes the issue relating to child sexual abuse among the summary of criticism, and it does not seem necessary to include the subject in the lead twice...

compromise, I shifted the Paine quote to this Criticism page, and added some more, while leaving just a brief criticism paragraph in Moses. This article is, therefore...

was recently removed from the article. If the refs are appropriate, and criticism is corroborated, then this is the place where such information should...

2021 (UTC) Criticism of Dropbox → Dropbox controversies – The article seems to focus on controversies surrounding Dropbox rather than criticisms of the service...

highly significant that it at least be noted that many criticisms of Marxist theory tie into criticisms of the practical applications. Most who oppose historical...

already covered at Atheism#Criticisms_of_atheism -- Astrokey44|talk 10:58, 22 February 2006 (UTC) The section Atheism#Criticisms_of_atheism links back here...

This page is not "criticism of hinduism". This page is "anti-criticism of hinduism". There are more text in defending hinduism than criticising it. What...

odd. It seems like User:Rincewind82 was working on a personal user-land criticisms page, and then a completely different user decided to move it into this...

In the beginning of the article, it states that literary criticism is a new genre in Iran since it did not exist before the penetration of European culture...

Criticism of Islam is entirely on-topic in this article, however, editors will be bound by scholarly and encyclopedic standards. Such a standard is set...

include: Adding a section on issues in criticism, relationship with readers, and examples of television criticism. Fixing citation mistakes Spelling and...

about criticism of various figures, religions, and philosophies including: Criticism of Jesus, Criticism of Christianity, Criticism of Islam, Criticism of...

difficult to prove. The many people who have left silently made implicit criticism that they found the message of Maharaji and the meditation not worthwhile...

Very interesting to compare the criticism of Jesus page to the criticism of Muhammad page. Wiki is managed and was created by Western Society but lets...

needs to be renamed "Criticism of the Latter Day Saint movement". This would help (big time) to clarify things like the FARMS criticisms, because then our...

Antifeminism isn't the criticism of Feminism no more than the Pro-Choice movement is the criticism of the Pro-Life movement. — Preceding unsigned comment...

are doing, for instance, feminine criticism is now called feminine literary criticism instead of just biblical criticism. Should I include that example?...

alas, it's not true, and it's especially not true of his Experiment in Criticism. Lewis does say there that a critic should not to try to tackle works...

See Criticism of Religion Criticism of Christianity Criticism of Hinduism Criticism of Islam Criticism of Judaism Criticism of Buddhism Criticism of Mormonism...

put it right then we can put the opinions or criticisms about it.... I think to put something as a criticism it should be a reliable thing, it's like to...

Wiki policy to describe any kind of criticism... But to put it plainly, that's complete BS. See the ExxonMobil criticism section for a healthy respectful...

then that would be a different story, because then it is definitely a criticism of religion. Otherwise, it would be like comparing rising global warming...

and criticism. It matches the following masks: Talk:Chiropractic controversy and criticism/Archive <#>, Talk:Chiropractic controversy and criticism. This...

proposed a major change involving this article, see Talk:Criticism of Wal-Mart#List of criticisms of Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. for rationale. Tuxide 17:06, 1...

criticisms and controversiesMSNBC criticisms and controversies – I've been looking at Category:Criticisms of companies and it is a mix of criticism and...

serious criticisms of his administration? —Preceding unsigned comment added by 71.206.87.116 (talk) 19:21, 3 January 2010 (UTC) Going to the FDR criticism page...

Definitely should be deleted. The Book of Abraham article is where the criticism should be - the BOA article needs to be cleaned up.Descartes1979 (talk)...

tautologous - after all, that's just what atheism is. But the burden of criticism in this section is the failure of atheism to accept any of the long-standing...

has to say is worth including - whether fairly or unfairly, these *are* criticisms levelled against socialism. He's also realised it's a bit POV and has...

request from Talk:Criticism of the Bible. It matches the following masks: Talk:Criticism of the Bible/Archive <#>, Talk:Criticism of the Bible. This...

from Talk:Criticism of Microsoft Windows. It matches the following masks: Talk:Criticism of Microsoft Windows/Archive <#>, Talk:Criticism of Microsoft...

battle against this word degenerates in complete irrationality. Every criticism and objective approach is then branded as "mind". If somebody feels bad...

legitimate criticism by many people, and it is not in any way POV to cover those criticisms here at wikipedia. Also, note that biblical criticism is not the...

12 March 2010 (UTC) I've been researching these criticisms, and it appears that all of the criticisms listed above are made by a variety of sources: Chinese...

requirement, so even if you don't like the property it is not really a criticism of C. This article was split off the main C programming language article...

Criticism of Family Guy. It seems the links in the article are to actual criticisms of family, but not secondary sources directly ABOUT the criticism...

Judging from other criticism articles about websites, whenever a website changes its design it must be included in the website's criticism article, sources...

I removed the criticism section as it was a bit off topic - dealing more with criticism of chiropractic in general rather than criticism of the scientific...

this isn't the only article spun off from the criticism section of an article. See: Category:Criticisms, which lists 60 pages including some from WP:BLP...

of the actual criticism levied at the league.Phillip J. Fry 22:37, 7 January 2007 (UTC) Also, as this page is more about the criticisms of the league...

again. Now it reads "Other criticisms" which incorrect because the criticism are in many cases are just the same criticisms as made by ex-premies. Andries...

Bill O'Reilly (political commentator). It matches the following masks: Criticism of Bill O'Reilly (political commentator)/Archive <#> It was generated...

usually described as the philosophical study of the methods of literary criticism -- the redirect was conflating the theory with its object. I've tried...

LGBTQIA+ rights. I removed this section for a few reasons: Framing it as a "criticism" risks violating NPOV, since much of the article focuses on things which...

out, in the context of the article itself, that there is substantial criticism. It's a whole other issue to actually create an entry devoted to the debate...

that any criticism that is added will be removed unless it is seemingly so minor that no one cares. The truth is that not only are Criticisms generated...

criticisms of the church 2) Improve the neutrality of individual sections, by ensuring that the first sentence of each section defines the criticism (rather...

commendable aspects to this article, explaining the different methods of criticism clearly, but the "Historical Jesus" sections (there are two of them) do...

of facts, with the actual criticism beeing drawn as OR from the sources. Most of the sources do not even contain criticism. This article is mostly useless...

be an article about criticisms of Linux aswell? 84.251.209.174 14:03, 25 December 2006 (UTC) Of course although any such criticisms are unlikely to be...

this article as a sub-section of the coca-cola article in response to criticism by a newspaper - Master Of Ninja 13:49, 24 June 2006 (UTC) Agreed. --Stbalbach...

remove the neutrality tag, since this surely cannot stand up to higher criticism, a part of which i have already provided.Atheistic Irani (talk) 00:37...

with "Criticism of .." as in: Criticism of Religion Criticism of Christianity Criticism of Hinduism Criticism of Islam Criticism of Judaism Criticism of...

articles called Criticism of EverQuest, Criticism of Everquest, Criticism of MMORPGs, etc. shows some obvious POV issues. There is a Criticism of Ultima Online...

anti-everything, holier-than-thou and pretentious. Unfortunately any criticism of Southpark is immediately branded as Christian conservatism, both being...

article, since there are two separate articles of Anti-Catholicism and Criticism of Catholicism, because clearly these are two separate topics. One is...

Deletion? But there is art criticism and literary criticism? Ben Tibbetts 02:02, 3 June 2006 (UTC) Image:Conscripcartoon.jpg is being used on this article...

I've been re-reading the 4th essay, rhetorical criticism, and now I finally feel I'm getting an understanding of the material. I've done an overhaul of...

instead of having been relegated to an article of their own. For example Criticism_of_Google#Privacy discusses issues that are at least as notable in terms...

This article is created along the lines of "criticisms of socialism." The text was moved here from Communism, which is now finally turning into a standard...

article was split out of "Textual criticism", but many discussions related to the subject remain in Talk:Textual criticism. - üser:Altenmann >t 16:14, 16...

supporters will NOT allow criticism on the CAIR-Wikipedia entry page, it is more than unusual to see that the wiki-entry named: "Criticism of the Council on American-Islamic...

which I believe places undue weight on outdated and poorly referenced criticisms of questionable relevance to the modern FDA and ongoing efforts by policymakers...

(UTC) Hello fellow Wikipedians, I have just modified 2 external links on Criticism of the Kyoto Protocol. Please take a moment to review my edit. If you...

(UTC) This page is about Criticism of Twelver Shiites. There is no reason for any Tu quoque fallacies. Also, the main criticism of mut'a marriage is that...

Could as just as well argue for that all the criticisms should be removed due to the counter-criticisms. ::Controversy itself is not a reason for exclusion...

this section. The result of the move request was: moved to "Myth (form criticism)" by nominator 18:10, 4 November 2012. DrKiernan (talk) 16:22, 8 November...

cid=1167467653137&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FShowFull Should this be added to the criticisms? It is difficult for users to know what changes have been recently added...

Times ran three sentences on page A20. Look under Criticisms of Dept. of Homeland Security > Criticisms of FEMA > Censorship in this article. There's some...

The "criticism" components of the parent NASCAR article had become dominant in that text. This varies quite a bit from the other professional league and...

could be left in Criticism of the Latter Day Saint movement. Alternatively, we could merge Criticism of the Book of Mormon and Criticism of the Book of...

the criticisms to be written down as null criticisms, these were chosen. However, the former does to some extent suggest that there is a criticism to be...

Is it just me or is it very difficult to find Bahá'í Faith specific criticisms with regards to gender equality. I know for a fact that there are people...

article, what is needed here is a proper statistical analysis of all the criticism, rather than all the anecdote in the article. I'm sure a few social science...

Wikipedians, I have just added archive links to one external link on Criticism of The Walt Disney Company. Please take a moment to review my edit. If...

amounts necessarily to controversy or scandal. One might consider it criticism but that belongs more in the CBS article itself rather than here and there...

Wikipedia and I hope I did this right. I made a change to the NT Textual Criticism section. I added a note recognizing the body of manuscripts in languages...

Since I know little of dance criticism I emailed the Dance Critics Association just now asking if they would care to contribute to the article, email...

textual criticism. This is actually a section that could be expanded much more, since every other religious text seems to have extensive criticism. Besides...

like a biased Tirade against the PTC. How is it relevant to to their criticism of Family Guy that the PTC files 1,10,50,99 or 100% of indecency complaints...

"criticsm of George W. Bush" or the like (an article merely based on criticism of something) because it's completely inappropriate. I know this has already...

January 2006 (UTC) First of all, there are plenty of mentions of this criticism. For example: Critics typically condemn Communist states by the same criteria...

that "Criticism of" articles are justified when "criticism" is notable in its own right, thus Criticism of wikipedia is an article, but criticism of software...

paragraph in Criticism of the Seventh-day Adventist Church (if that.) We don't even have an Adventist hospital article - having a criticism of... article...

in his movies, so I have no vested interest in "protecting" him from criticism or anything, but this article, created as a standalone as it is, seems...

there is much informative value here. The article is titled Recycling criticism so that's what you're going to find. Its too big to include in the main...

the sections. So, Privacy criticism of Facebook, Technical criticism of Facebook, Censorship on Facebook, Content criticism of Facebook, etc. Gary King (talk · scripts)...

isn't a List of ESPN employees who have ever received criticism. It's an article for criticism of the company itself. If this info belongs anywhere, it's...

that could be reflected in the article? --Grinmouse Is the Susan McClary criticism something that is merely mentioned in the article as an interesting fresh...

12/16/2005 While I support the right of a criticism/controvesry section in this article, I think it is important to realize that the last thing the WMA...

generated because of a request at Talk:Criticism of non-standard analysis. It covers the archives that match Talk:Criticism of non-standard analysis/Archive...

"Controversy and criticism of The X Factor (UK)" -- ungrammatical? I think it would be better as "The X Factor (UK): controversy and criticism". What do you...

Article already exist like Wikipedia:Criticisms and Wikipedia:Why Wikipedia is Not So Great So it will be third article doing the same thing. Agreed. The...

Here's a quick history: someone made a page called "Baha'i criticism", which had a lot of POV information and was lacking in references. After a lot of...

This doesn't make a valid criticism of non-Western societies.) - This is not an article useful for researching what criticisms for religion are available...

namely *criticism of atheism* requires only that we describe the criticisms. We have no obligations to judge the internal quality of the criticisms themselves;...

article was created via a problematic split from Criticism of the Catholic Church; see Talk:Criticism of the Catholic Church#Other side of the same coin...

In the first sentence, this article conflates criticism of copyright with anti copyright "sentiment". Sentiment implies emotional response and is often...

168.65 (talk) 13:26, 4 November 2012 (UTC) Wondering why An Essay on Criticism is in italics and not within quotation marks? Especially considering other...

been your intention. Andries 13:21, 4 Sep 2004 (UTC) In the Sources of Criticism section, it said: "The ex-premie group claims that many if not most of...

certain "new atheists") didn't so myopically focus on Islam (neglecting criticism of other religions and cultures, instead defending the allegedly "Christian"...

"Latino" while there is, indeed, a large amount of general and academic criticism. This view should be balanced and I hope there will be more contributions...

are to begin listing criticisms, we might at least rely on a substantial body of evidence for each criticism. Yet the 'criticisms' here all seem to be...

existence of a competitor is a "criticism" or anything. is the existence of Pepsi a criticism of coke? are planes criticisms of boats? Scroogle as an article...

brief overview of the prominent critics, especially the recent wave of criticism (Dawkins, Harris, Dennet). The section about the harmful consequences...

articles only with criticism, like Criticism of Microsoft, Criticism of Windows Vista, Criticism of Windows XP. As long as the criticism is valid and verifiable...

issues. Only a short reference about the mere existence of theological criticism is mentioned. The article itself however, talks about issues within Islamic...

(UTC) Hello fellow Wikipedians, I have just modified 2 external links on Criticism of Greenpeace. Please take a moment to review my edit. If you have any...

This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the Criticism of Wikipedia article. This is not a forum for general discussion of the subject of...

both? The "higher criticism" article introduces itself as "a branch of literary analysis". Would it be right to say that textual criticism is "literary analysis"...

the unsourced section "Definition", and some sprinkling of the term "criticism" into the existing text. I'm going to redirect this article to "Art history"...

October 2006 (UTC) Go down to the criticism section. The page is locked because one user kept adding the criticism section back in but refused to make...

Wikipedians, I have just added archive links to one external link on Criticism of the National Health Service (England). Please take a moment to review...

a a page for discussing improvements for the Wikipedia article about criticism of Wikipedia. GMGtalk 16:36, 21 January 2020 (UTC) Differentiation on...

5 October 2008 (UTC) "Criticism of marriage" never existed as an article. I'm suggesting to rename this article to "Criticism of marriage". --Apoc2400...

the variations found in the Sana'a manuscript should be included in the criticism of the Quran entry. It is a copy of an early copy which was not burned...

intended to put people off suggesting new items of criticism for inclusion but it has to be criticism that has verifiably and notably been made and been...

of criticism together in one place. It will delete it when done once a consensus version is reached. In Jan 07, it was decided to merge Criticism of Prem...

From the article: It has been argued that Frye’s version of archetypal criticism strictly categorizes works based on their genres, which determines how...

bolded controversy and criticism, and they should likely be part of the title. Hmmmm.....maybe Chiropractic controversies and criticism or some such beast...

all of the criticisms involve some degree of subjective interpretation. If you feel there is a critic that is voicing an unfounded criticism, the best...

makes a mistake, it's a mistake, not criticism. If this article is about criticism it should present the criticism Greenpeace has received. If the photo...

17 May 2007 (UTC) No merge: there is more material available about the criticism of the Pledge of Allegiance than there is about the pledge itself. It...

article was created via a problematic split from Criticism of the Catholic Church; see Talk:Criticism of the Catholic Church#Other side of the same coin...

fellow Wikipedians, I have just added archive links to 3 external links on Criticism of Dish Network. Please take a moment to review my edit. If necessary...

--Zappaz 20:50, 8 Sep 2004 (UTC) Rewrote intro sentence explaining the criticism of the claim of divinity Changed to uniform name convention—“Prem Rawat”...

the article. The article isn't stating that the criticism is necessarily true, just that it is criticism that has been made by a group. OhNoitsJamie Talk...

the way of criticism - when it was nominated for deletion; that redirect was deleted. The article was recreated as a summary of criticism of Apple, with...

February 2025 (UTC) Move to Criticism of G4S instead to keep in line with other set index articles such as, say, Criticism of Amazon. ToThAc (talk) 05:53...

stand, the "Criticisms" section of the article appears to consist largely of defenses against such criticisms, rather than the criticisms themselves....

have preferred keeping this in the main article and trimming to notable criticisms, but I'm willing to work with this if it is what everyone else wanted...

I just dumped most of the criticism sections from Space Shuttle program here. I have not made any other mods. Hopefully this article can turn into a valuable...

this article while reading the Literary theory Wikipedia page. Cambridge criticism is listed under the Schools section. Initial research showed notability...

articles or potentially large articles, such as criticism of Islam, criticism of religion, criticism of Christianity but in this case I do think that...

(UTC) It's used elsewhere as well: Criticism of Wikipedia, Criticism of Microsoft. Funny there's still no Criticism of Yahoo. DuckeJ (talk) 22:03, 3 February...

making them out to be. I'd prefer the merge be from the Anti page into the Criticism one; there's already an existing section which could be expanded upon...

research from the sources to come up with its own criticisms. I do not even feel I understand what the criticism is, (is it that a universal language was stated...

Bill O'Reilly article. Typically, every celeberty page has some sort of criticism section connected to it. I don't quite understand why a completly seperate...

lower criticism today. So that's a biased standard. They aren't notable among chemists either. jbolden1517Talk 13:18, 18 May 2009 (UTC) "Lower criticism" is...

fellow Wikipedians, I have just added archive links to 5 external links on Criticism of Myspace. Please take a moment to review my edit. If necessary, add...

12 October 2009 (UTC) This review is transcluded from Talk:Canonical criticism/GA1. The edit link for this section can be used to add comments to the...

2020 Hello fellow Wikipedians, I have just modified 9 external links on Criticism of The Walt Disney Company. Please take a moment to review my edit. If...

this page because the Criticism section of the Fed's page was too long. At some point, I would like to summarize the criticism section of the Fed's page...

I think one thing that will help these criticism articles be a little more stable and legitimate is to replace the dubious or controversial sources with...

is the "criticism of" article, no source can be used unless the info within is presented AS a criticism or an argument against that criticism. What this...

(UTC) Hello fellow Wikipedians, I have just modified 7 external links on Criticism of Hamas. Please take a moment to review my edit. If you have any questions...

wall of text. This article is for some reason missing a hell of a lot of criticism.71.174.141.4 (talk) 13:00, 23 October 2012 (UTC) Dear user at IP71.174...

(UTC) I do not see the relevance of this sentence to the topic of Value Criticism: "Many leftists[who?] claim, that books such as The Black Book of Capitalism...

06:10, 9 July 2010 (UTC) I will remove the cite because this page is for 'Criticism' of EDO Corporation' and therefore is the appropriate place for information...

(UTC) Hello fellow Wikipedians, I have just modified one external link on Criticism of Rede Globo. Please take a moment to review my edit. If you have any...

There is a move discussion in progress on Talk:Criticisms of socialism which affects this page. Please participate on that page and not in this talk page...

added by 216.8.139.6 (talk) 21:08, 8 July 2010 (UTC) Here is a list of criticisms from my point of view. To integrate them into the article, we need reliable...

The Criticisms of Internet Explorer article came into existence in May 2005, and is intended to eventually provide a neutral, concise, yet thorough summary...

"Excessive inequality" needs a major overhaul - all it is atm is a list of criticisms and list of responses. It could be made to flow better. Infinity0 talk...

documents criticisms aimed at traditional Judaism (which, in this context, generally means Judaism as it existed in 19th century Europe). The criticisms were...

10:18, 25 January 2012 (UTC) This article is about Criticism of Shiite Islam. One of the criticisms is mut'a marriage. The section should tell the reader...

article is "Schopenhauer's criticism of the proofs of the parallel postulate". I believe it should be "Schopenhauer's criticism of attempts to prove the...

MeredithParmer 04:57, 16 March 2007 (UTC) Fish explains reader-response criticism as how the reader interprets the text due to previous experiences in their...

fellow Wikipedians, I have just added archive links to 3 external links on Criticism of AOL. Please take a moment to review my edit. If necessary, add {{cbignore}}...

Shouldn't this article be named Criticism of Seventh-day Adventism? This isn't a criticism of a "church" its a criticism of the SDA religion. All the other...

this page "Criticism of bus rapid transit" doesn't appear to match the article's content, which focuses more on "BRT Creep" or the criticism of bus rapid...

difference of opinion on what constitutes criticism of the Fed. Please advise why you consider widespread criticism of the negative effects of central planning...

is the work of someone disgruntled with AANR, and not any particular criticism of the CFM. And what's with that note about Godwin's law? Tagged for complete...

Explorer#Criticisms, Criticisms of Internet Explorer, Mozilla Application Suite#Criticisms, Criticisms of Mozilla Firefox, Mozilla_Firefox#Criticisms and others...

be a criticism - nor logically who thinks them to be a criticism. Unfortunately, you don't count, so your statement of "To me it is a criticism in the...

purpose of this article? It is: Criticism of Bill O'Reilly. Criticism is criticism. This entire article is expanding on criticism. Likewise, it would be impossible...

fellow Wikipedians, I have just added archive links to 2 external links on Criticism of reality television. Please take a moment to review my edit. If necessary...

474157209 Relationship to Chinese party-state: restored "relocated" UFW criticism 475839572 Relationship to Chinese party-state: corrected grammar and India...

of any "criticism of..." page. I don't care if it's "criticism of Mormonism", "criticism of Nazism", "criticism of eating babies", or "criticism of white...

articles are far from being authoritative sources on psychoanalytic literary criticism anyway. 72.207.38.114 (talk) 07:26, 19 November 2009 (UTC) By placing...

the facts and the commentary are going to be closely tied together. The criticisms going back and forth on talk radio today will be talking points in Congressional...

company and its customers should be included in this article? Or is that criticism of individuals rather than the company itself. —Preceding unsigned comment...

October 2019 (UTC) Read WP:Criticism and read in table that how criticism of religion is made. It’s created by ‘Criticisms’ not by praise. What you’ve...

remove the paragraph quoted above. Also, in the same section, there's some criticism of the BBC from Jeff Randall. For the sake of balance, shouldn't the article...

Masterofthebrick ‍ talk 04:40, 10 March 2024 (UTC) Split the following sections to Criticism of Walt Disney Animation Studios: #Walt Disney Animation Studios #Accusations...

little footnote in the Infinite Jest article in reference to Bloom's criticism is warranted, you have to believe that a)Bloom read the footnote and was...

characteriztion made by the sources Melton and Introvigne). Also,under "Sources of Criticism" second par. 1st sentence, it was not since the 1980s...the sentence should...

Is there a reason why there's no criticism section of Aaron Swartz? There's at least two sides to every story, and this Wikipedia article does not attempt...

I would like to delete it but I don't want to be accused of removing criticism of her -- I think anyone who has actually read hooks or her scholarly...

than the worst-case SRES scenario. This has also been mentioned as a criticism to the report in newspapers at least. Narssarssuaq (talk) 12:00, 19 November...

This section was pruned from Criticism of the Space Shuttle program. James Van Allen, the father of nuclear physics in space and a longtime critic of...

source for this paraphrase: "Perhaps out of fear of provoking further criticism, the Institute has largely avoided controversial issues and has limited...

to an early 2020 version[[ https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Criticism_of_Sikhism&oldid=1057359811]] (my edit restoring article to an early 2020...

that in the article about Fidesz there is not a lot of discussion on "criticism", there is one section, late in the article, a short paragraph, linking...

a request from Talk:Criticism of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. It matches the following masks: Talk:Criticism of the Church of Jesus...

This article has been deleted (see Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Criticisms of Charismatic and Pentecostal belief). Please do not restore it to main...

any chance read the linked talk page above? There was no need for the criticism part longer than the part about the discipline itself. Hence, it's much...

between "academic" study of the Pentateuch - what I mean by Pentateuchal criticism - and religious study, which is more concerned with the spiritual message...

econometrics article. (Msrasnw (talk) 11:03, 12 April 2012 (UTC)) Is this a criticism of statistical methods not suited for the study of economic data?. If...

Hello fellow Wikipedians, I have just modified 13 external links on Criticism of Walmart. Please take a moment to review my edit. If you have any questions...

elanvital; summarize the description of the protagonists; summarize the criticism of the ex-premie group; summarize the ongoing legal disputes between both...

so they need more work: 1) Criticism related to word that may have originated Joseph Smith's New York background 2) Criticism involving miscellaneous factual...

agree to remove the disputed label. Must go Lineage challenge (Misc. criticism section) - This is much better covered in the main article Prem Rawat...

only coherent, reasoned criticism of Objectivism, not polemic rants (to which category an unfortunately large amount of criticism has belonged) or political...

2005 (UTC) See Talk:Criticism of Christianity/Archive1#Rendering_this_article_neutral for the many examples of where "Criticism of X" articles have become...

what the initial problems/criticisms are of the software, or should they be edited to only contain current problems/criticisms? Two things are very evident...

doctrine is "presenting", it is still a "Criticism" of the LDS Church. That is all and this being a "Criticism" page it is completely appropriate.--- ARTEST4ECHO...

The page "Criticism of Walt Disney Animation Studios" is poorly written and organized. The sentence structures, word choices, and syntax are sometimes...

against criticism is underreported. Since the page is afterall about significant criticisms. I have included the Vodafone's public criticism of Bloomberg's...

keep it. For now, it is essentially a personal essay on technological criticisms. The reference to capitalism in the byline is a red alert for NPOV. Some...

some minimal structure to the various criticisms. Selection bias, abortion, and organisational continuity criticisms don't really seem to fit in to the main...

correct technical inaccuracy or show how his comments are aligned with the criticism of APL. However Bookstaber's comments are very much in line with the observed...

lacking responses for all the criticisms, as well, there is a complete lack of independent WP:RS, all of the criticisms come from advocacy groups, there...

These comments are taken from OCT. pages: Criticism: OC Transpo has recently placed the name of bus pass users on their ID passes. If a user covers over...

provide criticism of fractional reserve banking, then I don't see how constantly pointing out that “mainstream” economists don’t agree with the criticism is...

fellow Wikipedians, I have just modified one external link on Feminist art criticism. Please take a moment to review my edit. If you have any questions, or...

requires serious rework before merged. 85.88.24.15 (talk) The topic "Criticism of C++" is a requested article on wiki. Hence an effort has to be made...

the length of the criticism section. I will do so below. HappyWanderer15 (talk) 13:39, 19 June 2025 (UTC) According to WP:CRITICISM: In most cases, editors...

HRW. That would be an instant and massive violation of WP:WEIGHT. The "criticisms" should be systemic, about how the organization operates, or about some...

On 27, Jan, 2006 User:Earl Rezner added a sub-section called Criticism to the Theodism entry. [1] This is the user's only edit, as of 17:01, 10 March...

touched in two weeks is because it was all copied back into George_W._Bush#Criticism_and_public_perception. I don't know what to do now other than deleting...

important discussion, please discuss at Talk:United Nations#United Nations vs Criticism of the United Nations : a clear example of content forking. Emmanuelm...

on the Sacrifice of the Mass as this is (was) by far the most common criticism of the Catholic (meaning Western and Eastern Latin and Orthodox rites)...

Wikipedia:Criticism#Philosophy, religion, or politics for religious topics it's usually "appropriate to have a "Criticism" section or "Criticism of ..."...

fellow Wikipedians, I have just modified one external link on Metaphoric criticism. Please take a moment to review my edit. If you have any questions, or...

'Sources of Criticism'. While keeping changes to a minimum, I have tried to let it flow better, giving a better historical context to the criticisms. I have...

is not a trivia article. The criticism and accompanying material in this article is sufficiant enough to make the criticism relevant to the show and valid...

other edits in its vicinity. A section dedicated for “controversies and criticism” is present in the Wikipedia articles of almost every major newspaper...

wikiedu.org assignment by PrimeBOT (talk) 23:02, 17 January 2022 (UTC) The Criticism section is comparable in size to the rest of the article (38/94 KB, at...

The source page http://www.pulitzer.org/bycat/Criticism is incongruous with the list on this page. For example, note that Jerry Saltz appears 3 times...

real" criticism are excluded. After all, if someone criticised O'R for this it is a criticism. However, if your observation that such a criticism wasn't...

more like a list of bad things Cargill got caught doing rather than criticism. Criticism includes judgment of these actions, with the implication of fault...

intention of whitewashing criticism even though I am an SGI member - all aspects of factual subject matter, including criticism, should I believe be documented...

person. Some of these could be dodged by at least changing this into a criticism of his programs and not the man himself (i.e. avoiding the stricter BLP...

wanted to post the link.SPhilbrickT 14:46, 15 February 2010 (UTC) Another criticism, of potential increased risk of disasters,[1] has been anwered by an IPCC...

written with much more neutral language. It reads more of a criticism of Marginalism than a criticism of the LTV. — Preceding unsigned comment added by 128...

related to criticism of nonstandard analysis. Similarly, in my reading about Brouwer, I have never seen it mentioned that he had a criticism of nonstandard...

however. It seems obvious that an article titled "Criticism of intellectual property" contains only criticism, an therefore is not neutral with respect to...

literary critic and cultural theorist, Terry Eagleton, defines Marxist criticism this way:" Placing those commas around the name "Terry Eagleton" would...

In the miscellaneous criticism section, I tightened up the bit about the exclusivity of the techniques. I have to say I don't understand what the anti...

censorship, others view this from a free enterprise standpoint, that criticism of Wal-Mart's product selection is misguided because Wal-Mart is free...

2022 Hello fellow Wikipedians, I have just modified 3 external links on Criticism of advertising. Please take a moment to review my edit. If you have any...

entitled 'Criticism of [religion]' (namely Criticism of Christianity, Criticism of Islam,Criticism of Buddhism, Criticism of atheism, Criticism of Judaism...

(talk) 16:40, 28 December 2011 (UTC) It's a bit weird that the article "Criticism of the Bible" doesn't have a single word to say about science (and only...

I'm surprised that there is no pedagogic criticism listed here. That's the reason that India gave for rejecting the project "Constructionist learning...

following Wikipedia pages: Amazon.com controversies Criticism of Google Should we rename so both are criticism of X with a redirect from X controversies? Should...

2009 (UTC) Perhaps one could call this "Criticism of FSB by...".Biophys (talk) 13:17, 1 May 2009 (UTC) Criticism of the least evil? Quite safe, actually...

Criticism of Qing dynasty's economic progress, similar to other articles such as Criticism of Facebook, Criticism of Jehovah's Witnesses, Criticism of...

(talk) 01:47, 21 February 2026 (UTC) The criticism part, as well as the general description, chiefly note the criticism of applicability to cultural contexts...

mind guys, I fixed it. There is a move discussion in progress on Talk:Criticisms of socialism which affects this page. Please participate on that page...

i'll admit but the criticism can't be in a standalone section per talk page and policy. If you had completely removed the criticism heading and integrated...

This article is the result of a merger of two articles: Criticism of kemalism and Kemalist ideology per AFD JERRY talk contribs 05:27, 12 January 2008...

editor of Wikipedia. Reading through these supposed "controversies and criticism", I see a lot of stuff that could be said about the New York Times, or...

independant criticism by Media Matters). What policies and guidelines have given you the authority to decide when there is "enough" criticism to make a...

because they were criticism. It's not mandatory that an article contain a distinct "criticism" section; more often than not, criticisms are found inline...

on precisely that issue: criticism of criticism of holocaust denial. My suggestion would be to make Criticism of criticism of Holocaust denial simply...

This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the Criticism of socialism article. This is not a forum for general discussion of the subject of...

worse from Firefox 55 or so and finally resolved in Firefox 57. As a criticism of Windows 10, I'd see most of this as due to the upgrade policy it used...

needs a complete rewrite. It has a hell of alot of POV statements in it. "Criticism of House" should be limited to only what people in the media say, not...

Wikipedia isn't creating its own criticism of Jehovah's Witnesses, and then proving it, or presenting evidence that it's criticisms are valid, but is supposed...

debated.--Cberlet 19:52, 2 May 2005 (UTC) Should we not say, for each criticism, who is making it? It seems like each one should be supported by a citation...

December 2021 (UTC) I was looking for a breakdown of methods of rhetorical criticism as described by Sonja K. Foss. I did find a few methods on Wikipedia,...

2012 2013 2016 2017 2020 2022 For these different sections of the Criticism of Advertising article I added on some important information so that they...

meaning, the role of Li Hongzhi, criticisms of the teachings or of Li Hongzhi, there are also defences and counter-criticisms. So there are a variety of things...

reasonable, adding serious and relevant criticism is reasonable. Adding criticism for the sake of adding criticism is low quality editing. "While it would...

fellow Wikipedians, I have just modified one external link on Unit for Criticism and Interpretive Theory. Please take a moment to review my edit. If you...

to 8 not delete (mostly keep), so no consensus. Unfortunately move to Criticism of the Iraq War on Wheels! got no votes. --SPUI (talk) 14:51, 23 Apr 2005...

originality that too low? We could probably have a bunch of section of criticism of different expansions, but here are some quickies: software fashion...

for the criticism of deniers. Suggest we keep the first sentence, toss the rest of the lede, and replace with the basic ideas of denial criticism. The existing...

demolishes Dr. Ford's criticism. --Perspicacious 19:15, 3 May 2006 (UTC) To say that MacArthur totally demolishes Ford's criticism is POV and should not...

almost nothing to do with the content of the article. HRW's own summary of criticism against it cannot be expected to be a particularly good NPOV summary of...

17 January 2022 (UTC) I tend to agree with the WP:CRITICISM essay that controversy and criticism sections are NPOV minefields. Ways to improve the article...

Seventh-day Adventists explain why the published and widely believed criticisms of by Ellen White are not encyclopedic whereas unpublished goofballs with...

nations to successfully contain the virus. It did not include any of the criticism against the response until I've just added "the pandemic" in one of the...

also the vote in the MT talk page, question 4 is this question exactly Criticisms of Mother Teresa Redundant with Mother Teresa, has been split away from...

presumably. Yet the "criticism" section seems to be nothing more than poltical soapboxing about . . . the trailer. 1)The "criticisms" are generic (location...

"proposing alternative views" and it flags criticism as full out "opposition" (until i fixed the term into "criticism" today). ~2026-21800-29 (talk) 19:00,...

two articles, but Criticism of Yahoo passed its AFD nomination, resulting in the redundancy. The overall effect, with a Criticism section almost as long...

Why is there no Criticisms section like with the other schools of Economic thought?```` — Preceding unsigned comment added by 173.52.119.87 (talk) 22:30...

Ataturk entitled "criticism of reforms", this in my eyes is written in much more encylopedic terms. I was not against including criticism of Ataturk, i was...

168 years ago in 1855. The "Premature obituaries" subsection in the "Criticism" section lists three examples in The Telegraph's history of publishing...

high-profile cancellations have been in the news lately, it's the most common criticism I think of when I think of Netflix 24.29.210.35 (talk) 20:53, 9 February...

I propose splitting the "Criticism and controversies" section into a standalone article, tentatively titled either Criticism of Ticketmaster - in line...

there is no policy against criticism sections, Wikipedia:Criticism explains why it’s a bad idea. It reads better to put criticism into the main text. For...

fellow Wikipedians, I have just modified one external link on Literary Criticism (UIL). Please take a moment to review my edit. If you have any questions...

The criticisms section is truly insane. Why does it open by criticizing the Americans for not intervening more to suppress opposition to the shah? How...

are criticisms of Wilyman, without explicitly mentioning criticism of Martin. This turns a neutral into a negative. I see no explicit criticism of Martin...

the improvement of the article? Or did you mean to answer to my criticism of criticism of "Holocaust denial" where I pointed out some falsifications and...

Islam has a short section summarizing criticism and linking to a more in-depth article, so why shouldn't Christianity? Explain here instead of reverting...

voiced criticism. The passionate criticism has come from the Muslim communities. Beyond governmental criticism this has been the independent criticism that...

similar things. Marcin 17:22, 14 June 2009 See Talk:Windows 7/Archive 6#Criticism article merged for discussion on this. Thank you. —Mythdon (talk • contribs)...

Controversies, praise, and criticism Q6: Why isn't there a criticisms/controversies section? A6: Because a section dedicated to criticisms and controversies is...

Add allegations of sexual assaults into the criticism category 2604:3D09:A17E:8800:CCC:326F:1284:7E5C (talk) 11:59, 30 August 2024 (UTC)...

"Controversy" section "Criticism and controversy", in which an expanded reference to these criticisms can be included. Criticisms, as such, aren't really...

This is the talk page of a redirect that targets the page:  • Criticism of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints Because this page is not heavily...

recommend shortening the criticism section a couple of paragraphs to avoid the undue weight issue. You can still expand on the criticism by creating a Wikipedia...

with preeminent figures in critical thought" Article: "The School of Criticism and Theory at Cornell University offers professors and advanced graduate...

assertions. Using an analogy doesn't soften transphobia or absolve him of criticism ~2026-19837-00 (talk) 22:32, 30 March 2026 (UTC) I'm not saying anything...

Where is the Criticism section? The guy has been called "Bloody Blinken" and "Butcher of Gaza" by protestors for his complicity in the genocide of Palestinians...

was removed. I know that I, personally, would like to have a list of criticisms from good sources, and responses to them; such as at this debate. I wouldn't...

@NinjaRobotPirate: Even though it's been a while since I removed the criticism of gaming chairs added here to the lede, I want to explain why I made those...

whole section of praise but lack of a section of the massive amount of criticism of Hayek is concerning as people who don’t know that Hayek is only revered...

2015 2016 2017 2019 2020 There is a move discussion in progress on Talk:Criticisms of socialism which affects this page. Please participate on that page...

Student editor(s): Yajzel V (article contribs). Normally, we try to avoid "Criticism" sections because they can present problems in achieving WP:NPOV. Perhaps...

the Reception section focuses entirely on scholarly and journalistic criticism of the men's rights movement. I propose adding non-MRM sources that highlight...

Requester suggests the article author used bias. Critic, criticism or criticized words are used 92 times. Suggests a shift of focus from opinion to fact...

Ferguson's criticism or were the same, essential criticism is mentioned in articles and books summarising criticism of anarchism. I assume that criticism has...

The “Criticisms” section is primarily responses to criticisms, with each paragraph starting with a criticism, followed by a much longer section about...

thinking of changing it to "keep" or perhaps to "merge to new article on criticism of CNBC."--JohnnyB256 (talk) 14:02, 14 March 2009 (UTC) Oh yeah, definitely...

purely dedicated to criticism of the government response because it was an opportunity for a detailed examination of the criticisms. The deletion of that...

Unredirected because the place that it redirected to had been deleted, i.e. the Criticism section of the Prem Rawat article. Unable to replace the deleted section...