DOKUMEN123.COM

Shortcuts WP:GA?WP:GA? WP:GACRWP:GACR WP:WIAGAWP:WIAGA The good article criteria are the six standards by which a good article nomination (GAN) may be...

nomination title "UE II" submarines? --PresN 06:22, 8 February 2010 (UTC) Quickfail - nomination does not include all articles, no attempt to notify the main...

(90+) (quickfail) Y valid quickfail — Golden talk 20:48, 19 August 2023 (UTC) Armadale railway station, Melbourne (982 words) (90+) (quickfail) Y valid...

found Result: Significant citation issues mean that the article meets the quickfail criteria, and thus should be delisted. ~~ AirshipJungleman29 (talk) 12:35...

guidelines for an FT. The image is also not free. --PresN 02:11, 5 February 2010 (UTC) Quickfail - per Nergaal - rst20xx (talk) 13:00, 5 February 2010 (UTC)...

criterion 2b, and satisfies criterion 3 (and arguably criterion 1) for a quickfail. UndercoverClassicist T·C 13:51, 5 October 2024 (UTC) Looks like an old...

was a quickfail that was quickfailed because there was a legitimate clean up tag in the article. Which is still there as of this comment. Quickfails (legitimate...

Completely and unequivocally improper quickfail. Courcelles 03:57, 5 October 2010 (UTC) Overturn and relist. Quickfail was improper; needs a full review....

decision to quickfail the initial GAN. The reviewer cited the article's lack of references in the lead and plot section as reasons for the quickfail, but per...

Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review Result: Close to quickfail level. ~~ AirshipJungleman29 (talk) 19:14, 26 June 2023 (UTC) GA from...

17 March 2011 (UTC) Agreed, renomination would the best course as the quickfail was in November last year. Jezhotwells (talk) 13:43, 17 March 2011 (UTC)...

throughout the article against unsourced content. That would probably be a quickfail if I GA reviewed it today. I'm not sure how to fix it all - can anyone...

India's Satish Dhawan Space Centre - Jayadevp13 09:33, 7 April 2013 (UTC) Quickfail. The nomination is premature. The article has unformatted refs and an...

recent review Result: Valid cleanup banners remain on the article, meeting quickfail criteria. ~~ AirshipJungleman29 (talk) 12:32, 13 July 2023 (UTC) The last...

--The1337gamer (talk) 11:55, 8 August 2015 (UTC) Delist Article arguably meets the quickfail criteria. sovereign°sentinel (contribs) 14:22, 10 August 2015 (UTC) Delist...

you meant to nominate at GAN, but I would suggest against it. This is a quickfail due to large chunks of uncited text. CMD (talk) 00:39, 14 February 2025...

in the lead and history section. If this were a nominee, I might not quickfail it, but I would definitely raise a lot of issues that would take a while...

to assess readiness. --Andy Walsh (talk) 16:41, 1 November 2010 (UTC) Quickfail, please, before pile-on: Wikipedia:Peer review/Ulnar collateral ligament...

incomplete. - Brojam (talk) 22:51, 21 October 2017 (UTC) Delist per WP:Quickfail #3 (would have needed a tag when nominated) and WP:GA? #3a. I was annoyed...

checkmark. Tell the authors what. Nothing in this process- other than a quickfail- can be done in under half an hour.Bradjamesbrown (talk) 22:55, 2 January...

situation, please do so. Otherwise I think this should be delisted as quickfail GAR, but given that there's no consensus about the state of the article...

nomination title "UE II" submarines? --PresN 06:22, 8 February 2010 (UTC) Quickfail - nomination does not include all articles, no attempt to notify the main...

this is a pretty weak article to have the badge -- I'd be inclined to quickfail it were I the reviewer, or at least go for a very "we're going to do significant...

citations are needed. If this was nominated for GAN in its current state, I'd quickfail it. Freikorp (talk) 08:44, 25 March 2018 (UTC) Thanks for getting involved...

I saw up at WP:GAN; I suggest you remove it from the queue to avoid a quickfail: article should be renamed to Gobioides broussonneti (specific epithet...

February 2008 (UTC) Relist for now The delisting was initially based on a quickfail edit conflict, but those criteria do not apply to the article. While it...

of other featured articles. Mechonis (talk) 17:48, 27 April 2013 (UTC) quickfail Setting up this FAC is the editor's first and only edits here. Several...

Insufficient density of citations - numerous unreferenced paragraph - quickfail criteria for a new nomination. --Piotr Konieczny aka Prokonsul Piotrus|...

Eddie891 Talk Work 23:00, 31 October 2020 (UTC) President of Austria (quickfail) Y -- Eddie891 Talk Work 23:00, 31 October 2020 (UTC) Wizards (Middle-earth)...

- @WP:MILHIST coordinators: this looks to me to be a candidate for a quickfail. There is a huge amount of high quality academic material on this subject...

you know that i still consider this a start class article, and would quickfail it if it appeared at good article review. for instance, the plot is just...

fail per WP:GAFAIL? cookiemonster755 (talk) 15:35, 27 October 2025 (UTC) Quickfails are explicitly for GANs, not GARs. ~~ AirshipJungleman29 (talk) 14:29...

Insufficient density of citations - numerous unreferenced paragraph - quickfail criteria for a new nomination.--Piotr Konieczny aka Prokonsul Piotrus|...

the first - see here for the latest on this. Also, the reason for the quickfail can be seen in the talk page history ;) rst20xx (talk) 19:26, 3 January...

Articles reviewed: 0 Old nominations reviewed: 0 Greece-Turkey relations (Quickfail) Y (t · c) buidhe 17:50, 1 June 2022 (UTC) @User:MrLinkinPark333 If I...

samples. I am aware that ragtime is not orchestral, but this nom may be a quickfail anyways since the band has no piano, which may be essential to ragtime...

my view (and other editors at WP:LAW) is OR. I would almost certainly quickfail this article if it were brought to GAN today. voorts (talk/contributions)...

identified. A "quickfail" is when you simply fail the article right away. These are relatively rare. There are only three valid reason to quickfail an article...

see why this article should not have them, hence i support the original quickfail. I didn't see the original reviewer asking for multiple cites for each...

criteria one. Regardless, were I reviewing this article for GA I would quickfail due to only one source. Trainsandotherthings (talk) 02:04, 27 June 2023...

paraphrasing in the article, which would make the article eligible for a quickfail at WP:GAN. See the following comparison with Javaid 2023: Article: "The...

--Rschen7754 19:41, 2 June 2013 (UTC) *Delist and as Rschen says, would quickfail a GA review due to the honking great {{refimprove}} at the top of the...

links, lead issues, notability, and too much detail. None of which are quickfail criteria, None of which are even a reason to fail an article in the first...

Insufficient density of citations - numerous unreferenced paragraph - quickfail criteria for a new nomination. --Piotr Konieczny aka Prokonsul Piotrus|...

tagged {{Notability}} by Lettler (courtesy ping), which would make it a quickfail at GAN. Of course, I wouldn't have created the article if I didn't think...

Insufficient density of citations - numerous unreferenced paragraph - quickfail criteria for a new nomination. --Piotr Konieczny aka Prokonsul Piotrus|...

the first - see here for the latest on this. Also, the reason for the quickfail can be seen in the talk page history ;) rst20xx (talk) 19:26, 3 January...

referring to something else? --Well-restedTalk 00:11, 25 January 2014 (UTC) Quickfail Oppose - just realized that you already have a nomination open; FLC is...

reviewer. "Quickfail" reviews which result in an immediate failing of a nomination count as a QPQ. See Wikipedia talk:Did you know/Archive 204#Quickfails not...

In literature, film, and television section will merit this article a quickfail if it is nominated with it remaining. If there are entries that are not...

higher than is normal for GA, simply because I've been doing a lot of quickfails of unready nominations (orange cleanup banners at the top, obviously incomplete...

GAN. I hadn't realised from that discussion the reviewer had applied a quickfail result. I thought the reviewer had commented awaiting feedback. Quickfailing...

Insufficient density of citations - numerous unreferenced paragraph - quickfail criteria for a new nomination. --Piotr Konieczny aka Prokonsul Piotrus|...

2008 (UTC) IMO that type of thing could possibly be grounds for a simple quickfail. Similar to trying to nominate something at WP:GAC with loads of {{citeneeded}}...

2008 (UTC) IMO that type of thing could possibly be grounds for a simple quickfail. Similar to trying to nominate something at WP:GAC with loads of {{citeneeded}}...

India's Satish Dhawan Space Centre - Jayadevp13 09:33, 7 April 2013 (UTC) Quickfail. The nomination is premature. The article has unformatted refs and an...

to the specific revision that the bot checked) are at User:Snottywong/Quickfail AfC. Articles failed with a reason of "v" means they didn't have any references...

and unverifiable content, and that would probably be enough for me to quickfail this article if it was presented for a GA review now - wouldn't even bother...

Up (one of the Quickfails: Wikipedia:Good article criteria) Human telomeres, cancer and ALT requires Clean Up (one of the Quickfails: Wikipedia:Good...

over it. It was nominated for GA over two years ago, but I think the quickfail reasons cited at the time no longer apply. Any suggestions you can provide...

Otherwise anyone could slap a neutrality tag or a globalize tag on a GA and quickfail it because they felt like it. Again, unless you have actual, specific...

without bias: I dare say the level of non-neutral treatment borders on quickfail territory, but hopefully there will be some serious progress made on this...

experiences at FAR, I have noticed that articles that would basically quickfail at FAC today often have a decent chance of staying an FA through FAR....

some of the reviewer's burden to a bot.) I.e., anything afoul of the quickfail criteria, notice of any open maintenance tags, Earwig %, recent edit warring...

either until I'm clearer about whether or not this really does fall under quickfail criteria - as Majoreditor says, has this come up for discussion before...

similar issues of depth of review with this reviewer before over their quickfail of Cyborg Kuro-chan. --Malkinann (talk) 22:15, 18 February 2011 (UTC)...

the quality of each previous article. Reviewers are encouraged not to quickfail based on length; if an article is short but can be expanded 5x, the nominator...

handy guide. The Rambling Man (talk) 19:30, 8 February 2011 (UTC) Oppose, quickfail please This is awful, sorry, and too far from the standards of FLC to...

Otherwise anyone could slap a neutrality tag or a globalize tag on a GA and quickfail it because they felt like it. Again, unless you have actual, specific...

rather than WP:GAR, I would at this point have probably gone for a WP:QUICKFAIL on the grounds of serious WP:Text–source integrity issues. This article...

experiences at FAR, I have noticed that articles that would basically quickfail at FAC today often have a decent chance of staying an FA through FAR....

the quality of each previous article. Reviewers are encouraged not to quickfail based on length; if an article is short but can be expanded 5x, the nominator...

summarise the article plus there are a couple of cleanup tags present (quickfail 1 - I think). As to the points raised above by Janweh64 (talk · contribs)...

referring to something else? --Well-restedTalk 00:11, 25 January 2014 (UTC) Quickfail Oppose - just realized that you already have a nomination open; FLC is...

article alongside two unreliable source tags, which would result in a quickfail on its own if brought up to a modern GAN review. I do not believe this...

criteria that would eventually fix the need of drives by including two new quickfail criterias about prose quality and coverage issues. Community rejected...

(talk) 03:21, 4 April 2022 (UTC) Y Overruling in my capacity as GA coord. Quickfails are eligible to be counted so long as the review is still thorough enough...

that the sentence is not verifiable, they can quickfail it); however, this suggestion limits the quickfail potential for people who use AI, review its outputs...

(talk) 12:29, 18 September 2012 (UTC) @Chris: Thanks. @Malleus: It is a GA quickfail (FA articles must meet GA criteria too). I had a couple of GA experiences...

even close to quick-fail for GA. The writing in and of itself isn't even quickfail for FA, though in my mind it's a candidate for {{sofixit}}. Final word:...

to do with abrupt quickfailing is not (as it was an absurdly blatant quickfail abuse, "supported" by "ignore all rules" for the lack of any real arguments)...

are encouraged to leave comments as if it was a GANR. If it would be a quickfail at GAN, they can suggest delisting. Otherwise, it is expected that one...

weeks 2 points Under 2 weeks 1 point Quickfails* 0 points * No matter how old the nomination is, if you quickfail the article, it is worth 0 points. Article...

avoided where possible I don't know that it really should have been a quickfail, but I didn't bother to look at the before link listed above. However...

of the sources [136]. When the review started, Jezhotwells decided to quickfail and claimed that the sites are blogs and therefore unreliable [137]. I...

archives are not being productively done. The last review was just a quickfail on the tagging. The tags have been removed. Is the tag removal at issue...

archives are not being productively done. The last review was just a quickfail on the tagging. The tags have been removed. Is the tag removal at issue...

(UTC) And there is disagreement with your assertion that it was a bad quickfail. It would have been better to discuss it first rather than doing what...

from me for pitching in with the backlog, but someone pointed out your quickfail at Pitfour estate with no examples or actionable recommendations, and...

the article is up for GA review again; I would personally be tempted to quickfail it for failing point 5. "Stability", but that probably wouldn't be constructive...

original concern is a valid talk page consideration (that is it doesn't quickfail NOT#FORUM), so just removing the DS link because its the DS while leaving...

criteria that would eventually fix the need of drives by including two new quickfail criterias about prose quality and coverage issues. Community rejected...

reviews. Some of these reviews were brought up on WT:GAN as inappropriate quickfails. A wide variety of experienced GA writers and reviewers brought up that...

criteria are required as part of the review process. It used to be a quickfail criteria, but because copyright violations are predominatley found during...

currently being held. A requets for comment proposing a new wording for the quickfail criteria, proposed by Aircorn, is currently being held. There are currently...

Torobayev Russian interference in the 2016 United States electionsN while a quickfail not a detailed review for these purposes Barkeep49 (talk) Modern Tales...

patrolling the mouth end of the AFC queue so actively (go over the front for quickfail objections (Copyright, attacks, patent nonsense)), and work the tail end...

place on the nompage, if someone wants, but if it were up to me I would quickfail this. This article wasn't written by the nominator and I have no idea...

— Wizardman "Talk That Talk (Rihanna song)" — Wizardman "Cat Daddy" N Quickfail. —Hahc21 03:20, 2 August 2012 (UTC) Tropical Depression Nine (2001) —Pyrotec...

no basis for the claim that there are image tag problems (which led to quickfail), especially as of now since all the images in the article are in Wikipedia...

11:48, 2 September 2024 (UTC) I agree, and as a copyright violation is a quickfail criterion, I have delisted the article. ~~ AirshipJungleman29 (talk) 11:53...

handy guide. The Rambling Man (talk) 19:30, 8 February 2011 (UTC) Oppose, quickfail please This is awful, sorry, and too far from the standards of FLC to...

to seek help at WP:GOCE or some related Wikiproject; or you can simply quickfail it if you find the problems are persistent and would take extensive work...

using standard citation templates without an excellent reason" would be a quickfail criterion). In the case of the Burnage references at least, it doesn't...

as to not make people too bitter from pointless wasting (idealy, the quickfail happens within 15 minutes of someone noticing it on their watchlist)....

a proper review (where I interpret proper review to mean opposite of quickfail).--TonyTheTiger (T / C / WP:FOUR / WP:CHICAGO / WP:WAWARD) 21:40, 8 February...

memorizer and to make sure that I hit everything I need to. I don't tend to quickfail articles; I've never seen one in such bad shape at GAC. I've found that...

memorizer and to make sure that I hit everything I need to. I don't tend to quickfail articles; I've never seen one in such bad shape at GAC. I've found that...

which is simply not a quickfail criterion. Finally, if you yourself are adding the templates, then it is also not a quickfail criterion: this refers...

experienced reviewer. Please do not close your review (i.e., pass, fail, or quickfail it) before an experienced reviewer has had a chance to check it. If you...

food, and drink" to "Warfare". That is, "Miscellaneous" is not required. Quickfails count; Wikipedia:Good article reassessment does not. It doesn't have to...

memorizer and to make sure that I hit everything I need to. I don't tend to quickfail articles; I've never seen one in such bad shape at GAC. I've found that...

minimize frustration due to wasted effort: Start with a check against the quickfail criteria (WP:QF). Check if there might be an earlier GAN review with unaddressed...

navigating that information has no business in the admin role. Many of the quickfail/SNOW RfAs include users that didn't bother adhering to that guidance....

reviews would be, because it was trending toward failing without being a quickfail at first glance. (After reading your comments and looking myself, I agree...

was a quickfail that was quickfailed because there was a legitimate clean up tag in the article. Which is still there as of this comment. Quickfails (legitimate...

not beat the clock with this and one more promotion. FAC2 was a recent quickfail due to image issues which have been resolved at Wikipedia:Peer review/Millennium...

GAN. :) I'm a little surprised that excessive fair use images aren't a quickfail, but that's probably because GA is not just for fiction articles. ;) --Malkinann...

memorizer and to make sure that I hit everything I need to. I don't tend to quickfail articles; I've never seen one in such bad shape at GAC. I've found that...

memorizer and to make sure that I hit everything I need to. I don't tend to quickfail articles; I've never seen one in such bad shape at GAC. I've found that...

— Wizardman "Talk That Talk (Rihanna song)" — Wizardman "Cat Daddy" N Quickfail. —Hahc21 03:20, 2 August 2012 (UTC) Tropical Depression Nine (2001) —Pyrotec...

--Rschen7754 19:41, 2 June 2013 (UTC) *Delist and as Rschen says, would quickfail a GA review due to the honking great {{refimprove}} at the top of the...

Insufficient density of citations - numerous unreferenced paragraph - quickfail criteria for a new nomination. --Piotr Konieczny aka Prokonsul Piotrus|...

of the sources [80]. When the review started, Jezhotwells decided to quickfail and claimed that the sites are blogs and therefore unreliable [81]. I...

who starts off their RfA stating areas that they wont work in. That's a quickfail for me. --Kraftlos (Talk | Contrib) 05:01, 6 October 2010 (UTC) I'd like...

sign of the anon, so I've removed the template, but, really, is this "GA quickfail" template even a good idea? It gives no suggestions for moving on. Adam...

wording for the quickfail criteria, proposed by Aircorn, is currently being held. Aircorn proposed a change that basically leaved the "quickfail" word out of...

are not reliable sources. If editors are unhappy with the decision to quickfail then take it to WP:GAR. There are undoubtedly plenty of reliable sources...

Completely and unequivocally improper quickfail. Courcelles 03:57, 5 October 2010 (UTC) Overturn and relist. Quickfail was improper; needs a full review....

think the idea is nice in theory, but in practice, too many are straight quickfails, with maintenance banners and sometimes more than ten unsourced paragraphs...

GAN. I hadn't realised from that discussion the reviewer had applied a quickfail result. I thought the reviewer had commented awaiting feedback. Quickfailing...

them. Likewise I can't see blocking an entire class. I would encourage quickfails at GAN and DYK, and have quickfailed some edu DYK's myself in the past...

clearly engaged with the article, though no spotchecks were done, and the quickfail was based on appropriate criteria. One nomination at FAC, quickly archived...

reviewer. Liz Read! Talk! 05:39, 18 November 2024 (UTC) Delist - this is a quickfail #4 and fails general criterion #5 (stable) both owing to the constant...

to my question shows that Sahaib still has some areas to grow in. The quickfail was not appropriate, for the editor claimed that the article didn't have...

— Wizardman "Talk That Talk (Rihanna song)" — Wizardman "Cat Daddy" N Quickfail. —Hahc21 03:20, 2 August 2012 (UTC) Tropical Depression Nine (2001) —Pyrotec...

it as a basis for improving the article here and now? Do you suggest a quickfail based on prose and/or length? And your critique thus far does not touch...

in Talk page by one author! Illustrated (With images or graphics) Some Quickfails Notes: I think we could get this article to B relatively easily! A relating...

February 2008 (UTC) Relist for now The delisting was initially based on a quickfail edit conflict, but those criteria do not apply to the article. While it...

memorizer and to make sure that I hit everything I need to. I don't tend to quickfail articles; I've never seen one in such bad shape at GAC. I've found that...

either until I'm clearer about whether or not this really does fall under quickfail criteria - as Majoreditor says, has this come up for discussion before...

this article as a WP:Good article nomination, I would close it as a WP:QUICKFAIL. I suggest this nomination be archived so the article can be brought to...

a proper review (where I interpret proper review to mean opposite of quickfail).--TonyTheTiger (T / C / WP:FOUR / WP:CHICAGO / WP:WAWARD) 21:40, 8 February...

with no other contribution history - I judge this as C class at best. Quickfail. Jezhotwells (talk) 18:55, 3 December 2011 (UTC)" The problem with that...

links, lead issues, notability, and too much detail. None of which are quickfail criteria, None of which are even a reason to fail an article in the first...

samples. I am aware that ragtime is not orchestral, but this nom may be a quickfail anyways since the band has no piano, which may be essential to ragtime...

decision to quickfail the initial GAN. The reviewer cited the article's lack of references in the lead and plot section as reasons for the quickfail, but per...

wordcount to the nearest 500, for the sake of the co-ordinators' sanity. For quickfails and insubstantial reviews, only the review point might be rewarded (at...

issues that were far more than just simple fixes; it was a justifiable quickfail because I would've had to completely rewrite and alter multiple sections...

see why this article should not have them, hence i support the original quickfail. I didn't see the original reviewer asking for multiple cites for each...

(talk) 12:29, 18 September 2012 (UTC) @Chris: Thanks. @Malleus: It is a GA quickfail (FA articles must meet GA criteria too). I had a couple of GA experiences...

this viewpoint is due. I do agree that the proposed expanded version quickfails and I have reverted per BLP. VQuakr (talk) 21:26, 7 May 2020 (UTC) I think...

avoided where possible I don't know that it really should have been a quickfail, but I didn't bother to look at the before link listed above. However...

2013 entries Would an experienced editor assess the consensus at Talk:Caste/Archive 4#RfC: Does the article minimize the centrality of India to the notion...

identified. A "quickfail" is when you simply fail the article right away. These are relatively rare. There are only three valid reason to quickfail an article...

experienced reviewer. Please do not close your review (i.e., pass, fail, or quickfail it) before an experienced reviewer has had a chance to check it. If you...

10:18, 30 June 2024 (UTC) Copyright violations in articles are a GAN quickfail criterion, Sirberus. You will note that WP:COPYRIGHT, a policy with legal...

not beat the clock with this and one more promotion. FAC2 was a recent quickfail due to image issues which have been resolved at Wikipedia:Peer review/Millennium...

--The1337gamer (talk) 11:55, 8 August 2015 (UTC) Delist Article arguably meets the quickfail criteria. sovereign°sentinel (contribs) 14:22, 10 August 2015 (UTC) Delist...

similar issues of depth of review with this reviewer before over their quickfail of Cyborg Kuro-chan. --Malkinann (talk) 22:15, 18 February 2011 (UTC)...

summarise the article plus there are a couple of cleanup tags present (quickfail 1 - I think). As to the points raised above by Janweh64 (talk · contribs)...

checkmark. Tell the authors what. Nothing in this process- other than a quickfail- can be done in under half an hour.Bradjamesbrown (talk) 22:55, 2 January...

toxic, if at all - for my part I found it roughly as hurtful as any other quickfail. The problem isn't with the formalism, the problem is the way in which...

experienced reviewer. Please do not close your review (ie, pass, fail, or quickfail it) before an experienced reviewer has had a chance to check it. if you...

this is a pretty weak article to have the badge -- I'd be inclined to quickfail it were I the reviewer, or at least go for a very "we're going to do significant...

using standard citation templates without an excellent reason" would be a quickfail criterion). In the case of the Burnage references at least, it doesn't...

January 2023 (UTC) Okay, I thought you meant actually create the page and quickfail it. I don't expect to be removing any more templates in the near future...

- @WP:MILHIST coordinators: this looks to me to be a candidate for a quickfail. There is a huge amount of high quality academic material on this subject...

it as a basis for improving the article here and now? Do you suggest a quickfail based on prose and/or length? And your critique thus far does not touch...

11:48, 2 September 2024 (UTC) I agree, and as a copyright violation is a quickfail criterion, I have delisted the article. ~~ AirshipJungleman29 (talk) 11:53...

throughout the article against unsourced content. That would probably be a quickfail if I GA reviewed it today. I'm not sure how to fix it all - can anyone...

Section Criteria status Excerpt Suggestion 1 Gameplay 2nd paragraph   quickfail Cards fall into two classes: lands and spells. Citation needed tag, preferably...

citations are needed. If this was nominated for GAN in its current state, I'd quickfail it. Freikorp (talk) 08:44, 25 March 2018 (UTC) Thanks for getting involved...

how to improve the GA Cup in the future, including the definition of "quickfails" and the use of pools, which we'll seriously consider as we move forward...

wordcount to the nearest 500, for the sake of the co-ordinators' sanity. For quickfails and insubstantial reviews, only the review point might be rewarded (at...

have reviewed all of your listed GAN articles at the end of drive. For quickfails and insubstantial reviews, only the review point might be rewarded (at...

WP:TRADES likely paraphrasing a presser to me No idea how reliable Skipped, quickfail on other criteria Regalado, Antonio. "Here's why I am coining the term...

WP:GAN: TTT has nominated (and sometimes renominated directly after a quickfail) several articles that he last edited years ago, and some of them are...

I saw up at WP:GAN; I suggest you remove it from the queue to avoid a quickfail: article should be renamed to Gobioides broussonneti (specific epithet...

WP:TRADES likely paraphrasing a presser to me No idea how reliable Skipped, quickfail on other criteria Regalado, Antonio. "Here's why I am coining the term...

of other featured articles. Mechonis (talk) 17:48, 27 April 2013 (UTC) quickfail Setting up this FAC is the editor's first and only edits here. Several...

round". FinTech Global. Retrieved 2023-10-11. – No evidence it is, but quickfail funding announcement minimal additional detail anyway Tucker, Charlotte...

2024-05-17. Seems like a media release again, but again, moot by the RS quickfail First thing I notice here was the about page linking to D2 Emerge... We...

2024-05-17. Seems like a media release again, but again, moot by the RS quickfail First thing I notice here was the about page linking to D2 Emerge... We...

to assess readiness. --Andy Walsh (talk) 16:41, 1 November 2010 (UTC) Quickfail, please, before pile-on: Wikipedia:Peer review/Ulnar collateral ligament...

19:45, 1 November 2024 (UTC) Leafy46, I personally fully concur with that quickfail. I think you did an excellent job of pointing out what needs to be improved...

and the close of the review, discuss the situation with coordinators. Quickfails are capped at one point and will not receive additional points for length...

labeled run-of-the-ordinary Wikipedia articles by considering several "quickfails" that can eliminate a nominated article from promotion to a good article...

criteria one. Regardless, were I reviewing this article for GA I would quickfail due to only one source. Trainsandotherthings (talk) 02:04, 27 June 2023...

round". FinTech Global. Retrieved 2023-10-11. – No evidence it is, but quickfail funding announcement minimal additional detail anyway Tucker, Charlotte...

reviewer. Liz Read! Talk! 05:39, 18 November 2024 (UTC) Delist - this is a quickfail #4 and fails general criterion #5 (stable) both owing to the constant...

article alongside two unreliable source tags, which would result in a quickfail on its own if brought up to a modern GAN review. I do not believe this...

GAN. :) I'm a little surprised that excessive fair use images aren't a quickfail, but that's probably because GA is not just for fiction articles. ;) --Malkinann...

over it. It was nominated for GA over two years ago, but I think the quickfail reasons cited at the time no longer apply. Any suggestions you can provide...

found Result: Significant citation issues mean that the article meets the quickfail criteria, and thus should be delisted. ~~ AirshipJungleman29 (talk) 12:35...

tagged {{Notability}} by Lettler (courtesy ping), which would make it a quickfail at GAN. Of course, I wouldn't have created the article if I didn't think...

merit behind it, but they pushed this narrative and forced Freedoxm to quickfail the nomination before the nomination even got to finish. Then that brings...

Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review Result: Close to quickfail level. ~~ AirshipJungleman29 (talk) 19:14, 26 June 2023 (UTC) GA from...

fail per WP:GAFAIL? cookiemonster755 (talk) 15:35, 27 October 2025 (UTC) Quickfails are explicitly for GANs, not GARs. ~~ AirshipJungleman29 (talk) 14:29...

10:18, 30 June 2024 (UTC) Copyright violations in articles are a GAN quickfail criterion, Sirberus. You will note that WP:COPYRIGHT, a policy with legal...

rather than WP:GAR, I would at this point have probably gone for a WP:QUICKFAIL on the grounds of serious WP:Text–source integrity issues. This article...

February 2026 (UTC) TarnishedPath The only incident you cite is the GA quickfail. If you want to present misbehaviour in the topic area I'd expect something...

very rudimentary contents barely covering material being useful. Both quickfails concluded with this statement, which I don't even need to explain the...

considering Lee found Magic: The Gathering rules of such low quality as to quickfail, but not sufficient to move me to an oppose on its own. However, the poor...

issues that were far more than just simple fixes; it was a justifiable quickfail because I would've had to completely rewrite and alter multiple sections...

10:18, 30 June 2024 (UTC) Copyright violations in articles are a GAN quickfail criterion, Sirberus. You will note that WP:COPYRIGHT, a policy with legal...

you meant to nominate at GAN, but I would suggest against it. This is a quickfail due to large chunks of uncited text. CMD (talk) 00:39, 14 February 2025...

on the article talk page to that effect, so that your reviewer doesn't quickfail it. -- asilvering (talk) 22:40, 26 April 2024 (UTC) Thank you, I'll do...

this article as a WP:Good article nomination, I would close it as a WP:QUICKFAIL. I suggest this nomination be archived so the article can be brought to...

clearly engaged with the article, though no spotchecks were done, and the quickfail was based on appropriate criteria. One nomination at FAC, quickly archived...

at 22:17 UTC on January 1st, about two days after they posted their quickfail verdict for the review. The renumbering appears to be entirely correct...

consider whether they have adequate knowledge to opine about what the quickfail criteria should be. Now, RGloucester has opened a clearly retaliatory...

standards (statements that would not meet the standard of review even of many quickfails of GA nominations; example) and, in effect, asks any would-be rescuer...