DOKUMEN123.COM

press release sent out to multiple media outlets. Shortcuts WP:RSMUSICWP:RSMUSIC WP:MUSICRSWP:MUSICRS These sources are generally considered reliable for...

2024 (UTC) Spotcheck coming in bit. [87]: Y Source is reliable per WP:RSMUSIC; although some concern would come up due to the RSP entry on AllMusic,...

per WP:RSMUSIC) Ultimate Guitar (reliable per WP:RSMUSIC) Guitar World (reliable per WP:RSINSTRUMENT), Alternative Press (reliable per WP:RSMUSIC). I'm...

Allmusic is an WP:RSMUSIC source: [1], [2], [3]. Staff reviews in Punknews are valid per WP:RSMUSIC: [4], [5], [6]. Exclaim! is another WP:RSMUSIC source: [7]...

17 October 2023 (UTC) For what it's worth, Metal Storm is listed on WP:RSMUSIC with a discussion from 2011, and this review is marked as staff. However...

Felinaex (purr / pawprints) 14:57, 1 June 2026 (UTC) Comment three WP:RSMUSIC sources have coverage: [1], [2], [3], [4]. ResonantDistortion 19:19, 2...

in WP:RSMUSIC source Punk News. Staff review on Allmusic and bio. Coverage in the Seattle Times confirming the name change. Review in WP:RSMUSIC source...

Felinaex (purr / pawprints) 14:57, 1 June 2026 (UTC) Comment three WP:RSMUSIC sources have coverage: [1], [2], [3], [4]. ResonantDistortion 19:19, 2...

04:42, 30 December 2025 (UTC) Comment two album reviews available in WP:RSMUSIC source metal.de: [2], [3]. Plus another here in powermetal.de: [4]. ResonantDistortion...

there aren't going to be reviews yet. And there's already a dedicated WP:RSMUSIC-approved source (https://exclaim.ca/amparticle/animal_collective_annou...

several articles from WP:RSMUSIC source Clash, a review in the Irish Times, also news article in Billboard, and another WP:RSMUSIC review in Pop Matters...

has one source aside from charts, and it's from a site not listed at WP:RSMUSIC. Only other source I could fine is from Noisecreep but I'm not certain...

explaining why you're claiming that, and again let me mention the entries at WP:RSMUSIC which I brought up below. Those sources are all standard for usage in the...

reliable at WP:RSMUSIC. Here's another: [2] from a source called UDiscoverMusic, which has not been analyzed as reliable or unreliable at WP:RSMUSIC. There might...

September 2025 (UTC) Comment Keep The band received reviews in at least two WP:RSMUSIC sources ([1], [2]). toweli (talk) 07:35, 15 September 2025 (UTC) Hi Towelli...

Times, CNET, Wired and Magnet alone should do the job per WP:RSP and WP:RSMUSIC (and those lists aren't exhaustive). Paulie302 (talk) 13:38, 16 December...

detail, to the subject, and have a consensus for being reliable per WP:RSMUSIC. Sergecross73 msg me 20:58, 6 July 2022 (UTC) The above discussion is preserved...

provides significant coverage, does not have the genre sidebar, and per WP:RSMUSIC regarding AllMusic, "Biography/reviews prose are reliable, but do not use...

I found reviews from Allmusic and Rock Hard, both are reliable per WP:RSMUSIC. There's also a couple in the article that I've never heard of. Honestly...

January 2025 (UTC) Keep A quick search identified 3 critical reviews in WP:RSMUSIC sources: Punknews, Exclaim!, Allmusic. Subject appears to be notable per...

reviews from AllMusic & RapReviews which, whilst both being listed at WP:RSMUSIC, aren't quite enough to warrant the album having a standalone article....

2026 (UTC) Keep passes WP:MUSICBIO#1 with non-trivial coverage from WP:RSMUSIC sources: [1], [2], [3], [4]. Citations added to the article. ResonantDistortion...

—LastJabberwocky (Rrarr) 12:46, 25 May 2025 (UTC) Comment There is also an WP:RSMUSIC staff bio on Allmusic here. ResonantDistortion 17:27, 25 May 2025 (UTC)...

review in WP:RSMUSIC source Metal Hammer, a short staff-written band history on Allmusic, a news article with secondary analysis from WP:RSMUSIC source New...

Rolling Stone, and Entertainment Weekly are all reliable sources per WP:RSMUSIC. Given the characteristics above, and the fact that the album was released...

Keep Sourcing below meets the WP:GNG. They are reliable sources per WP:RSMUSIC. https://loudwire.com/3teeth-metawar-american-landfill/ https://www.revolvermag...

(UTC) Keep meets WP:MUSICBIO#1 per secondary critical reviews in 3 WP:RSMUSIC sources:[1],[2],[3]. ResonantDistortion 09:40, 19 September 2025 (UTC)...

links. The listed sources does not seem reliable and are not found here WP:RSMUSIC. dxneo (talk) 13:55, 25 September 2023 (UTC) The above discussion is preserved...

to Trinity (My Dying Bride album). The track is highlighted in this WP:RSMUSIC album review of the proposed target [1]. ResonantDistortion 10:51, 1 March...

✎ 05:03, 9 May 2025 (UTC) Keep Seems to pass WP:NMUSIC. Examples of WP:RSMUSIC secondary coverage include a staff bio on Allmusic [1], album review in...

source for artist biographies, as can be seen from its inclusion at WP:RSMUSIC. Their review of his debut album is also good coverage. The Pitchfork source...

"meaningless or circular". The coverage is from known reliable sources (see WP:RSMUSIC entries for Dummy, Fact, NPR Music, RA, and TMT) and it's all regarding...

RapReviews piece Chaotic Enby linked (regarded as a reliable source per RSMUSIC). No appearance of an NALBUM pass. QuietHere (talk | contributions) 06:31...

See citations in the article, and further coverage when searching 3 WP:RSMUSIC sources DJ Mag, Mixmag, and Billboard. ResonantDistortion 16:14, 25 April...

biography that contains a paragraph on the demos. Reliable site per WP:RSMUSIC but it alone is not enough for notability. Suggesting a redirection to...

Further to the RS coverage identified above, there are two further WP:RSMUSIC sources including Mixmag and a bylined single review in DJ Mag. Furthermore...

-goth-angel-sinner-ep-when-i-lie-video-906094/ All are reliable per WP:RSMUSIC. And there's more out there too. Pretty easily meets the GNG. Sergecross73...

2025 (UTC) Keep Meets WP:MUSICBIO#1 per secondary reviews and bios in WP:RSMUSIC publications: [1], [2], [3], [4], [5], [6]. ResonantDistortion 15:50, 18...

You'd want to find something like coverage from music publications at WP:RSMUSIC or charting on something from WP:GOODCHARTS. Sergecross73 msg me 12:26...

review in HX Magazine via TWL, bylined coverage in WP:RSMUSIC source DJ Mag, and another WP:RSMUSIC source calls the subject a "New York Legend" Mixmag...

WP:NOTRSMUSIC, and the other of which (Buzzbands) has no consensus at RSMUSIC. Complete failure of WP:NOTABILITY, just because it was established by...

WP:BEFORE from the nominator. Leaning Keep per coverage in reliable WP:RSMUSIC sources that all together look form a claim of notability per WP:BASIC...

January 2025 (UTC) Sputnikmusic review is a user review, thus ineligible per RSMUSIC, and I can't say I'm confident in RoughEdge. But both AllMusic and Exclaim...

AFD. The subject is covered at the target with text that is cited to WP:RSMUSIC secondary coverage. ResonantDistortion 22:39, 4 September 2025 (UTC) I...

three are from WP:RSMUSIC. I found one from the website "Bring the Noise" too that I thought we considered reliable, but it's not at RSMUSIC so I could be...

sources used from "Gay City News" and "PopCrush" which are not reliable (WP:RSMUSIC). The NME and Billboard sources fall short of what is required to be "independent...

sources are some weak "download/listen" links which clearly does not pass WP:RSMUSIC. ihateneo (talk) 02:23, 21 September 2023 (UTC) Note - See also Wikipedia:Articles...

30 November 2025 (UTC) Keep: Arguably passes WP:NMUSIC#1 in multiple WP:RSMUSIC sources, including Pitchfork and Spin (and that's not counting the additional...

subject has non-trivial coverage, two album reviews, at the Metal.de WP:RSMUSIC source: [1] and [2]. Not sufficient to meet WP:MUSICBIO by itself, but...

Keep Further to the Blabbermouth coverage, there are at least 3 more WP:RSMUSIC publications covering the subject: staff bio & staff review on Allmusic:...

TWL) Fails WP:NSONG, virtually no significant coverage of the song in WP:RSMUSIC sources. Before I removed them, most of the sources were WP:USERG fansites...

it, avoid USERG sources, uses sources in the list of sources per the WP:RSMUSIC. Bungle nominated it the article for deletion for repeatedly recreating...

multiple album reviews; multiple album reviews in CMJ, and Exclaim!, an WP:RSMUSIC, called them the "kings of negative energy rock". A quick search identified...

per WP:MUSICBIO#1 - subject has sigcov album reviews in at least four WP:RSMUSIC sources: Pop Matters, Quietus, Punknews and Ox-fanzine. Also has a claim...

(Rrarr) 08:48, 5 May 2025 (UTC) Keep meets WP:MUSICBIO per multiple WP:RSMUSIC secondary coverage including Billboard:[4][5], CMJ:[6], Chicago Tribune:[7]...

the article. There are further indications, in coverage such as this WP:RSMUSIC review, and in this Punk Planet review, and in this UTV review, that the...

WP:MUSICBIO#1. The subject has attracted secondary coverage in a number of WP:RSMUSIC sources stretching over a period from 1989 to 2016. I have added several...

obviously notable, at least four reviews from reliable sources per WP:RSMUSIC: Allmusic, Beats Per Minute, Consequence of Sound, Pitchfork Media. --Mika1h...

editorial oversight as Lil-unique1 pointed out, and do not comply with WP:RSMUSIC. --Ashleyyoursmile! 16:03, 22 March 2021 (UTC) The above discussion is...

XXL is considered generally reliable at WP:RSMUSIC[7], AllHipHop is considered generally reliable at WP:RSMUSIC[8]. TMZ is considered questionable at WP:RSP...

Schützenpanzer (Talk) 15:37, 5 May 2026 (UTC) Keep per WP:MUSICBIO#1. Further WP:RSMUSIC coverage: Observer, Line of Best Fit, The Fader. ResonantDistortion 15:59...

secondary coverage in multiple sources. This criteria is fulfilled by 3 WP:RSMUSIC critical review articles: metal.de, Rock Hard, Metal Injection. ResonantDistortion...

failed to find coverage, including in the Christian sources listed as RSMUSIC. QuietHere (talk | contributions) 20:53, 26 December 2024 (UTC) Redirect...

21:47, 5 February 2021 (UTC) The source you cited is not considered WP:RSMUSIC. HĐ (talk) 04:58, 7 February 2021 (UTC) The above discussion is preserved...

WeirdNAnnoyed (talk) 22:27, 26 February 2025 (UTC) Comment There is a sigcov WP:RSMUSIC staff review available here on punknews. It's a start, but not quite sufficient...

Spiderone(Talk to Spider) 13:29, 5 October 2025 (UTC) Keep Secondary Coverage in WP:RSMUSIC sources: [1], [2], [3], [4]. ResonantDistortion 15:00, 5 October 2025 (UTC)...

has found a number of reviews in a variety of sources, some of which are RSMUSIC. Sufficient presented here to presume notability. ResonantDistortion 23:36...

all I could find and Flaunt is not on the pretty extensive list at WP:RSMUSIC. And I also laughed at the 1979 (though it's certainly a typo), but definitely...

a standard search engine, coverage has been identified in multiple WP:RSMUSIC sources: [1], [2], [3], [4], [5], [6], [7], [8]. Further coverage at EBSCOhost 92471639...

because it's a user review, and that's not acceptable, as stated by WP:RSMUSIC. Richard3120 (talk) 14:30, 11 July 2020 (UTC) The sputnikmusic.com entry...

and Metal Hammer are pretty mainstream publications and reliable per WP:RSMUSIC. We generally have similar thoughts on album notability, so I was a bit...

Pitchfork, PopMatters, and Loud and Quiet, all three of which appear on RSMUSIC. QuietHere (talk | contributions) 06:01, 17 June 2024 (UTC) Also appears...

Oaktree b (talk) 00:36, 24 February 2024 (UTC) Comment There is an WP:RSMUSIC review of Cornetts work in this Allmusic staff review [3]. Still not sufficient...

CNBC piece is not churnalism and Bandcamp Daily is independent per WP:RSMUSIC; the bar here is being raised artificially sky-high, and any reasonable...

Tool and other bands. The article includes listing or each band at WP:RSMUSIC Allmusic and Rolling Stone with D'Amour as a founder, it also has interviews...

WCQuidditch ☎ ✎ 02:25, 22 May 2026 (UTC) Comment there's also sigcov in this WP:RSMUSIC review: [1]. ResonantDistortion 06:35, 23 May 2026 (UTC) And Plan B magazine...

—LastJabberwocky (Rrarr) 20:22, 9 April 2026 (UTC) Keep Further coverage in WP:RSMUSIC source Muzik magazine is available: [5], [6], [7], [8], and [9]. There...

by AllMusic: [1] and RapReviews.com: [2], both reliable sources per WP:RSMUSIC. --Mika1h (talk) 15:12, 5 November 2025 (UTC) There's also a review in...

staff byline, of the subjects album does contribute to notability per WP:RSMUSIC. Cited in the article are 5 non-trivial critical reviews of the subjects...

(UTC) Keep I have identified further sourcing - 2 critical reviews in WP:RSMUSIC Mixmag, including one of his remix productions being chosen as "Tune of...

com/2014/12/ha-reform-rock-rio/ Mortyman (talk) 18:25, 20 October 2021 (UTC) WP:RSMUSIC has a list of a lot of commonly acceptable sources. Generally speaking...

10 August 2025 (UTC) Comment With a quick search I identified two WP:RSMUSIC articles with non-trivial coverage: Sputnik staff review and Allmusic staff...

Spider) 12:28, 11 December 2025 (UTC) Comment There's a staff review in WP:RSMUSIC source Punk News, which counts towards notability. Further short secondary...

and album review identified by User:doomsdayer520, there are further WP:RSMUSIC album reviews per : Allmusic: Review of debut album Mistress Sputnikmusic:...

StabroTalk • Contribs 04:39, 18 January 2025 (UTC) Keep A quick search identified WP:RSMUSIC critical reviews:[2], [3], and coverage in Pitchfork: [4] stating one of...

Furthermore, this band also has a profile page in Rock Hard, which is an WP:RSMUSIC, featuring multiple album reviews and articles (even if paywalled). See...

17:35, 20 February 2026 (UTC) Keep per WP:MUSICBIO. According to this WP:RSMUSIC staff review in Allmusic, the subject had two albums in the Billboard 200...

articles mentioned, there is this 1995 album review in (paywalled) WP:RSMUSIC source Rock Hard, a short paragraph in this book published in 1998, and...

100% sure on is the Sputnikmusic review (It's a user review, see the WP:RSMUSIC entry). The People piece is partly about the album and ostensibly exists...

and an album review, both by staff writers, which are reliable per WP:RSMUSIC. Combine those with the charting and other sources, they comfortably pass...

single in the Billboard charts Funky Little Beat #44 & [1]. Allmusic has WP:RSMUSIC staff writer coverage [2] and [3]. There are also some further critical...

All sources have a consensus for being reliable per WP:RSMUSIC, or are major entertainment publications (Variety, Entertainment Weekly...

music databases like Discog.com. No written reviews of the albums from WP:RSMUSIC either. Tutwakhamoe (talk) 22:03, 26 August 2023 (UTC) The above discussion...

Spider) 08:27, 25 January 2026 (UTC) Keep further secondary coverage in WP:RSMUSIC sources: [1], [2], [3], [4], [5]. ResonantDistortion 10:51, 25 January...

my delete vote, thanks. fx (talk) 10:36, 31 December 2025 (UTC) See WP:RSMUSIC for guidance on reliable sources for music. At least 6 of the sources listed...

a scale of 1 to 5 stars and Allmusic is listed as a reliable source WP:RSMUSIC and has given a 3-star rating to this album. Donaldd23 (talk) 18:32, 21...

album. Heartfox (talk) 07:44, 23 February 2021 (UTC) Well, I noticed WP:RSMUSIC says otherwise but that discussion was not unanimous. Something feels off...

article. It meets the WP:GNG, its has a lot of dedicated sourcing from WP:RSMUSIC-approved sources. It could use some cleanup, but its a different enough...

Americana Highways is as far as I know (bit surprised to see neither listed at RSMUSIC), but it's still a bit limited. This could be turned around though. QuietHere...

turntables and vinyl" in a reliable music source ([1]). Other WP:RS/WP:RSMUSIC coverage includes [2] and [3] and [4]. A quick look on ProQuest and there...

obviously notable, at least four reviews from reliable sources per WP:RSMUSIC: Allmusic, Beats Per Minute, Consequence of Sound, Pitchfork Media. --Mika1h...

should be plenty. Both AbsolutePunk and Alternative Press are listed at WP:RSMUSIC. QuietHere (talk | contributions) 17:00, 7 September 2023 (UTC) Relisted...

notability has been met.Nil🥝 09:58, 7 August 2025 (UTC) Keep There are WP:RSMUSIC critic reviews available per [1] and [2] and [3]+[4], three different sources...

per WP:RSMUSIC, so contributes to WP:MUSICBIO#1. Further, Muzik magazine, which has reviewed 3 of the subjects albums, is another WP:RSMUSIC source....

October 2022 (UTC) Thank you as well. I also see they have an entry at RSMUSIC. I probably should've checked more on this site before posting my submission...

notice. Thanks, Liz Read! Talk! 04:41, 25 June 2023 (UTC) Keep. Using WP:RSMUSIC to narrow to reliable sources, and excluding all interviews to keep independence...

West Coast ska revival", there is further critical coverage in another WP:RSMUSIC publication here. I have added several of the identified citations to the...

100% sure either way. The Ultimate Guitar review should be good per WP:RSMUSIC (note the UG Staff byline) and the Punknews.org review should be as well...

17 January 2026 (UTC) Comment The subject has twice appeared in the WP:RSMUSIC DJ Mag top 100 DJs poll: Korolova. Further coverage in DJ Mag here. That...

3 November 2025 (UTC) Keep per WP:MUSICBIO. Album reviews in three WP:RSMUSIC sources NME, Rock Hard, and Drowned in Sound. Furthermore significant coverage...

identified non-trivial coverage including an Allmusic staff bio (which is an WP:RSMUSIC, and is always a good sign) and three four album reviews in independent...

cited in the article. Allmusic coverage certainly counts; it meets WP:RSMUSIC it consists of staff-written review and bio. ResonantDistortion 18:12,...

source is of questionable reliability for biographical details Hmm. Per WP:RSMUSIC both biographies and reviews are reliable, but also gives the genres as...

Comment There is an Allmusic staff biography which is sigcov sourcing per WP:RSMUSIC: [1]. This profile is sigcov: Korea Herald, which is 5 years after his...

2025 (UTC) Just noting that HotNewHipHop is a reliable source, per WP:RSMUSIC. Better question is whether it's enough to establish notability. Nil🥝...

page are generally not reliable. Reviews are generally reliable. (see WP:RSMUSIC) —LastJabberwocky (Rrarr) 14:57, 12 May 2025 (UTC) Keep meets WP:MUSICBIO#1...

secondary coverage identified. Note: Staff Bio on Allmusic counts as an WP:RSMUSIC. Further note - I have !voted in the seperate discography article AfD that...

{{Music ratings}} template adopts it. Also it is a reliable source per WP:RSMUSIC. Camilasdandelions (✉️) 16:56, 1 May 2026 (UTC) First point is irrelevant...

criterion 1 precludes reviews. The references are reliable (I verified with WP:RSMUSIC), not self-published, and independent from the musician. CelestialWeevil...

is available here, and the Lollipop source is here. There is another WP:RSMUSIC review available in Ox-fanzine. ResonantDistortion 07:05, 21 April 2026...

Forever in SputnikMusic (tagged emeritus review, considered reliable by WP:RSMUSIC) [1] 1 short review of their self titled EP in HeartattaCk zine: [2] 1...

(TALK|CONTRIBS) 13:12, 15 October 2025 (UTC) Keep Further coverage available in WP:RSMUSIC source Exclaim!: [5] and [6]. ResonantDistortion 18:24, 15 October 2025...

short staff bio on Allmusic referenced in the article, which is an WP:RSMUSIC, and an album review in The Syncopated Times now cited too. The BBC website...

Atlantic306 (talk) 23:01, 31 October 2024 (UTC) Metal Injection has been on WP:RSMUSIC for a long time without any contention I can recall. It has no restrictions...

remember that it weren't one. AllMusic is considered reliable over at WP:RSMUSIC: Biography/staff reviews are reliable, but do not use sidebar, as it may...

18:25, 20 May 2023 (UTC) Is that a film thing then? It isn't listed at WP:RSMUSIC. Sergecross73 msg me 01:59, 21 May 2023 (UTC) I don't know if there have...

December 2024 (UTC) Important to note that 3family6 added Metal.de to RSMUSIC without any prior discussion, but it was removed right after with a request...

its a decade+ spanning music website, and is considered reliable per WP:RSMUSIC. To call the charting insignificant is a stretch too, considering the Electronic/Dance...

song has received widespread sigcov, in multiple sources that meet WP:RSMUSIC and WP:RSPS. As well as the Rolling Stone, Variety & BBC refs you added...

BrooklynVegan, and Pitchfork (magazine) are all listed reliable at WP:RSMUSIC. And certainly the Library Journal appears to meet RS criteria. ResonantDistortion...

explaining why you're claiming that, and again let me mention the entries at WP:RSMUSIC which I brought up below. Those sources are all standard for usage in the...

E2A: With the LA Times article and Allmusic bio (which is reliable per WP:RSMUSIC) this article has multiple sources thus meeting WP:SINGER#1.ResonantDistortion...

pages 28 to 33 on the July 2020 issue of DJ Mag: [1]. This is firmly in WP:RSMUSIC territory; with the journalist likening Wolfram to an electronic version...

per WP:RSMUSIC) Ultimate Guitar (reliable per WP:RSMUSIC) Guitar World (reliable per WP:RSINSTRUMENT), Alternative Press (reliable per WP:RSMUSIC). I'm...

sound of an ethereal world. Mixmag is independent and reliable per WP:RSMUSIC, and shows potential for meeting MUSICIO, but it's not quite sufficient...

Guitar appears to be a large and well-known website (and appears on WP:RSMUSIC), and seems to have focused on a theme that is now more apparent and developed...

Keep per Flooded’s sources, which are largely reliable sources, per WP:RSMUSIC, and are dedicated to the subject. Could use some cleanup, but it’s definitely...

available online), including under his alternate name. However - there is a WP:RSMUSIC Allmusic staff bio available, which is both non-trivial coverage and confirms...

industry. Atisnakebite (talk) 05:45, 16 April 2025 (UTC) Comment Further RSMUSIC coverage available: a staff bio on Allmusic: [4], a staff review on Allmusic:...

didn't just chart, it topped multiple charts and there's no shortage of WP:RSMUSIC approved sources writing dedicated coverage centered around it. Sergecross73...

discussion of the band. Ink19 hasn't been subject to a formal discussion at RSMUSIC, but it is a longstanding publication I have used frequently for independent...

but both NME and Rolling Stone are considered reliable sources per WP:RSMUSIC, and long running print magazines in the music world. Sergecross73 msg...

and there does appear some coverage to build an article, including an WP:RSMUSIC staff bio on Allmusic. ResonantDistortion 11:05, 6 July 2025 (UTC) AllMusic...

contribute towards notability; PopMatters is listed as generally reliable at WP:RSMUSIC. The problem is that WP:NALBUM#1 would require multiple independent RS...

Felinaex (purr / pawprints) 14:57, 1 June 2026 (UTC) Comment three WP:RSMUSIC sources have coverage: [18], [19], [20], [21]. ResonantDistortion 19:19...

com/music/taylor-swift-reputation/ Listed among reliable sources at WP:RSMUSIC. Reuters acknowledged Slant among the reliable side of online publications...

WCQuidditch ☎ ✎ 02:25, 22 May 2026 (UTC) Comment there's also sigcov in this WP:RSMUSIC review: [22]. ResonantDistortion 06:35, 23 May 2026 (UTC) And Plan B magazine...

sites are all independent coverage, with at least four being listed at WP:RSMUSIC so that's already enough for an easy pass. QuietHere (talk) 08:15, 7 January...

note that Tiny Mix Tapes, Exclaim!, and PopMatters all have entries at WP:RSMUSIC and would be reliable coverage for an album article if someone wants to...

WCQuidditch ☎ ✎ 02:25, 22 May 2026 (UTC) Comment there's also sigcov in this WP:RSMUSIC review: [27]. ResonantDistortion 06:35, 23 May 2026 (UTC) And Plan B magazine...

Both of those publications are on our list of reliable sources at WP:RSMUSIC. I can't decide whether she just about scrapes WP:MUSICBIO - that's why...

professional journalists. There’s a consensus for it being reliable at WP:RSMUSIC. We don’t deem entire publications unusable just because someone disagrees...

sites are all independent coverage, with at least four being listed at WP:RSMUSIC so that's already enough for an easy pass. QuietHere (talk) 08:15, 7 January...

All dedicated to the subject. All considered reliable per WP:RSMUSIC. Sergecross73 msg me 19:50, 8 June 2022 (UTC) Information has to go beyond...

other info WP:RSMUSIC ✘ No https://loudwire.com/stereo-satellite-mike-orlando-life-after-adrenaline-mob-crash-music-saved-me/ WP:RSMUSIC ✔ Yes https://loudwire...

the side bar, which from my understanding, is acceptable according to WP:RSMUSIC as I'm not sourcing a genre from the side bar (for reference, it is the...

sources writing dedicated articles about the album, all sources from WP:RSMUSIC. (2015) Exclaim (2017) DJ Mag (2018) Billboard (2018) MTV (2018) Forbes...

WCQuidditch ☎ ✎ 02:25, 22 May 2026 (UTC) Comment there's also sigcov in this WP:RSMUSIC review: [28]. ResonantDistortion 06:35, 23 May 2026 (UTC) And Plan B magazine...

in the industry. I've never heard of any of them. None are listed at WP:RSMUSIC or even WP:NOTRSMUSIC. Not that they have to be, in just saying, they're...

Guitar appears to be a large and well-known website (and appears on WP:RSMUSIC), and seems to have focused on a theme that is now more apparent and developed...

it, avoid USERG sources, uses sources in the list of sources per the WP:RSMUSIC. Bungle nominated it the article for deletion for repeatedly recreating...

in the industry. I've never heard of any of them. None are listed at WP:RSMUSIC or even WP:NOTRSMUSIC. Not that they have to be, in just saying, they're...

a reliable source? Punknews.org is considered a reliable source at WP:RSMUSIC Per The Ringer's about us page, they have an editorial staff, with an editor-in-chief...

usually where music sourcing questions end up since that project hosts WP:RSMUSIC. I'm personally not any more convinced than Richard is but maybe we're...

Eumerus (talk) 08:22, 13 July 2024 (UTC) Thanks for the review! I suppose WP:RSMUSIC is the closest thing we have.--NØ 17:05, 13 July 2024 (UTC) Jo-Jo Eumerus...

review is a staff review and JFH is on the reliable sources list at WP:RSMUSIC. I'm surprised there is so much resistance in this discussion; I really...

08:19, 26 March 2023 (UTC) For what it's worth Exclaim! is listed at WP:RSMUSIC and does have an editorial team([14]). Also "Sarajevo Times piece ... is...

2025 (UTC) Keep per WP:MUSICBIO#1. Multiple sources, all listed at WP:RSMUSIC, all have non-trivial coverage: Allmusic has sigcov with a band bio and...

--NØ 06:20, 9 April 2021 (UTC) What is the reliability of The Fader? WP:RSMUSIC considers it reliable and Larry Fitzmaurice, the author, has written for...

album. Heartfox (talk) 07:44, 23 February 2021 (UTC) Well, I noticed WP:RSMUSIC says otherwise but that discussion was not unanimous. Something feels off...

CBS News, Chicago Tribune) and music sources vetted as reliable at WP:RSMUSIC. Additionally, the subject is discussed collectively by reliable sources...

Rolling Stone, and Entertainment Weekly are all reliable sources per WP:RSMUSIC. Given the characteristics above, and the fact that the album was released...

reliable at WP:RSMUSIC. Here's another: [20] from a source called UDiscoverMusic, which has not been analyzed as reliable or unreliable at WP:RSMUSIC. There might...

"meaningless or circular". The coverage is from known reliable sources (see WP:RSMUSIC entries for Dummy, Fact, NPR Music, RA, and TMT) and it's all regarding...

Tool and other bands. The article includes listing or each band at WP:RSMUSIC Allmusic and Rolling Stone with D'Amour as a founder, it also has interviews...

because it's a user review, and that's not acceptable, as stated by WP:RSMUSIC. Richard3120 (talk) 14:30, 11 July 2020 (UTC) The sputnikmusic.com entry...

and Metal Hammer are pretty mainstream publications and reliable per WP:RSMUSIC. We generally have similar thoughts on album notability, so I was a bit...

-goth-angel-sinner-ep-when-i-lie-video-906094/ All are reliable per WP:RSMUSIC. And there's more out there too. Pretty easily meets the GNG. Sergecross73...

I found reviews from Allmusic and Rock Hard, both are reliable per WP:RSMUSIC. There's also a couple in the article that I've never heard of. Honestly...

its a reliable source. I've never heard of it, and its not listed at WP:RSMUSIC (which isn't required, I just mean I don't have any reference point on...

02:11, 8 September 2021 (UTC) To further support the site's notability, WP:RSMUSIC lists it as a generally reliable source. Aoba47 (talk) 02:30, 8 September...

editor and web site owner for over 47 years. Thank you for your work. RSMusic web guy (talk) 18:34, 2 November 2019 (UTC) how do i submit my articles...

has one source aside from charts, and it's from a site not listed at WP:RSMUSIC. Only other source I could fine is from Noisecreep but I'm not certain...

All dedicated to the subject. All considered reliable per WP:RSMUSIC. Sergecross73 msg me 19:50, 8 June 2022 (UTC) Information has to go beyond...

detail, to the subject, and have a consensus for being reliable per WP:RSMUSIC. Sergecross73 msg me 20:58, 6 July 2022 (UTC) The above discussion is preserved...

editorial oversight as Lil-unique1 pointed out, and do not comply with WP:RSMUSIC. --Ashleyyoursmile! 16:03, 22 March 2021 (UTC) The above discussion is...

21:47, 5 February 2021 (UTC) The source you cited is not considered WP:RSMUSIC. HĐ (talk) 04:58, 7 February 2021 (UTC) The above discussion is preserved...

Keep Sourcing below meets the WP:GNG. They are reliable sources per WP:RSMUSIC. https://loudwire.com/3teeth-metawar-american-landfill/ https://www.revolvermag...

source for artist biographies, as can be seen from its inclusion at WP:RSMUSIC. Their review of his debut album is also good coverage. The Pitchfork source...

October 2022 (UTC) Thank you as well. I also see they have an entry at RSMUSIC. I probably should've checked more on this site before posting my submission...

provides significant coverage, does not have the genre sidebar, and per WP:RSMUSIC regarding AllMusic, "Biography/reviews prose are reliable, but do not use...

although it may warrant more investigation if you agree. I see it is on WP:RSMUSIC. Also, Trainor has never interviewed with this publication or interacted...

All sources have a consensus for being reliable per WP:RSMUSIC, or are major entertainment publications (Variety, Entertainment Weekly...

You'd want to find something like coverage from music publications at WP:RSMUSIC or charting on something from WP:GOODCHARTS. Sergecross73 msg me 12:26...

its a decade+ spanning music website, and is considered reliable per WP:RSMUSIC. To call the charting insignificant is a stretch too, considering the Electronic/Dance...

sources writing dedicated articles about the album, all sources from WP:RSMUSIC. (2015) Exclaim (2017) DJ Mag (2018) Billboard (2018) MTV (2018) Forbes...

100% sure on is the Sputnikmusic review (It's a user review, see the WP:RSMUSIC entry). The People piece is partly about the album and ostensibly exists...

com/2014/12/ha-reform-rock-rio/ Mortyman (talk) 18:25, 20 October 2021 (UTC) WP:RSMUSIC has a list of a lot of commonly acceptable sources. Generally speaking...

criterion 1 precludes reviews. The references are reliable (I verified with WP:RSMUSIC), not self-published, and independent from the musician. CelestialWeevil...

a scale of 1 to 5 stars and Allmusic is listed as a reliable source WP:RSMUSIC and has given a 3-star rating to this album. Donaldd23 (talk) 18:32, 21...

note that Tiny Mix Tapes, Exclaim!, and PopMatters all have entries at WP:RSMUSIC and would be reliable coverage for an album article if someone wants to...

at WP:RSMUSIC would indeed be helpful, in my opinion. Oroborvs (talk) 19:01, 17 July 2022 (UTC) Worth noting that other websites listed on RSMUSIC also...

usually where music sourcing questions end up since that project hosts WP:RSMUSIC. I'm personally not any more convinced than Richard is but maybe we're...

dedicated articles by extremely reputable sources approved by WP:VG/S, WP:RSMUSIC, and WP:RSP, and that's all that the GNG requires. Sergecross73 msg me...

other info WP:RSMUSIC ✘ No https://loudwire.com/stereo-satellite-mike-orlando-life-after-adrenaline-mob-crash-music-saved-me/ WP:RSMUSIC ✔ Yes https://loudwire...

Keep per Flooded’s sources, which are largely reliable sources, per WP:RSMUSIC, and are dedicated to the subject. Could use some cleanup, but it’s definitely...

but both NME and Rolling Stone are considered reliable sources per WP:RSMUSIC, and long running print magazines in the music world. Sergecross73 msg...

mentioned, Consequence of Sound is designated as a reliable source at WP:RSMUSIC. Metacritic also uses CoS reviews for their weighted averages, as described...

your best course of action would be to find other reliable sources (WP:RSMUSIC is a good starting point) that classify the song differently, and then...

December 2022 (UTC) 4) AnyDecentMusic? is listed as reliable over at WP:RSMUSIC (listed there by this 2016 Discussion). – zmbro (talk) (cont) 22:57, 30...

e. should AllMusic no longer be designated a reliable source under WP:RSMUSIC?) and then filed a report, which User:EdJohnston accepted without vetting...

has been considered reliable (albeit with caveats) for many years at WP:RSMUSIC. I'm not saying that can't change, but I'm saying we're going to want to...

(talk) 23:25, 27 June 2023 (UTC) PopMatters is considered reliable per WP:RSMUSIC. They're a major publication in the music world. I didn't think they did...

Spin, and Vibe. Spin and Vibe are listed as "reliable sources" at WP:RSMUSIC, and Stereogum looks very similar to these two publications, with a comparable...

I think you should amend your source analysis table, lest people think RSMUSIC lists Billboard Argentina as a reliable source. When you take out the rumors...

commentary. The Fader is considered a reliable source according to WP:RSMUSIC and the author, Raphael Helfand, has contributed to the publication Pitchfork...

October 2024 (UTC) It's a reliable source for Music articles, listed at WP:RSMUSIC. It was also selected by The Independent as one of the best music websites...

review and it's considered generally reliable for music articles per WP:RSMUSIC. Can you please clarify further why would it need to be removed? Medxvo...

02:11, 8 September 2021 (UTC) To further support the site's notability, WP:RSMUSIC lists it as a generally reliable source. Aoba47 (talk) 02:30, 8 September...

own lists. I linked to it in my comment above, but to clarify, see WP:RSMUSIC and WP:NOTRSMUSIC for music lists, WP:VG/S for the video game one, and...

reviews are considered reliable to use, both album and song reviews. See WP:RSMUSIC – zmbro (talk) (cont) 16:19, 31 October 2025 (UTC) Closing note: This candidate...

Swift album)/addition1. This publication does not have an entry at WP:RSMUSIC nor RSP. The publication appears to have gone dormant in 2016 but is routinely...

December 2022 (UTC) 4) AnyDecentMusic? is listed as reliable over at WP:RSMUSIC (listed there by this 2016 Discussion). – zmbro (talk) (cont) 22:57, 30...

I think you should amend your source analysis table, lest people think RSMUSIC lists Billboard Argentina as a reliable source. When you take out the rumors...

is an WP:RSMUSIC source: [19], [20], [21]. Staff reviews in Punknews are valid per WP:RSMUSIC: [22], [23], [24]. Exclaim! is another WP:RSMUSIC source:...

listacle entry No Binaural [10] Yes Yes. No mention of source at Wikipedia:RSMUSIC or Wikipedia:RSPLIST but appears to meet RS. Yes Femme Metal Webzine [11]...

WP:BEFORE from the nominator. Leaning Keep per coverage in reliable WP:RSMUSIC sources that all together look form a claim of notability per WP:BASIC...

com/music/taylor-swift-reputation/ Listed among reliable sources at WP:RSMUSIC. Reuters acknowledged Slant among the reliable side of online publications...

refocused the statement, and attributed to Pitchfork, a reliable source per WP:RSMUSIC. I'm unsure of mentioning apparently non-notable concert venues by name...

source is of questionable reliability for biographical details Hmm. Per WP:RSMUSIC both biographies and reviews are reliable, but also gives the genres as...

the side bar, which from my understanding, is acceptable according to WP:RSMUSIC as I'm not sourcing a genre from the side bar (for reference, it is the...

Kendrick Lamar's Super Bowl Show". Complex. Retrieved October 26, 2025. WP:RSMUSIC biographically insignificant info for an encyclopedia ✘ No Jynxzi (February...

--NØ 06:20, 9 April 2021 (UTC) What is the reliability of The Fader? WP:RSMUSIC considers it reliable and Larry Fitzmaurice, the author, has written for...

failed to find coverage, including in the Christian sources listed as RSMUSIC. QuietHere (talk | contributions) 20:53, 26 December 2024 (UTC) Redirect...

BrooklynVegan, and Pitchfork (magazine) are all listed reliable at WP:RSMUSIC. And certainly the Library Journal appears to meet RS criteria. ResonantDistortion...

music publication, based on how discussions typically go for entries on WP:RSMUSIC. I feel that at this point, it would be more beneficial that someone with...

there aren't going to be reviews yet. And there's already a dedicated WP:RSMUSIC-approved source (https://exclaim.ca/amparticle/animal_collective_annou...

review in WP:RSMUSIC source Metal Hammer, a short staff-written band history on Allmusic, a news article with secondary analysis from WP:RSMUSIC source New...

sources are some weak "download/listen" links which clearly does not pass WP:RSMUSIC. ihateneo (talk) 02:23, 21 September 2023 (UTC) Note - See also Wikipedia:Articles...

(Rrarr) 08:48, 5 May 2025 (UTC) Keep meets WP:MUSICBIO per multiple WP:RSMUSIC secondary coverage including Billboard:[44][45], CMJ:[46], Chicago Tribune:[47]...

Morwen (talk) 19:59, 20 May 2026 (UTC) Both are listed as reliable at WP:RSMUSIC. Obviously everything is contextual as far as gossip, controversial statements...

Spider) 12:28, 11 December 2025 (UTC) Comment There's a staff review in WP:RSMUSIC source Punk News, which counts towards notability. Further short secondary...

per WP:RSMUSIC, so contributes to WP:MUSICBIO#1. Further, Muzik magazine, which has reviewed 3 of the subjects albums, is another WP:RSMUSIC source....

refocused the statement, and attributed to Pitchfork, a reliable source per WP:RSMUSIC. I'm unsure of mentioning apparently non-notable concert venues by name...

cited in the article. Allmusic coverage certainly counts; it meets WP:RSMUSIC it consists of staff-written review and bio. ResonantDistortion 18:12,...

September 2025 (UTC) Comment Keep The band received reviews in at least two WP:RSMUSIC sources ([87], [88]). toweli (talk) 07:35, 15 September 2025 (UTC) Hi Towelli...

in WP:RSMUSIC source Punk News. Staff review on Allmusic and bio. Coverage in the Seattle Times confirming the name change. Review in WP:RSMUSIC source...

birthday at DJ Paul, due to it being designated as a reliable source per WP:RSMUSIC, but I self-reverted to bring the source here since I am unsure about whether...

Forever in SputnikMusic (tagged emeritus review, considered reliable by WP:RSMUSIC) [49] 1 short review of their self titled EP in HeartattaCk zine: [50]...

sound of an ethereal world. Mixmag is independent and reliable per WP:RSMUSIC, and shows potential for meeting MUSICIO, but it's not quite sufficient...

(band) – User:Frost: Special:Diff/1293577118 Y | Ref acceptable per WP:RSMUSIC. Tag doesn't follow MOS:ORDER. Nobody (talk) 06:24, 13 June 2025 (UTC)...

Times, CNET, Wired and Magnet alone should do the job per WP:RSP and WP:RSMUSIC (and those lists aren't exhaustive). Paulie302 (talk) 13:38, 16 December...

17 October 2023 (UTC) For what it's worth, Metal Storm is listed on WP:RSMUSIC with a discussion from 2011, and this review is marked as staff. However...

is considered generally reliable at WP:RSMUSIC[21], AllHipHop is considered generally reliable at WP:RSMUSIC[22]. TMZ is considered questionable at WP:RSP...

articles mentioned, there is this 1995 album review in (paywalled) WP:RSMUSIC source Rock Hard, a short paragraph in this book published in 1998, and...

RapReviews piece Chaotic Enby linked (regarded as a reliable source per RSMUSIC). No appearance of an NALBUM pass. QuietHere (talk | contributions) 06:31...

obviously notable, at least four reviews from reliable sources per WP:RSMUSIC: Allmusic, Beats Per Minute, Consequence of Sound, Pitchfork Media. --Mika1h...

review in HX Magazine via TWL, bylined coverage in WP:RSMUSIC source DJ Mag, and another WP:RSMUSIC source calls the subject a "New York Legend" Mixmag...

several articles from WP:RSMUSIC source Clash, a review in the Irish Times, also news article in Billboard, and another WP:RSMUSIC review in Pop Matters...

17:35, 20 February 2026 (UTC) Keep per WP:MUSICBIO. According to this WP:RSMUSIC staff review in Allmusic, the subject had two albums in the Billboard 200...

04:42, 30 December 2025 (UTC) Comment two album reviews available in WP:RSMUSIC source metal.de: [7], [8]. Plus another here in powermetal.de: [9]. ResonantDistortion...

notice. Thanks, Liz Read! Talk! 04:41, 25 June 2023 (UTC) Keep. Using WP:RSMUSIC to narrow to reliable sources, and excluding all interviews to keep independence...

reviews at SputnikMusic are acceptable to use with attribution, per WP:RSMUSIC. One area I have minor concerns about, however, is the use of these reviews...

Spiderone(Talk to Spider) 13:29, 5 October 2025 (UTC) Keep Secondary Coverage in WP:RSMUSIC sources: [34], [35], [36], [37]. ResonantDistortion 15:00, 5 October 2025...

WCQuidditch ☎ ✎ 02:25, 22 May 2026 (UTC) Comment there's also sigcov in this WP:RSMUSIC review: [28]. ResonantDistortion 06:35, 23 May 2026 (UTC) And Plan B magazine...

three are from WP:RSMUSIC. I found one from the website "Bring the Noise" too that I thought we considered reliable, but it's not at RSMUSIC so I could be...

Pitchfork, PopMatters, and Loud and Quiet, all three of which appear on RSMUSIC. QuietHere (talk | contributions) 06:01, 17 June 2024 (UTC) Also appears...

—LastJabberwocky (Rrarr) 20:22, 9 April 2026 (UTC) Keep Further coverage in WP:RSMUSIC source Muzik magazine is available: [19], [20], [21], [22], and [23]. There...

—LastJabberwocky (Rrarr) 12:46, 25 May 2025 (UTC) Comment There is also an WP:RSMUSIC staff bio on Allmusic here. ResonantDistortion 17:27, 25 May 2025 (UTC)...

available online), including under his alternate name. However - there is a WP:RSMUSIC Allmusic staff bio available, which is both non-trivial coverage and confirms...

100% sure either way. The Ultimate Guitar review should be good per WP:RSMUSIC (note the UG Staff byline) and the Punknews.org review should be as well...

Furthermore, this band also has a profile page in Rock Hard, which is an WP:RSMUSIC, featuring multiple album reviews and articles (even if paywalled). See...

See citations in the article, and further coverage when searching 3 WP:RSMUSIC sources DJ Mag, Mixmag, and Billboard. ResonantDistortion 16:14, 25 April...

article. It meets the WP:GNG, its has a lot of dedicated sourcing from WP:RSMUSIC-approved sources. It could use some cleanup, but its a different enough...

reliable/unreliable sources. WP:VG has WP:VG/S, the music projects have WP:RSMUSIC, etc. They can be a good reference point for this sort of thing, though...

and there does appear some coverage to build an article, including an WP:RSMUSIC staff bio on Allmusic. ResonantDistortion 11:05, 6 July 2025 (UTC) AllMusic...

music databases like Discog.com. No written reviews of the albums from WP:RSMUSIC either. Tutwakhamoe (talk) 22:03, 26 August 2023 (UTC) The above discussion...

contribute towards notability; PopMatters is listed as generally reliable at WP:RSMUSIC. The problem is that WP:NALBUM#1 would require multiple independent RS...

(talk) 23:25, 27 June 2023 (UTC) PopMatters is considered reliable per WP:RSMUSIC. They're a major publication in the music world. I didn't think they did...

30 November 2025 (UTC) Keep: Arguably passes WP:NMUSIC#1 in multiple WP:RSMUSIC sources, including Pitchfork and Spin (and that's not counting the additional...

genres, and user reviews. Binksternet (talk) 00:44, 9 August 2025 (UTC) WP:RSMUSIC outlines the current consensus. Sergecross73 msg me 00:52, 9 August 2025...

reliable in regards to music, though it doesn't list any discussions: WP:RSMUSIC. I imagine based on that it's reliable for gaming and music, but I agree...

didn't just chart, it topped multiple charts and there's no shortage of WP:RSMUSIC approved sources writing dedicated coverage centered around it. Sergecross73...

has found a number of reviews in a variety of sources, some of which are RSMUSIC. Sufficient presented here to presume notability. ResonantDistortion 23:36...

Atlantic306 (talk) 23:01, 31 October 2024 (UTC) Metal Injection has been on WP:RSMUSIC for a long time without any contention I can recall. It has no restrictions...

review is a staff review and JFH is on the reliable sources list at WP:RSMUSIC. I'm surprised there is so much resistance in this discussion; I really...

2025 (UTC) Just noting that HotNewHipHop is a reliable source, per WP:RSMUSIC. Better question is whether it's enough to establish notability. Nil🥝...

18:25, 20 May 2023 (UTC) Is that a film thing then? It isn't listed at WP:RSMUSIC. Sergecross73 msg me 01:59, 21 May 2023 (UTC) I don't know if there have...

Both of those publications are on our list of reliable sources at WP:RSMUSIC. I can't decide whether she just about scrapes WP:MUSICBIO - that's why...

AllMusic: [16] and RapReviews.com: [17], both reliable sources per WP:RSMUSIC. --Mika1h (talk) 15:12, 5 November 2025 (UTC) There's also a review in...

to Trinity (My Dying Bride album). The track is highlighted in this WP:RSMUSIC album review of the proposed target [39]. ResonantDistortion 10:51, 1 March...

TWL) Fails WP:NSONG, virtually no significant coverage of the song in WP:RSMUSIC sources. Before I removed them, most of the sources were WP:USERG fansites...

2025 (UTC) Keep per WP:MUSICBIO#1. Multiple sources, all listed at WP:RSMUSIC, all have non-trivial coverage: Allmusic has sigcov with a band bio and...

08:19, 26 March 2023 (UTC) For what it's worth Exclaim! is listed at WP:RSMUSIC and does have an editorial team([59]). Also "Sarajevo Times piece ... is...

17 January 2026 (UTC) Comment The subject has twice appeared in the WP:RSMUSIC DJ Mag top 100 DJs poll: Korolova. Further coverage in DJ Mag here. That...

is available here, and the Lollipop source is here. There is another WP:RSMUSIC review available in Ox-fanzine. ResonantDistortion 07:05, 21 April 2026...

SongMeanings, which cannot be cited on Wikipedia. Music publications (see WP:RSMUSIC) might occasionally cover the song meanings of popular songs, but the number...

anything) submitted. -- Nat Gertler (talk) 14:03, 4 August 2024 (UTC) WP:RSMUSIC classifies it as reliable, but to exercise caution with WP:BLP related...

28 to 33 on the July 2020 issue of DJ Mag: [20]. This is firmly in WP:RSMUSIC territory; with the journalist likening Wolfram to an electronic version...

Keep Further to the Blabbermouth coverage, there are at least 3 more WP:RSMUSIC publications covering the subject: staff bio & staff review on Allmusic:...

E2A: With the LA Times article and Allmusic bio (which is reliable per WP:RSMUSIC) this article has multiple sources thus meeting WP:SINGER#1.ResonantDistortion...

remember that it weren't one. AllMusic is considered reliable over at WP:RSMUSIC: Biography/staff reviews are reliable, but do not use sidebar, as it may...

WP:MUSICBIO#1. The subject has attracted secondary coverage in a number of WP:RSMUSIC sources stretching over a period from 1989 to 2016. I have added several...

dedicated articles by extremely reputable sources approved by WP:VG/S, WP:RSMUSIC, and WP:RSP, and that's all that the GNG requires. Sergecross73 msg me...

✎ 05:03, 9 May 2025 (UTC) Keep Seems to pass WP:NMUSIC. Examples of WP:RSMUSIC secondary coverage include a staff bio on Allmusic [71], album review in...

CNBC piece is not churnalism and Bandcamp Daily is independent per WP:RSMUSIC; the bar here is being raised artificially sky-high, and any reasonable...

industry. Atisnakebite (talk) 05:45, 16 April 2025 (UTC) Comment Further RSMUSIC coverage available: a staff bio on Allmusic: [6], a staff review on Allmusic:...

all I could find and Flaunt is not on the pretty extensive list at WP:RSMUSIC. And I also laughed at the 1979 (though it's certainly a typo), but definitely...

CBS News, Chicago Tribune) and music sources vetted as reliable at WP:RSMUSIC. Additionally, the subject is discussed collectively by reliable sources...

reviews from AllMusic & RapReviews which, whilst both being listed at WP:RSMUSIC, aren't quite enough to warrant the album having a standalone article....

song has received widespread sigcov, in multiple sources that meet WP:RSMUSIC and WP:RSPS. As well as the Rolling Stone, Variety & BBC refs you added...

and album review identified by User:doomsdayer520, there are further WP:RSMUSIC album reviews per : Allmusic: Review of debut album Mistress Sputnikmusic:...

Americana Highways is as far as I know (bit surprised to see neither listed at RSMUSIC), but it's still a bit limited. This could be turned around though. QuietHere...

subject has non-trivial coverage, two album reviews, at the Metal.de WP:RSMUSIC source: [4] and [5]. Not sufficient to meet WP:MUSICBIO by itself, but...

West Coast ska revival", there is further critical coverage in another WP:RSMUSIC publication here. I have added several of the identified citations to the...

notability has been met.Nil🥝 09:58, 7 August 2025 (UTC) Keep There are WP:RSMUSIC critic reviews available per [68] and [69] and [70]+[71], three different...

discussion of the band. Ink19 hasn't been subject to a formal discussion at RSMUSIC, but it is a longstanding publication I have used frequently for independent...

a standard search engine, coverage has been identified in multiple WP:RSMUSIC sources: [16], [17], [18], [19], [20], [21], [22], [23]. Further coverage...

per WP:MUSICBIO#1 - subject has sigcov album reviews in at least four WP:RSMUSIC sources: Pop Matters, Quietus, Punknews and Ox-fanzine. Also has a claim...

should be plenty. Both AbsolutePunk and Alternative Press are listed at WP:RSMUSIC. QuietHere (talk | contributions) 17:00, 7 September 2023 (UTC) Relisted...

StabroTalk • Contribs 04:39, 18 January 2025 (UTC) Keep A quick search identified WP:RSMUSIC critical reviews:[70], [71], and coverage in Pitchfork: [72] stating one...

January 2025 (UTC) Sputnikmusic review is a user review, thus ineligible per RSMUSIC, and I can't say I'm confident in RoughEdge. But both AllMusic and Exclaim...

the article. There are further indications, in coverage such as this WP:RSMUSIC review, and in this Punk Planet review, and in this UTV review, that the...

page are generally not reliable. Reviews are generally reliable. (see WP:RSMUSIC) —LastJabberwocky (Rrarr) 14:57, 12 May 2025 (UTC) Keep meets WP:MUSICBIO#1...

multiple album reviews; multiple album reviews in CMJ, and Exclaim!, an WP:RSMUSIC, called them the "kings of negative energy rock". A quick search identified...

Further to the RS coverage identified above, there are two further WP:RSMUSIC sources including Mixmag and a bylined single review in DJ Mag. Furthermore...

identified non-trivial coverage including an Allmusic staff bio (which is an WP:RSMUSIC, and is always a good sign) and three four album reviews in independent...

my delete vote, thanks. fx (talk) 10:36, 31 December 2025 (UTC) See WP:RSMUSIC for guidance on reliable sources for music. At least 6 of the sources listed...

short staff bio on Allmusic referenced in the article, which is an WP:RSMUSIC, and an album review in The Syncopated Times now cited too. The BBC website...

10 August 2025 (UTC) Comment With a quick search I identified two WP:RSMUSIC articles with non-trivial coverage: Sputnik staff review and Allmusic staff...

(TALK|CONTRIBS) 13:12, 15 October 2025 (UTC) Keep Further coverage available in WP:RSMUSIC source Exclaim!: [55] and [56]. ResonantDistortion 18:24, 15 October 2025...

3 November 2025 (UTC) Keep per WP:MUSICBIO. Album reviews in three WP:RSMUSIC sources NME, Rock Hard, and Drowned in Sound. Furthermore significant coverage...

Felinaex (purr / pawprints) 14:57, 1 June 2026 (UTC) Comment three WP:RSMUSIC sources have coverage: [28], [29], [30], [31]. ResonantDistortion 19:19...

turntables and vinyl" in a reliable music source ([1]). Other WP:RS/WP:RSMUSIC coverage includes [2] and [3] and [4]. A quick look on ProQuest and there...

secondary coverage identified. Note: Staff Bio on Allmusic counts as an WP:RSMUSIC. Further note - I have !voted in the seperate discography article AfD that...

2025 (UTC) Keep Meets WP:MUSICBIO#1 per secondary reviews and bios in WP:RSMUSIC publications: [67], [68], [69], [70], [71], [72]. ResonantDistortion 15:50...

Schützenpanzer (Talk) 15:37, 5 May 2026 (UTC) Keep per WP:MUSICBIO#1. Further WP:RSMUSIC coverage: Observer, Line of Best Fit, The Fader. ResonantDistortion 15:59...

Oaktree b (talk) 00:36, 24 February 2024 (UTC) Comment There is an WP:RSMUSIC review of Cornetts work in this Allmusic staff review [3]. Still not sufficient...

biography that contains a paragraph on the demos. Reliable site per WP:RSMUSIC but it alone is not enough for notability. Suggesting a redirection to...

WP:NOTRSMUSIC, and the other of which (Buzzbands) has no consensus at RSMUSIC. Complete failure of WP:NOTABILITY, just because it was established by...

its a reliable source. I've never heard of it, and its not listed at WP:RSMUSIC (which isn't required, I just mean I don't have any reference point on...

January 2025 (UTC) Keep A quick search identified 3 critical reviews in WP:RSMUSIC sources: Punknews, Exclaim!, Allmusic. Subject appears to be notable per...

whose reliability has already been agreed upon by the community at WP:RSMUSIC (your claim that SuperDeluxeEdition is owned by record labels was a total...

(UTC) Keep meets WP:MUSICBIO#1 per secondary critical reviews in 3 WP:RSMUSIC sources:[39],[40],[41]. ResonantDistortion 09:40, 19 September 2025 (UTC)...

2026 (UTC) Keep passes WP:MUSICBIO#1 with non-trivial coverage from WP:RSMUSIC sources: [28], [29], [30], [31]. Citations added to the article. ResonantDistortion...

WeirdNAnnoyed (talk) 22:27, 26 February 2025 (UTC) Comment There is a sigcov WP:RSMUSIC staff review available here on punknews. It's a start, but not quite sufficient...

and an album review, both by staff writers, which are reliable per WP:RSMUSIC. Combine those with the charting and other sources, they comfortably pass...

single in the Billboard charts Funky Little Beat #44 & [1]. Allmusic has WP:RSMUSIC staff writer coverage [2] and [3]. There are also some further critical...

a reliable source? Punknews.org is considered a reliable source at WP:RSMUSIC Per The Ringer's about us page, they have an editorial staff, with an editor-in-chief...

reviews are considered reliable to use, both album and song reviews. See WP:RSMUSIC – zmbro (talk) (cont) 16:19, 31 October 2025 (UTC) Closing note: This candidate...

2014. It is supported by at least two sources considered reliable at WP:RSMUSIC, and two additional sources were presented during the discussion. The user...

commentary. The Fader is considered a reliable source according to WP:RSMUSIC and the author, Raphael Helfand, has contributed to the publication Pitchfork...

October 2024 (UTC) It's a reliable source for Music articles, listed at WP:RSMUSIC. It was also selected by The Independent as one of the best music websites...

although it may warrant more investigation if you agree. I see it is on WP:RSMUSIC. Also, Trainor has never interviewed with this publication or interacted...

Eumerus (talk) 08:22, 13 July 2024 (UTC) Thanks for the review! I suppose WP:RSMUSIC is the closest thing we have.--NØ 17:05, 13 July 2024 (UTC) Jo-Jo Eumerus...