DOKUMEN123.COM

assessment department of the Military history WikiProject focuses on assessing the quality of Wikipedia's military history articles. The resulting article...

adding articles to MILHIST task force assessing articles that fall within the project's scope updating the open tasks template on Milhist task force pages...

fall within the project's scope, including adding articles to MILHIST task force assessing articles that fall within the project's scope, including Good...

history-related topic and are not members of the project. The syntax is as follows: {{subst:Wikipedia:MILHIST/I|~~~~}} Shortcut WP:MILHIST/IWP:MILHIST/I...

has since been adapted for use as part of the Milhist Academy. Many editors' first inkling of Milhist's existence is when they spot our project banner...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Outdawg (talk) 0 The worklists below include just over 3500 Milhist articles currently assessed as B-Class (Worklist A) and 4000 articles whose B-Class criteria...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

fall within the project's scope, including adding articles to MILHIST task force assessing articles that fall within the project's scope, including Good...

task forces turn to their parent project – Milhist – where uniform systems are in place for discussion, to assess articles, send newsletters to all project...

formal reviewing processes are WP:GAN, the project A-Class assessment at WP:MILHIST/ACR, and WP:FAC. For instance, an editor who provides both a source review...

Moonriddengirl), has asked us to self-assess our project. Please add your views to the page, as it will help Milhist and the encyclopedia as a whole: The...

recently passed 50 GANs. Nice work! The results of the January to March 2020 Milhist reviewing are in. CPA-5 headed the tally with an impressive 42 reviews...

significant inroads. Over 850 pages have been tagged for Milhist, more than 310 Milhistbot-assessed articles have been checked, and task forces have been...

October. Welcome to all, feel free to ask any questions you have at WT:MILHIST. Finally, we will open our annual Military historian of the year and newcomer...

articles and ancillary pages were tagged for the MILHIST project, with 2,565 articles being assessed. In addition, 131 new articles were created and many...

found many many ship articles without the Milhist tag. --Brad (talk) 01:06, 3 September 2008 (UTC) I find the assess drive (and the awards offered) increases...

B-class criteria in the MILHIST tag for articles that are Stub, Start, and B-class. If I were to assess this article today, I would assess it as a Start-class...

Importance score = Assessed_importance_points + External_interest_points. Some WikiProjects, such as WP:MILHIST, have chosen not to assess for importance...

already had new members join thanks to Bobo.03's tool ..." – Peacemaker67, MILHIST "I would recommend the tool to others as a valuable way to reach new editors...

have been active as a MILHIST coordinator, being re-elected to a fifth term in September 2014. In this capacity I have assessed articles, closed A class...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

feature. What skills/qualities can you contribute as a Milhist coordinator? My ability to quickly assess a multitude articles, and spellcheck other people's...

in the two Tag & Assess drives, and the B-class assessment drives, from a couple years back. (see: here) Generally most of my MILHIST work is gnomish in...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

on a set of heuristics. Articles will be graded as Start, C or B. The {{MILHIST}} template will be updated. It is anticipated that initial runs will be...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

assess article quality. These can be broadly divided into three groups: WikiProject assessments are based on a project's quality scale; the Milhist scale...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

automatically assess articles as C-Class with only a few minutes of work by one person. – Joe Nutter 19:57, 8 March 2009 (UTC) Which do you think MilHist should...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

assigned by any editor. By convention, military history articles should be assessed by an editor who has not been involved with the article; this is to avoid...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

passed/promoted during the contest period. Don't overload the WP:FAC, WP:GAN, Milhist A-Class review and Peer review systems. New articles written for Did you...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

will eventually come along and assess your article, and if it is a stub, it will be classified as such using the MILHIST template. This will automatically...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

"requested" article should be construed broadly. This refers to adding the Milhist project's banner to the talk page. Content updates on A-class articles...

you contribute as a Milhist coordinator? I am comfortable with the routine coordinator tasks, and have extensive experience assessing articles. I am a capable...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Tag & Assess 2007 is now officially over. It has been successful and we would like to repeat it later in the year. The purpose of this workshop is to discuss...

assessment department of the Illinois WikiProject! This department focuses on assessing the quality of Wikipedia's articles about Illinois. While much of the...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

passed/promoted during the contest period. Don't overload the WP:FAC, WP:GAN, Milhist A-Class review and Peer review systems. Please note that at FAC, nominators...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

with a decent bit of content work, and for MILHIST-specific areas, I've been involved with all the Tag&Assess and B-class Assessment Drives and done a fair...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

by participating in GA and A class reviews and tagging and assessing articles for MILHIST. I've also been guilty of quite a bit of wikignoming to tidy...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

protect | delete | links | watch | logs | views) Quality: B (Bio), Start (Milhist) Importance: N/A Revolving Bugbear 13:32, 9 February 2008 (UTC) George...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

This is the worklist page for the Military history project's April 2021 Reviewing Drive. Throughout the drive, each participant should keep track of their...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

WikiProject Milhist Talk:Evelyn Conyers: Assessed as Start Class against B-Class standards for WikiProject Milhist Talk:Gisèle Guillemot: Assessed as Start...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

an upcoming edit-a-thon, which will take place in April. The April 2018 Milhist Backlog Drive aims to target several areas including tagging and assessment...

to work, I think milhist and biography are notable exceptions (I tried to make it work for Poland and gave up, nobody but me assessed stuff). So from where...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

(UTC) CPA-5 (talk · contribs) Hi everyone, I joined Wikipedia in 2016 and MILHIST in 2018. I've been elected in 2019 as coordinator and after a small break...

Military History Writers' Contest Cup {{subst:Milhist Writers' Contest Cup|1=On behalf of the Milhist coordinators, I hereby award you the Military History...

Calcutta, and Battle of Appomattox Station. In WP:MILHIST, I evaluate A-class reviews, and assess articles. I also tag a few CSD's and participate in...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

challenges, and assess historical sources. What skills/qualities can you contribute as a coordinator? I too have served three years as a MILHIST co-ordinator...

18:57, 5 June 2026 (UTC) Anotherclown (talk · contribs) I have been a MILHIST coordinator for the last year and will throw my hat into the ring for another...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Wikipedia in general and the MILHIST project in particular following the GWE case? What do you intend to do as a MILHIST coordinator in this area? Will...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

communication skills, which is a necessity for admins. I would recommend WP:MILHIST. There are contests that you can participate in, and there are a very large...

and filled in the B-class checklist but B-class is not appearing on the Milhist banner on the talk page when I saved. A. Nothing's wrong with it. The template...

independent editors, rather than by WikiProjects." Some Wikiprojects, like WP:MILHIST, have assessments for B and A class, but most do not because of the high...

doesn't perform A-class assessments ourselves, we do recognize WP:CHEM/WP:MILHIST's A-Class reviews in the many areas where physics and chemistry/military...

objections from the previous nomination have been satisfied. Commenting The new Milhist A-Class standard is deliberately set high, very close to featured article...

Please do not assess any article under our scope with C-Class. For each article: Read the article. Then: Check that it's within the Milhist scope. Check...

Strong keep (as MILHIST coordinator). If even just one or two projects want to use it, why care? I've been quite involved in A-Class for MILHIST and have never...

coordinator at Milhist which means he cleans up after the rest of us. Roger was the key architect and figure behind the successful Milhist tag and assess drive...

on the Milhist talk page and Military history related topics? I ask this as I don't see many contributions (2 in the last 6 months) to Milhist project...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

review workshop is intended to evaluate the various Wikipedia processes that assess and improve content. It seeks to clarify means and methods, reduce procedural...

reassessed by the project, in order to see whether this paradox (a WP:MILHIST projet A-Class article to have failed GA review) should remain or not.--Yannismarou...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

background knowledge to assess how well it balances the competing arguments." I took his implied advice and stepped away from MILHIST. Both Peer review and...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

sure. I am now a solid contributor to many Wikiprojects, including: WP:MILHIST, WP:WPTC, and WP:CHEM. Of my article contributions, I would be most proud...

Those who are into monitoring new pages or recent changes can add the {{milhist}} template to articles within our scope, and if you are looking for a way...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

history WikiProject?'' ** *''What skills/qualities can you contribute as a Milhist coordinator?'' ** ==== Votes in support of Name ==== # The election will...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

questions, feel free to contact one of the coordinators or post on WT:MILHIST if you have any questions. Your editors, Ian Rose (talk) and Nick-D (talk)...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

practice at WP:VG in the drafting of its bylaws and guidelines, we look to WP:MILHIST for guidance, and here we find details concerning a significant step that...

news section comprises only ten works but all worthy additions to the MilHist showcase. Notably, three of these articles were developed by Gog the Mild...

can manage FAC without A-class, I suspect that it's a crucial part of Milhist's success. So not only does the whole project owe you a debt of thanks for...

five-point Milhist checklist) and promote if applicable. (Here's link to the B-class FAQ.) Many have been improved since they were last assessed; you may...

following links may be helpful for reviewing articles that fall within Milhist's scope: Wikipedia:Manual of Style/Military history Wikipedia:WikiProject...

sentence of this case is, K.e.coffman speaking: "My op-ed in the Bugle, WP:MILHIST's newsletter, summarises my findings on the subject of Wikipedia's mythmaking...

for A MilHist article to not have an infobox these days. Kirk (talk) 21:39, 14 August 2013 (UTC) I get what you're saying, but there are six MILHIST FL ORBAT...

Kirill Lokshin (talk · contribs), as the lead coordinator of the insanely successful WP:MILHIST, is the person to ask for WikiProject advice. However, he does not have...

skills/qualities can you contribute as a coordinator? I’ve been involved with MILHIST in some form for about 8 years I think, and a co-ordinator for four, so...

is no A-Class review process as happens in other projects (e.g. in WP:MILHIST). Members of the project should keep the criteria for featured articles...

featured article and list processes. I was runner up in the WikiCup in 2013, MILHIST Military historian of the year in 2012 and 2024. I have been involved with...

too much effort. PediaPress offers to publish books that were created, assessed and proposed by the community. There are only a few restrictions when choosing...

CPA-5 (talk · contribs) Hallo, everyone, I've been active since 2016 but joined MILHIST two years later. I've been elected coordinator in 2019–2020 however due...

Banzai edit-a-thon, and have chased up many reviewers at Milhist ACR, listed and closed many Milhist ACRs, handed out A-Class Medals and Crosses in a timely...

Cam (Chat) 01:39, 8 December 2008 (UTC) Reviewers: Please say whether Milhist should Keep or Demote this article. Reviewers should satisfy themselves...

there aren't others doing featured pictures, it's more I'm the one with a MILHIST bent. Do nominate some, eh, old chaps? - Adam) Battle of the Blacks (Cplakidas)...

the norm ever since, except we also include C-Class assessments since Milhist adopted that assessment level. The highest point-scorer each month is awarded...

before MILHIST consensus [176], on 26.11.13 before MILHIST consensus [177], at 00:34 on 27.11.13 before MILHIST consensus [178], after MILHIST consensus...

receive feedback on articles and the very active project talk page WT:MILHIST. We also work pretty well with our main 'sister' projects such as WP:AIR...

14:33, 9 March 2008. Notified: WP:GERMANY, WP:MILHIST, WP:MARITIME, WP:GERMIL, WWI task force, British Milhist task force, User:Gdr, User:Tirronan. There...

"general in name only." Could be wrong though. Hope for feedback from WP:MILHIST.--GrapedApe (talk) 02:25, 16 December 2011 (UTC) Keep. The findagrave reference...

via FACBot (talk) 7:01, 13 February 2021 (UTC) [1]. Notified: Robth, WP MILHIST, WP Classical Greece and Rome, WP Biography, WP Greece, 2020-12-24 Well...

of the project members, MILHIST is one of the most successful WikiProjects. I believe that an assistant coordinator for MILHIST should take a lead role...

I felt I had a knowledge of the subject that was probably unique among MILHIST Project Wikipedians. The Coast Guard is the smallest of the United States...

2018 (UTC) No worries, Nick, thanks for your efforts. I reviewed this at MILHIST ACR and having reviewed the changes since then, am happy to support it...

site for nearly one year, previously as AirplanePro. I contribute to WP:MILHIST mainly and two important sidelines are WP:AIR and WP:GOCE. I have taken...

privilege of being a Milhist coordinator for many years. For most of that time, I've been copyediting almost all of the Milhist Featured and A-class articles...

review toolbox Wikipedia:WikiProject Military history/Academy/What do Milhist task forces do? Wikipedia:WikiProject Military history/Academy/How can...

to improve certain, potentially neglected areas of the project, we at Milhist occasionally hold major contributor-driven events called drives. The thrust...

contributions to Wikipedia, and why? My AFD contributions, assessing articles for WP:MILHIST, tagging articles for CSD, and writing articles such as the...

Milhist or the infobox talk page would seem most appropriate place, as I’ve already said (quite a bit) in this debate. My previous comment at Milhist...

World War", I don't think there's an agreed standard, at least not in MILHIST, except that things should be consistent within an article. Cheers, Ian...

DYKs and have two FAs, a FP, and an FL (most of which are in MILHIST scope.) I joined MILHIST two or three years ago now, and have been involved in content...

(UTC) Done - (Initiated 2787 days ago on 18 October 2018) Would an admin assess the consensus at Wikipedia:Move review/Log/2018 October#World Heritage site...

been part of WP:MILHIST since the 28th Feburary 2006. Since then I have taken part in discussion on the Project's talk page, assessed articles and A-class...

Wikipedia:Prosesize, by Dr pda: gets the prose length of an article, useful for assessing articles against the length criteria Wikipedia:Did you know/DYKcheck,...

productive MILHIST A-class review (thanks to all who helped) and is, in my view, ready for FA. Constantine ✍ 16:05, 11 August 2019 (UTC) I assessed this at...

from a single authorial view whereas there are other critiques out there. MILHIST has enough WWII expertise to identify those, I think. Monstrelet (talk)...

(edit | history) · Watch • Watch peer review Created this article and was assessed as B-class recently and would like to bring it to Good article status....

mostly redlinks, I've seen it happen in discussions at WP:SHIPS or WP:MILHIST. 70.49.126.147 (talk) 05:17, 14 March 2012 (UTC) Also note that disambiguation...

why were there so many "neo-Nazi publications" in MILHIST articles, inserted by a four-term MILHIST coordinator, MisterBee 1966, and defended by a five-term...

of eliminating all backlogged articles from the year 2009. Join today! Milhist March Madness is marching along at a steady pace. The backlog reduction...

1,500 will inevitably suffer a delay if this task is not taken up and MilHist Featured Articles are demoted through FAR/C. Project members are similarly...

October 2017 (UTC) Support I reviewed this article at GAN and again for Milhist A-Class. I've gone through the changes since then, including Dan's copyedit...

more content for it to be a B. I reassessed it as a C (and a Start for MILHIST as they do not use C for some reason). ···日本穣? · Talk to Nihonjoe 20:20...

Popular Culture" sections in articles are- generally- to be avoided (WP:MILHIST#POP. Now, my understanding is that (and I'm reposting part of a comment...

Footnote 1. @WP:MILHIST coordinators: Battle of Preston (1648) has odd assessment history, shown as start and then at one time as C and start at same...

reconstructed. Most, if not all these articles, have been successfully assessed by MILHIST to B-class [1], and a number have reached GA [2]. This would have...

devoted years of his time and energy to the coordination and maintenance of MILHIST. (Awarded November 2023) Ian Rose: In recognition of his outstanding contributions...

doing this in the case of 3 projects that I belive are reliable (US Roads, MILHIST and NRHP) but others can be used as well if desired. If class is inherited...

A-class criteria. --K.e.coffman (talk) 19:27, 17 March 2019 (UTC) @WP:MILHIST coordinators: I've advertised this on the main page, but I think it is...

charter" to supplement their usual classwork. [EXPAND] Tag & assess drive a la WP:MILHIST's? DYK of the week? Barnstars/WikiBling? Get a bot to tag all...

good job, but you're in the wrong place; the article was assessed as not meeting Milhist's B-class criteria, and you're going to need a lot of help with...

This could include: Critically assessing the language and content of articles to try to spot gaps or biases. Assessing older sources to determine if they...

sources myself). Hog Farm Talk 19:10, 28 June 2022 (UTC) I've notified the MilHist and Aircraft projects. Hopefully this will bring more help.Nigel Ish (talk)...

have been active as a MILHIST coordinator, being re-elected to a fifth term in September 2014. In this capacity I have assessed articles, closed A class...

two article tagging/assessment drives for WP:SHIPS and WP:MILHIST during which I tagged/assessed 3100+ articles from September to December 2007. The co-nomination...

essays that are written and published before such a small audience in the MILHIST newsletter, and I hope republishing it here will expose it to a larger...

article was removed 08:48, 11 August 2007. WP Netherlands, WP Biography, WP MilHist, Iblardi and Arnoutf notified. DrKiernan 09:48, 10 July 2007 (UTC) Despite...

consider replacing this tag with {{WikiProject status|Inactive}}. Guide to WikiProjects Directory of WikiProjects Shortcut WP:MILHIST/ITALYWP:MILHIST/ITALY...

(UTC) Completely agree with SnowFire - a GA I recently got within the Milhist scope was picked up in less then a day, whereas others sit in categories...

tagging and assessing of articles. While doing New pages patrol, I constantly tag articles within the MILHIST scope, but the tagging/assessing contributions...

perennial sources list, to help page reviewers unfamiliar with a given subject assess notability and neutrality of an article –entries should focus on whether...

network with other projects, WikiProject Video Games has partners with WP:MILHIST for peer reviews. Users for either project can list their articles for...

because I am not active in this project much, if at all; I apologize, but Milhist articles, especially those which fall under WP:OMT, have stolen the attention...

to closing AFDs and speedy deleting as well. I'll stay mainly within WP:MILHIST, as I have done, unless I have specific familiarity with an issue. 2. What...

to try different solutions, but it's more than fair for the Committee to assess that such efforts would be fruitless. While it's looking retrospectively...

I look forward in working with reviewers to ensure this article meets MILHIST standards. Thanks to all who take the time to review the list. Parsecboy...

05:20, Tuesday, October 13, 2020 (UTC) Function overview: Go through the MilHist stub-class articles and reclassify the ones that are no longer stubs Automatic...

self-nom, it should be noted that he is an active coordinator with WP:MILHIST, a project that manages a number of high use (and thus protected) templates;...

a Featured List I believe it meets the criteria. It has just had a WP:MILHIST peer review and all comments have been addressed.. Jim Sweeney (talk) 08:19...

(talk) 07:55, 21 September 2024 (UTC) I was invited to have a look at the MILHIST talk page. Right off the bat, I am surprised that the go-to resource on...

one in size and complexity is MILHIST -- and that template is just half the size of this one (in bytes). Because MILHIST doesn't rate pages on importance...

comparisons such as T34vTiger, SMLEvs91/30vsG98vsM1903, and a few other milhist ones. Civil aircraft probably has a couple of notable planes too. L3X1...

inactive, so we are always looking for new editors to join Milhist." – PeaceMaker67, MILHIST "The tool is most helpful with surfacing users who have shown...

dealt with; beyond that, a number of other points need citations, per WP:MILHIST#CITE. Topics such as this one tend to be quite controversial, so thorough...

many projects, and so have terminated my interest in Wikipedia. But the MilHist coordinators, bless them all, made huge assumptions of good faith. Which...

limitation of one nomination at a time per user. So here I am, back at MILHIST A-class, hoping for some more reviews and useful feedback for the day when...

addition to the project, I've see very little talkpage action compared to WP:MILHIST or WP:FOOD. The project is the parent of 15 task forces. Are you involved...

Comment Uboat.net is fairly reliable (there was a discussion on this at Milhist) and they give their sources here. Tonnage sunk is a fair marking of impact...

yesterday about three supports being recommended. I've suggested to the milhist people that they might take a look - the more the merrier. Thanks. I've...

listen to it!), and this is the device that started it all. It underwent a MILHIST A-class a while back and I've been letting it stew for a while since. But...

Comments: hello, PunkyNZ, I'm not sure if you have been involved in the Milhist A-class Review process before. If not, welcome. Please be aware that the...

as part of documenting the history of those regiments for WikiProject Milhist; also helping to increase the number of bios of notable women as a member...

others are not notable. Did not receive a notable military award per the MILHIST guideline, and more to the point these articles are nothing but stubs with...

requires administrative action. Second, I would like to be able to help tidy MILHIST project pages, and other routine deletions affecting articles in my areas...

addressed, so now I'm awaiting review from Milhist. The more reviews, the better, and the last time Milhist reviewed one of my articles, it was a positive...

beggar's diarrheal discharge"). Etc. And to say this is only obliquely a MILHIST issue is to fly in the face of every single source. Even Tauger, who might...

little consequence. The article underwent a GAN in September, and then a MILHIST A-class review in October. As always, all feedback will be gratefully received;...

as part of documenting the history of those regiments for WikiProject Milhist; also helping to increase the number of bios of notable women as a member...

about the article in its current state can be found at this version of the MILHIST talk page: [1] Additionally, the previous ACR was in 2008 and can be found...

vast sea of editors. MILHIST might be the only project that comes close on this. #2, I'd argue this is more a side-effect of MILHIST being an active and...

can we ban all WikiProject templates from redirects? I've seen too many MILHIST-tagged redirects that should not be tagged (only the article it redirects...

have been active as a MILHIST coordinator, being re-elected to a fifth term in September 2014. In this capacity I have assessed articles, closed A class...

already seen 10 of). It would really help the Milhist nominations if we could get a regular volunteer from Milhist helping out. - Dank (push to talk) 22:04...

enjoy article writing and reviewing (for instance at peer review, GA, Milhist A-class, or FAC). Of my contributions, I would say the articles that I...

received over the past month, can be found here. With most of our articles assessed as Stub- or Start-Class, there's a lot of work to be done. However, we...

15 March 2009 (UTC) Support - I was one of those who reviewed this for MILHIST's A-class rating. The only suggestion I have is to add locations and OCLC's...

received over the past month, can be found here. With most of our articles assessed as Stub- or Start-Class, there's a lot of work to be done. However, we...

understandable to a broad audience. (t · c) buidhe 23:28, 18 February 2022 (UTC) {{@Milhist}} Thanks everyone for their input. I am withdrawing this to nominate at...

these should all be changed into side menus below the infobox, like the WP:MILHIST {{Campaignbox}} series of templates. Go ahead and propose something like...

devoted years of his time and energy to the coordination and maintenance of MILHIST. (Awarded November 2023) Ian Rose: In recognition of his outstanding contributions...

Be careful that MILHIST doesn't become a place where that groupthink crowds out those who genuinely disagree, and another that MILHIST was counsel[ed]...

her to interact with many other projects as well. She participated in MILHIST's article assessment drive last year, and currently has 25 articles entered...

decade, with most of the work being done this past April. It went through a MILHIST A-class review after that, and has been waiting for me to have the time...

sure is interesting or unusual in my mind. I linked this to deletesort WP:MILHIST, I hope they have people with experience about similar articles and can...

seems to me that there are two opposing risks to allowing projects like MILHIST to tag the approximately 11,000 relevant pages they estimate exist. If...

org/navhist/battleships/us_dr.htm#nev-cl a reliable source? I believe so. All of the WP:MILHIST reviewers didn't have a problem with it in its A-class review. See below...

00:38, 3 November 2011 (UTC) Article has been reworked and expanded, please assess. Any constructive criticism would be appreciated. Outrune (talk) 00:11,...

have had this discussion ad infinitum in Milhist. Articles were adjusted to the satisfaction of the milhist coordinators by the editor(s). One editor...

Self-nomination. Listed as a "good article", assessed as "A-class" by WP:MILHIST, has gone through a couple of peer reviews. The article is based on the...

few years ago I produced an account of Rawlinson's career that satisfied MilHist A-Class requirements, but as coverage of his later life was next to zero...

no preview).Icewhiz (talk) 08:25, 5 December 2017 (UTC) We also have a MILHIST issue here, as this was the HQ of a militant group in 1977 Washington,...

still has a lot of interesting details, at least for those interested in MILHIST and in history generally. Also, its aftermath confirmed the isolationist...

John Tavares (ice hockey), and have started doing some editing with WP:MILHIST as part of their backlog drive. I am also active on the IRC -help channel...

(talk) 10:08, 24 August 2019 (UTC) I reviewed this article during its Milhist ACR, so I have very little to add: Luftwaffe doesn't need to be italicised...

your opinion, what are the main strategic directions to develop for the MILHIST project as of now? -- Grafikm (AutoGRAF) 21:15, 26 July 2006 (UTC) The...

combat during the Soviet invasion of Manchuria. The article passed GA and a Milhist A-Class review before I nominated it. Kges1901 (talk) 09:47, 14 May 2018...

Nick-D (talk) 23:52, 4 August 2012 (UTC) Support Reviewed/supported at MilHist A-Class Review, having found prose, structure, coverage, referencing and...

only WikiProject still producing top content is MILHIST. With a decades-old organizational history, MILHIST survives and thrives even with the decline in...

be best to incorporate them into a broader project (i.e. Terrorism -> Milhist, Spirits -> Food and drink) to keep them alive. I believe that organizing...

concerns about the blockings, noting that: “The blocks were done by a WP:MILHIST member, Nick-D, when the articles in question were ones regarding World...

awards that have similarly no refs but primary ones. I will in fact ping MILHIST project, because I think we need to add a section about military awards...

Renamed user df576567etesddf, WP Africa, WP Aviation, WP Cold War, WP Milhist, WP Politics, WP Rhodesia I am nominating this featured article for review...

ago (I happen to be a Milhist coordinator). Crisco basically isn't a Milhister, despite being signed up. There's your Milhist involvement. I tend to...

active editor since April 2007; a Milhist coordinator since August 2007; administrator since February 2008; Milhist lead coordinator since March 2008;...

focus. This type of approach appears highly successful at WP:BIOGRAPHY, WP:MILHIST and to a lesser extent WP:FILM. There obviously is a home here for both...

8 March 2019 (UTC) I went over this article with a fine tooth comb at Milhist ACR, have looked at the minor changes since it was promoted, and consider...

have had this discussion ad infinitum in Milhist. Articles were adjusted to the satisfaction of the milhist coordinators by the editor(s). One editor...

thread. The point about CANVASS re Nick-D and Milhist is because you are discussing the behavior of Milhist. When you are confused about something I say...

less active today than it was in 2010-2012, but the goal isn't to surpass MILHIST or WIR, just to make things easier for editors of Apple-related articles...

2016 (UTC) @Tisquesusa:, I wrote some code and started a discussion on WT:MILHIST; if that discussion results in a consensus for this task, I'll file the...

assessment class they really don't serve much purpose, though I think WP:MILHIST does active peer review and uses it. I'm not aware of any other active...

believe it now meet the definition of an FA. I have asked that its WP:MILHIST peer review be closed so I can get at least some FA comments before I have...

thought of the article. Clearly the subject is of little interest here on MilHist. Hawkeye7 (discuss) 21:20, 21 September 2020 (UTC) Given that the plans...

(talk) 07:34, 10 June 2018 (UTC) Support by PM I reviewed this in detail at Milhist ACR, and have looked at the copyedits and changes since 1 January when...

Also note that even though the banner and tags remain on the talk page, assessing a Future-class will remove the article from the bot's listing. Articles...

an odd case but I wanted to include it. Military History Wikiproject (milhist) has many "task forces". They really are only ways to sort topics and few...

October 2014 (UTC) Comment I've left a message at the MilHist project in the hope someone can assess the relevance of Aéro-Club de France, which is hard...

constitute the majority of Wikipedia's pages) a cut across both MED and MILHIST gets us a much more consistent cross section. However, we have a theory...

but "wikiproject[s]" by itself as a generic label is not: "WP:TOL and WP:MILHIST are two important wikiprojects, and WP:FAC is effectively a wikiproject...

others who come in to contribute to MILHIST or firearms articles. Nor have the rest of the firearms and MILHIST editors commented about trolling and...

Be careful that MILHIST doesn't become a place where that groupthink crowds out those who genuinely disagree, and another that MILHIST was counsel[ed]...

into question? And I see you're a MILHIST coordinator - couldn't we use the same logic to call some of the MILHIST FAs into question? --Rschen7754 00:38...

GraemeLeggett and Peacemaker67 who weighed in on the notability issue at WT:MILHIST. (t · c) buidhe 04:41, 18 December 2021 (UTC) Ref#2 ([1]) gives a 6 paragraph...

have advised them not to do so and raise the issue of "US claims" on the Milhist talk page to reach a consensus on this issue. Mztourist (talk) 05:55, 31...

implemented in this project after having been successfully implemented in WP:MILHIST, WP:MESO, WP:AZTEC where they are currently being used. I am willing to...

this discussion. Closed per MILHIST/Aviation cross-listing agreement, this is unnecessary as the article was promoted at MILHIST -MBK004 04:17, 31 March 2010...

matter for MILHIST to determine, it is a matter for the community. However, I have reviewed most MILHIST-tagged articles at FAC and Milhist ACR and a significant...

review is done ... prose reviews tend to be easy to come by, especially for Milhist articles. The table coding seems fine. I sampled the links in the table...

are other projects, which ban together on Wikipedia to do things (see eg Milhist and FAC, and those guidelines you mention) is just noting that it is not...

it. ;-) As far as producing results: it's been my experience (with WP:MILHIST) that the process is very helpful in motivating and tracking improvement...

Be careful that MILHIST doesn't become a place where that groupthink crowds out those who genuinely disagree, and another that MILHIST was counsel[ed]...

demand from MilHist Wikiproject in the future. Wikiproject Medicine benefited from such a triage of effort where articles that has not been assessed for years...

(UTC) Because if MILHIST says it's B-class, it's safe for me to copy that to another project, but if MILHIST says it's A-class, then MILHIST probably screwed...

Be careful that MILHIST doesn't become a place where that groupthink crowds out those who genuinely disagree, and another that MILHIST was counsel[ed]...

History of the Office of the Inspector General of the United States Army at Milhist ACR and FAC, teachable, temperament seems great, answer to Q11a is excellent...

"internally" is actually significant: those familiar with MILHIST expectations/standards/MOS and general milhist knowledge offer a much better critique and judgement...

Be careful that MILHIST doesn't become a place where that groupthink crowds out those who genuinely disagree, and another that MILHIST was counsel[ed]...

from MilHist to get one or more of your articles up to Featured Article. (They'll no doubt want you to add their B-class checklist to the MilHist talk...

Regarding the milhist template, removing empty B-Class assessment parameters can be inconvenient for editors that come along later to assess the article...

Be careful that MILHIST doesn't become a place where that groupthink crowds out those who genuinely disagree, and another that MILHIST was counsel[ed]...

(UTC) @Lyndaship and Silver seren: I intend to open a discussion at WT:MILHIST on the subject of auxiliary warships such as these once this discussion...

the WT:MILHIST archives, I participated in a discussion about the notability of ACW units, and expressed some general statements. That MILHIST discussion...

Be careful that MILHIST doesn't become a place where that groupthink crowds out those who genuinely disagree, and another that MILHIST was counsel[ed]...

admit that these examples are extreme in nature and off topic (this is a MILHIST article, the others are more or less FICTION articles) me concern is decidedly...

be making sure all your military history based RMs are notified on the MILHIST notice board, which to date you have avoided doing, be sure of that. No...

Lokshin, user:Roger Davies and user:Woody. All three are coordinators of the Milhist project, all administrators, and are in a more neutral position to comment...

and MILHIST A class review. This follows from earlier plagiarism panics at FAC, and long standing concerns with the research quality of MILHIST articles...

active editor since April 2007; a Milhist coordinator since August 2007; administrator since February 2008; Milhist lead coordinator since March 2008;...

Kierzek (talk) 20:18, 30 September 2016 (UTC) I posted a notification to the MilHist Talk page (link), but I see that I did not include the article name in...

(UTC) Support--Wehwalt (talk) 14:23, 28 October 2021 (UTC) Reviewed at Milhist's ACR, happy to support as FA quality. Iazyges Consermonor Opus meum 18:32...

BTW, just to comment on the 'MilHist example' point, as I've mentioned elsewhere to Sandy, a number of reviewers at MilHist A-Class level do image checks...

because it has recently undergone significant improvements through GA and MILHIST A-Class, and I believe it now meets the criteria for FA. It is a little...

new discussion about whether Milhist should adopt C-Class is underway. All comments are welcome. The 2008 Tag & Assess Workshop is still open, seeking...

beckoning for many members, this has been a quiet month on the talk pages for Milhist. (If you are facing exams yourself, we all wish you the very best of luck...

construction. Creators of all categories informed. Notice posted at WP:SHIPS, WP:MILHIST — Bellhalla (talk) 13:34, 14 April 2008 (UTC) Support rename I think this...

notifications on relevant Wikiproject talk pages if you wish (I'd suggest WT:MILHIST and Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Aviation. Nick-D (talk) 10:57, 23 February...

sources myself). Hog Farm Talk 19:10, 28 June 2022 (UTC) I've notified the MilHist and Aircraft projects. Hopefully this will bring more help.Nigel Ish (talk)...

those with a long track record in a narrow field, such as some of the MilHist editors, might skip it. This wouldn't help with points C1 and C2 above...

would suggest going to wikipedia's Military History wikiproject at WT:MILHIST and enquiring there. Skinny87 (talk) 12:27, 4 September 2009 (UTC) According...

that the Bot 1.0 be unblocked for 1 hour so I can update WP:MILHIST/Biographies and WP:MILHIST – Please? Adamdaley (talk) 03:08, 16 November 2018 (UTC) @Adamdaley:...

A-class criteria. --K.e.coffman (talk) 19:27, 17 March 2019 (UTC) @WP:MILHIST coordinators: I've advertised this on the main page, but I think it is...

because some projects have different criteria. (for example, I would trust a Milhist B class more than many others). If the articles is GA or higher though...

Military history A-Class promotion criteria are unique to our project, and assessing them requires an internal review. While anyone can file for, or comment...

already seen 10 of). It would really help the Milhist nominations if we could get a regular volunteer from Milhist helping out. - Dank (push to talk) 22:04...

date with Milhist articles needing copy input, just paste – {{WPMILHIST Copy-editing alerts}} onto your talk page. The debate on whether Milhist should adopt...

in policy much like WP:MEDRS. (WP:MILHIST editors would almost certainly offer opinion). If any article is MILHIST is has to meet a higher standard:...

looked further at the article as you had drawn attention to it. Within the Milhist and Aviation projects which I frequent, such tagging is commonplace and...

against Raul654 ([50], [51] [52]) and tried to unseat Nick Dowling as a Milhist coordinator ([53]). Perhaps the time has now come to consider either a...

Be careful that MILHIST doesn't become a place where that groupthink crowds out those who genuinely disagree, and another that MILHIST was counsel[ed]...

difference between a start class and a B class unless you're a part of MILHIST (and that is not a knock on them. They're just one of the few wikiprojects...

editors I've come across; I had the pleasure of serving alongside him as a Milhist coordinator for a while. He always impressed me with his ability to give...

meantime, I've contributed extensively to other WP:VG, WP:RELI, and WP:MILHIST-related topics. I've expanded and nominated two articles concerning medieval...

global assessment whenever the article falls under WP:MILHIST (with criterion 6 being always assessed as true). Hawkeye7 (discuss) 05:48, 7 February 2023...

comments. Nick-D (talk) 11:09, 1 July 2019 (UTC) I looked at this during the Milhist ACR, and could find precious little to nitpick about then. I have a few...

ago, and this seems to be an even more clear-cut case for deletion. WP:MILHIST doesn't appear to agree at all that any military commander of any notable...

(UTC) Support. I know from personal experience working with him in WP:MILHIST that he is definitely an asset to the project and should be even more so...

4th Baronet was assessed in 2012 by another editor. I want to ask people here, why was that editors' version of assessing WP:MILHIST acceptable around...

they are, one approach would be to encourage more projects to use the MILHIST system of tagging by B-class criteria; the talkpage template allows a more...

Be careful that MILHIST doesn't become a place where that groupthink crowds out those who genuinely disagree, and another that MILHIST was counsel[ed]...

Wikiproject (for instance the MilHist Proj seems to have a multiple-user assessment for A-class; others barely assess at all). Given my lack of familiarity...

(talk) 02:52, 6 July 2010 (UTC) Heho. The first edit was discussed at the milhist discussion. It was a very long and heated discussion. With many misunderstandings...

it'll need a significant amount of cleanup and the sooner I can let WP:MILHIST know the better :P I won't provide other diffs (though can if they're needed;...

attempted to apparently link me to an off-wiki account in this post to the WP:MILHIST noticeboard (diff) (revision deleted). This was done as part of an on-going...

but no levels in between; a few have Stub List (or SL) in addition; WP:MILHIST has CL, BL and AL, but not Good List (see WP:MHA#SCALE). --Redrose64 (talk)...

substantial changes to Wikipedia:Assessing articles there, one of which I reverted because it seemed to be stating that MILHIST's grading scheme was the standard...

Wikiprojects on the whole are dead (with a few notable exceptions such as MILHIST) and I honestly had no clue that the “WikiProject Council” even existed...

longer commenting on this thread. I am not opening up FOUR to a special MILHIST style collaboration. I don't want to wake up and see all of the battleships...

larger groups, like WPMED (92 regular participants on its talk page) or MILHIST (116 regular participants) or WPVG (84 regular participants), would have...

2021 (UTC) Agreed. --Hammersoft (talk) 16:17, 19 April 2021 (UTC) @WP:MILHIST coordinators: The editors above are sorting this out here, but as this...

Belfast. There is also a Canadian example: HMCS Algonquin. Be aware that WT:MILHIST is a place you can get advice. EdJohnston (talk) 17:04, 22 June 2019 (UTC)...

should develop its own guideline on what constitutes a B, C, etc. (like MILHIST's assessment is somewhat different from 1.0's criteria) to target articles...

them. They may have value in as part of a further reading section. Any Milhist types still lurking around who want to take a look at Otbergs recent edits...

(talk) 05:20, 7 December 2010 (UTC) Your inference, not my implication. MILHIST maintains a project newsletter which I see being added to the talk pages...

January 2018 (UTC) (edit conflict) See also this very recent thread at WT:MILHIST; TPH has been on something of a spree lately of nominating obviously-notable...

further expert input. Evident manipulation of sources, or disregard of a MILHIST consensus, should be considered disruptive editing and addressed via regular...

Legotech (2nd); Harland1 (3rd) and Smsarmad (4th). They helped assess 4303 B-class Milhist articles. Well done! To belatedly commemorate the first anniversary...

again in a bit. ——Serial # 15:10, 8 July 2020 (UTC) I dropped a note at WT:MILHIST for further investigation. Rgrds. --Bison X (talk) 17:29, 8 July 2020 (UTC)...

together to improve a group of articles within their projects scope. WP:MILHIST focuses on military subjects, WP:WIRED seeks to improve the coverage of...

impartial milhist User who will either pass the page or submit it to AFD. I will recuse myself from all involvement until after the Milhist review. Mztourist...

and outside of the scope of this project (and sometimes overlapping WP:MILHIST, WP:PINOY, WP:RIGHT, & WP:WPAA). I am interested in military history, and...

project (usually one I have some faith in the class being correct like MILHIST, USRoads, NRHP and a few others) run through that and then pick the next...

been looking through FAR and FAN in order to better fulfill my role as milhist coordinator. Generally, when there are this many delist votes it goes to...

purpose of A class in what is admitted only a few wikiprojects (most notably MILHIST) that use it, but just like C class, it gives them more flexibility. Making...

review A-class articles. Some people have raised concerns that only WP:MILHIST has proper facilities to review A-class articles, and I wish to create...

(talk) 03:10, 14 June 2021 (UTC) In accordance with discussions at WT:MILHIST I now propose a Wikipedia:Topic Ban for J-Man11 from military and order...

the page and am about to add a link to the projects talk page so other milhist editors can help this article. Hypnosadist 20:19, 21 June 2007 (UTC) Lummee...

Be careful that MILHIST doesn't become a place where that groupthink crowds out those who genuinely disagree, and another that MILHIST was counsel[ed]...

Flaherty, Hal Jespersen, Eb.hoop, Hartfelt, WP Science and academia, WP Milhist, WP Louisiana, WP Ohio, WP Georgia, WP Missouri, WP St Louis, talk page...

WT:MILHIST. Buckshot06 (talk) 08:50, 24 February 2013 (UTC) Seems to be an extension of an ongoing content dispute, which has also reached WT:MILHIST — Crisco...

effort, however. • Astynax talk 20:47, 29 May 2011 (UTC) MILHIST has a banner which assesses articles in a more thorough way than we do, and I think that...

2013 (UTC) Likewise. I've never done an RFCU, but as a coordinator for milhist I feel I've an obligation to the editors of the project to resolve this...

Following my flagging up an individual editor's assessment of articles at WT:MILHIST#Assessment problems, discussion has evolved on the subject of assessment...

that link in the template is so nice-looking and non-obtrusive, and it's MILHIST which is actually an active Wikiproject. I think this should be determined...

have been active as a MILHIST administrator, being re-elected to a fourth term in September 2014. In this capacity I have assessed articles, closed A class...

contribution history. His talk page history is basically limited to two things - MILHIST newsletters and warning notices. Beyond that, having now had his whole...

when Dragovit added coats of arms to some well-watched articles under WP:MILHIST (although this apparently started well before that, if I look at their...

twice would be very stupid. The "C" class is entirely optional, I know milhist are having a discussion on whether it is worthwhile implementing it. I...

won't be telling readers anything they don't already know. I'll notify WP:MILHIST. --BDD (talk) 17:47, 9 December 2019 (UTC) Delete Redirect should not be...