DOKUMEN123.COM

arbitrators are subscribed to this list. Shortcut WP:ARBCOM#LISTSWP:ARBCOM#LISTS In addition to the arbcom-en list, the Committee operates several other official...

A statement from Jimbo Wales about recent events: I have encouraged the ArbCom to move slowly and thoughtfully. Gather all the facts. Don't have a public...

← return view all tags → All articles tagged "arbcom" News and notes Beeblebrox ejected from Arbitration Committee following posts on Wikipediocracy 2023-12-04...

The Tides of March at ARBCOM: After a fairly tame February, ARBCOM had a lot on its plate this month. ← Back to Contents View Latest Issue 31 March 2019...

proposal concerns the access and handling of confidential information by arbcom members and oversighters. And also changes policy concerning the granting...

arbcom-en (arbcom-enwikimedia.org) is the primary mailing list of ARBCOM business. arbcom-en-b (arbcom-en-bwikimedia.org) and arbcom-en-c (arbcom-en-cwikimedia...

review by The Arbitration Committee ("Arbcom"), per existing policy that de-sysopping is under their remit. And Arbcom can of course independently choose...

A quiet month for Arbcom: No valid new requests for arbitration, no new cases. ← Back to Contents View Latest Issue 1 October 2018 Arbitration report Contribute...

user's agreement. JohnCD (talk) 19:48, 4 June 2013 (UTC) User:Viriditas/Arbcom (edit | talk | history | links | watch | logs) Page does not appear to have...

proposal concerns the access and handling of confidential information by arbcom members and oversighters. And also changes policy concerning the granting...

decided to have the full ArbCom consider such appeals (along with their existing work hearing appeals to AE blocks and ArbCom remedies), and disband BASC...

that, in giving this guidance, Arbcom has exceeded its remit by straying into ruling on content matters. Since Arbcom voted to accept the case on 30 November...

Arbcom looking for new checkusers and oversight appointees while another case opens: TRM, CUOS '16, R&I, RfC ← Back to Contents View Latest Issue 29 September...

08:09, 30 October 2007 (UTC) Shortcuts WP:TROUBLESWP:TROUBLES WP:ARBCOM/TROUBLESWP:ARBCOM/TROUBLES Case Amended by motion on 14:32, 27 October 2011 (UTC)...

active case: GiantSnowman asked to chill, and other disputes addressed by Arbcom (or not). ← Back to Contents View Latest Issue 24 December 2018 Arbitration...

the case, it is "to review whether a desysop is in order for Salvidrim". Arbcom has stated that if the case isn't decided by the end of December – when...

principle campaign pledge for ArbCom is always to keep in mind the goal of writing a high-quality encyclopaedia. All ArbCom decisions must make it easier...

collaboration issues: Politeness and collegial behavior about to be taken up by Arbcom, and perhaps a revisit of the infobox question. ← Back to Contents View...

discussion, which took place as part of the planning phase of the 2008 Arbcom Election. Some reforms were adopted, others not. More information may be...

January 2012 (UTC) Collect's suggestion is a good one, as it's the same thing Arbcom has suggested to Mathsci several times over the past year. The offending...

Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee/Anti-harassment RfC The RfC is part of the Arbcom–WMF understanding reached in the wake of last year's events covered in The...

 Mastodon  LinkedIn  Facebook  X (Twitter)  Bluesky  Reddit By Bri and Kudpung Arbcom is about to decide how we talk about this. The evidence phase closed 13...

"discussions involving (i) the conduct of an arbcom-l subscriber or (ii) cases, broadly defined, to which an arbcom-l subscriber is a party". The Arbitration...

your comment has not appeared here, you can try purging the cache. The Arbcom is, and has been for a long time, drunk on power, arbitrary and often irrational...

the Arbitration Committee and is composed half of arbitrators and half of ArbCom-appointed community representatives. To file a complaint, please e-mail...

went to Arbcom. The argument to send it there was that a widely supported community indef might be reversed by some random admin. But I think Arbcom should...

to shuffle candidates Hello, I'm Wugapodes, and I am willing to serve on ArbCom. I view Wikipedia as a community of practice organized around the development...

assess the level of community trust in him; the fact that we were having an Arbcom case at all, became part of the issue. Salvidrim! was transparent about...

not appeared here, you can try purging the cache. It is a sad day when Arbcom so completely get things wrong. Unless we are to count our blessings that...

looks likely) the result will be: Arbcom is asked for clarification of a previous injunction. Instead of clarifying, Arbcom declares the community sanctions...

A long break ends: Arbcom takes its first new case since June. ← Back to Contents View Latest Issue 1 December 2018 Arbitration report Contribute   —  ...

considerable differences between arbcoms on different projects. In the article I already alluded to the late founding of the German arbcom. And it seems that at...

Arbcom case, all parties generally come out worse off. The amount of work to raise an Arbcom is significant. There's all sorts of reasons that Arbcom...

This project is defunct. Its major role has been taken over by WP:ARBCOM. Some notes on how to handle editors who are problematic in this area: Never call...

closed and two opened: The Banning Policy case was closed on 12 October. Arbcom affirmed that users have "considerable leeway" in terms of how their talk...

block, send it to review by WP:OPP If the block is an Arbcom block, direct the user to Arbcom list If the block is for anonymous only IPs, direct the...

return to beginning Please contact the Committee's main mailing address at <arbcom-enwikimedia.org>. If your account has email enabled, you may alternatively...

return to beginning Please contact the Committee's main mailing address at <arbcom-enwikimedia.org>. If your account has email enabled, you may alternatively...

committee (commonly known as ARBCOM). Do not bring cases to ARBCOM unless the matter has been looked at by the other areas; ARBCOM is the final step in the...

had been covered up by Arbcom or at their request, that Arbcom had been aware that the PumpkinSky account was Rlevse, that Arbcom supported the PumpkinSky...

ArbCom election Contribute   —   Share this  PDF download  E-mail  Mastodon  LinkedIn  Facebook  X (Twitter)  Bluesky  Reddit By Flcelloguy Related articles...

protects · deletions · moves) I'm Doug Weller and have been a member of ArbCom for two years. I've had this account for 10+1⁄2 years and have a dormant...

their own." An unprecedented "topic moratorium" was proposed by active Arbcom member David Fuchs. One quarter of the twelve active arbitrators recused...

alternative desysoping procedure based on community input, but does not involve ArbCom. (For example, opening a specific form of discussion on WP:AN/I.) However...

English Wikipedia to established local processes. We also acknowledged that ArbCom has struggled to handle civility and harassment complaints in a way that...

Modification of WMF protection brought to Arbcom: The Wikimedia Foundation's Director of Community Advocacy's application of pending changes level two...

net-negative for Arbcom. Arbcom needs diversity of opinion. Besides civility, I would strive to help out with transparency. Arbcom, for better or worse...

taken back to Arbcom if it's one that really must be considered by arbitrators. The ARC will not review a matter recently decided by Arbcom. Its role is...

ArbCom candidates Contribute   —   Share this  PDF download  E-mail  Mastodon  LinkedIn  Facebook  X (Twitter)  Bluesky  Reddit By Flcelloguy Related articles...

ArbCom update Contribute   —   Share this  PDF download  E-mail  Mastodon  LinkedIn  Facebook  X (Twitter)  Bluesky  Reddit By Flcelloguy Related articles...

committee set up to mentor people put on probation or mentorship by either the Arbcom or the Wikipedia community. Those watched will be informed by us. A bot...

resulted in a community ban, and the other is undergoing discussion at Arbcom and noticeboards with at least three administrators asking for revocation...

for candidate statements from those wishing to run in the December 2006 arbcom elections. Anyone with over 1000 edits as of 01-October-2006 on en.wikipedia...

over arbcom would mean that arbcom is no longer the last step of dispute resolution. A higher-arbcom (arbiter) would face the same issues arbcom is facing...

December 9, 2018. A unanimous decision to reopen the case was reached by Arbcom on March 5 after receiving a communication from Jytdog expressing the wish...

Hi. Given Arbcom's importance and the small field so far, I ask for your support for this nomination. Background I joined Wikipedia in April 2007 and became...

discussed here. Pseudoscience – outcome pending as of publishing deadline Arbcom member DGG included this statement in his decision: [This case has] helped...

net-negative for Arbcom. Arbcom needs diversity of opinion. Besides civility, I would strive to help out with transparency. Arbcom, for better or worse...

categorically withdraw any comments which indicate concern about precedents and/or ArbCom as a whole. KillerChihuahua?!? 21:48, 27 June 2008 (UTC) At least they now...

through Wikipedia if you have registered a email address or directly to arbcom-enwikimedia.org if you have not registered an email address or been blocked...

WMF Legal and ArbCom weigh in on tension between disclosure requirements and user privacy: The two statements prompt extensive community discussion; plus...

ArbCom election—candidates’ opinions analysed: Our annual election coverage. ← Back to Contents View Latest Issue 18 November 2015 Special report Contribute  —  ...

I decided to run for ArbCom because reform is so urgently needed. I want ArbCom to take the lead in solving problems. ArbCom needs greater transparency...

(All participants are subject to Arbitration Committee decisions, and the ArbCom will consider each participant's role in the dispute.) Comments are very...

I've been troubled by Arbcom for a while. This recent thread illustrates the issue [1] (also [2]). Since I've not been able to change the committee from...

and sex differences in head size and IQ" 00:21, 9 February 2012: "Your Arbcom links are irrelevant..." Claim that edits not covered by this case. 01:24...

Wikipedia:Adminship coaching with tools RfA reform proposal Wikipedia:Arbcom electoral reform Wikipedia:ArbCom reform Wikipedia:Areas for Reform Wikipedia:Deletion reform...

[or] (c) people associated with (a) or (b), all broadly construed". When ArbCom grudgingly accepted a GamerGate case in November (the third such request...

ArbCom announcements Contribute   —   Share this  PDF download  E-mail  Mastodon  LinkedIn  Facebook  X (Twitter)  Bluesky  Reddit By Ral315 In the wake...

ArbCom tries to keep the peace at internet encyclopedia". Arbcom keeps the peace The Wall Street Journal, by Corinne Ramey, May 7 (paywall). ArbCom member...

CheckUser and Oversight permissions: The following is an ArbCom internal process. It supplements the ArbCom procedure on CheckUser/Oversight permissions and inactivity...

I am throwing my hat in the ring and signing up as a candidate for Arbcom this round. I held off out of concern about time committments, but have decided...

million dollars, total budget of 4.6 million Fundraising Blog [4] Arbcom 101 [5] Arbcom elections update? Raul654 selects someone else to act as a proxy...

time to run for arbcom. I'm certainly well aware of what arbcom does having been involved in everything from unofficially getting the arbcom elections to...

decisions of previous Arbcom findings and remedies that were ignored. So it comes back to Arbcom to reconsider, like any other Arbcom remedy that has proven...

the receiving end of various debates, enforcements etc from Arbcom, Arbcom's clerks, Arbcom's admins, it's evident to me that communication and empathy...

Deletion review Wikipedia:April Fools' Main Page Wikipedia:Rules for Fools Arbcom case arising from 2016 April Fools activities {{AprilFoolsNotice}} {{April...

role of the Mediation Committee with respect to its relationship to the Arbcom role of the Association of Members' Advocates with respect to the overall...

 – iridescent 11:19, 23 November 2010 (UTC) ArbCom and policies: Do you agree or disagree with this statement: "ArbCom should not be in the position of forming...

Arbcom election procedures, Wiki Loves Monuments, Privacy policy, FDC, and more: As mentioned in "In the news" on Wikipedia's main page, the Library of...

could not unblock themselves, and with Arbcom removing the block there is no need for the desysop. However, Arbcom had access to secret evidence that I...

performing internal tasks such as coordinating the sometimes-overwhelming arbcom-l mailing list traffic. A: Generally, all of these. Being active in the...

steadily, as User:Wyss, about 4 years ago. I've been an admin for 6 months. Arbcom is meant to deal with behavioural worries. It is in no way a means of handling...

Non-admin arbitrators? Since several ArbCom candidates are non-admins, editors have asked whether non-admin ArbCom members should be granted the admin...

I have a good amount of experience with the arbcom, having, I believe, a record for number of cases involved in. I have a lot of respect for what the job...

fledgling institution. With a series of personnel and process changes, the arbcom has become a more effective institution that is able to work through a case...

German ArbCom implodes: The German Wikipedia's Arbitration Committee loses more than half its members amid political feud ← Back to Contents View Latest...

Arbitration Committee is not bound by Wikipedia RfCs and AN cannot override any Arbcom decision. We are, however, free to advise the Arbitration Committee, which...

as he wishes to remain on a break. Reducing Burnout of ArbCom Members: Right now, an ArbCom term is 3 years. I dare you to find ANYONE in this world...

as-is? Or should they be reverted per policy? The request was voted down by Arbcom 0/6/0, then withdrawn. A workaround was enunciated by Black Kite and endorsed...

ArbCom election Contribute   —   Share this  PDF download  E-mail  Mastodon  LinkedIn  Facebook  X (Twitter)  Bluesky  Reddit By Flcelloguy Related articles...

an administrator. I am volunteering for this role because I believe in Arbcom as a necessary part of the Wikipedia ecosystem. It helps to safeguard the...

decisions of previous Arbcom findings and remedies that were ignored. So it comes back to Arbcom to reconsider, like any other Arbcom remedy that has proven...

response to any and all unblock requests Runs for arbcom Gets onto arbcom Runs subsequent times for arbcom They try to remove this essay or any such essay...

recommendations in some cases where arbcom members may be involved or a particular case is critical of some aspect integral to arbcom in some way. Thus, if folks...

mailing lists that have official status with the Wikimedia Foundation (OTRS, Arbcom-l, and Checkuser-l in particular), the consequences for such improper disclosure...

recused themselves for this case. This leaves the majority for the case under Arbcom rules as six. The most severe proposed remedy, "Kudpung desysopped", was...

And the arbcom has also claimed Phil used private information, but that's just casual defamation (which is an unfortunate thing for the arbcom to be getting...

strongest opinion on Arbcom, and my takeaway lesson from WP:FRAMBAN in 2019, is the need for a strong, active and vibrant Arbcom to ensure the community...

the name of "MaliceAforethought" began leaking selected email threads of Arbcom-l, the Arbitration Committee's non-public mailing list, on Wikipedia Review...

Template:Arbcom proposed (talk · history · transclusions · logs · subpages) This template sets a very dangerous precedent, because it implies that arbcom can...

an administrator. I am volunteering for this role because I believe in Arbcom as a necessary part of the Wikipedia ecosystem. It helps to safeguard the...

desysops, blocks, unbans [9][10][11][12][13] first formal apology for poor Arbcom case management, in a ruling [14] first effective system for documenting...

Hi. Given Arbcom’s importance and the fairly limited field so far, I ask for your support for this nomination. Background I joined Wikipedia in April 2007...

while Arbcom remedies can be effective, they can also create rifts in the community that can never be resolved fully. Furthermore I feel that the Arbcom case...

actual harasser. The problem now is less the fault of the bullies than with ArbCom. I’ve never really considered myself to be a feminist – it just hasn’t been...

ArbCom will only hear appeals of bans imposed by ArbCom, full stop. Let the community (try to) handle the rest, and the community can approach ArbCom...

rough draft of my ArbCom request that was at my talk page;[40] I changed every aspect that KC now criticizes, prior to submitting the ArbCom request here....

July 2008 (UTC) As I replied to a query on my user talk page, I asked on ArbCom and got good replies about the reason. I'm still looking into the situation...

would you reform ArbCom? And how can editors be sure that you will stay true to your promise? Reply See #arbcom_reform_objectives Arbcom questions 2008...

community. Note that disclosure of your account history, pursuant to the ArbCom selection and appointment policy, must be made in your opening statement...

question. If Arbcom were a legal process, I'd say balance of probability, but it's not. As nobody's life, liberty or property is in jeopardy at Arbcom I'm not...

purging the cache. Just a small point - I do not believe that the Gamaliel arbcom case scope covers Gamergate. The clerks are removing evidence of Gamaliel's...

purpose of my candidacy is to gauge general community disaffection with Arbcom as well as with this year's list of candidates. If elected, I pledge to...

I'm afraid. Giano 13:06, 2 November 2007 (UTC) As functions assigned by ArbCom, describe your view on the assignments of Oversight and Checkuser permissions...

It appears that arbcom is likely to end up rather larger than it has been in the past, and that's a good thing; with a larger arbcom, the work can be...

I agree with the thinking behind it; in the absence of a governing body Arbcom has by default picked up a lot of powers it never really wanted and isn't...

years, and an admin for about 30 months. I've always been disturbed by Arbcom's ability to miss the point and ignore obvious implications of all issues...

year, looking through the cases, understanding the ways and means of WP:ARBCOM, and the benefits and flaws this system entails. This year, I believe I...

edition dates back to 2004, I was sysop, helped on mediation groups was arbcom clerk. But then at some point I decided to stay away from this wiki. Not...

look at the advantages. There will always be enough arbcom members. Because of the above, arbcom members will have to hear fewer cases (each), possibly...

2004, and I thought that I might as well throw my hat in the ring here. Arbcom is an important mechanism for resolving disputes and solving problems that...

arbcom is unable to solve complex problems. Many people to date said this... I know all too well. But complaining alone never fixes problems. Arbcom has...

since May 2006, and an admin since March 2007. I am nominating myself for arbcom as I feel I have some attributes which may be of benefit to wikipedia in...

ArbCom update Contribute   —   Share this  PDF download  E-mail  Mastodon  LinkedIn  Facebook  X (Twitter)  Bluesky  Reddit By Flcelloguy Related articles...

to run - but some recent arbcom decisions, combined with concern over lack of candidates interested in actively guiding arbcom decisions towards increasing...

Dec 2004 (UTC) A more detailed statement is available at User:Blankfaze/Arbcom. I believe that one thing the Committee needs is people with copious amounts...

can be enforced by ordinary admins. You will have to request help from ArbCom itself, via e-mail or by posting to the Requests for clarification section...

to make one. A few in fact: RE: ARBCOM Arbcom as a means to resolve content issue. - Personally I'm not sure Arbcom is the way to go here. Firstly because...

This page was created for an arbcom review Initial response More detailed response Continued disruption by proxy Further response prior to posting of motion...

question answering for a few days. I'll be back on it tonight (Thursday). Arbcom (if appointed) would be easy compared to the sheer amount of typing here...

supported by at least six other administrators, it may be referred to Arbcom. Arbcom shall then consider whether an administrator: 1) still enjoys the confidence...

discussed privately but these are always affairs for the Arbcom rather than a general admin. Regarding Arbcom deliberations many problems can be solved by common...

know this was valid? Hipocrite (talk) 14:57, 6 March 2009 (UTC) Comment to ArbCom Thank you for your haste in dealing with this. It is appreciated. Hipocrite...

in December 2007 and January 2008, has been officially withdrawn by the Arbcom, because "a series of significant irregularities occurred" which "resulted...

 E-mail  Mastodon  LinkedIn  Facebook  X (Twitter)  Bluesky  Reddit By Bri Arbcom to editors: Be nice to others here ... or else. Also in New Jersey. Civility...

for the following people to make up the Electoral Commission for the 2017 ArbCom elections: 1. User:Ritchie333 2. User:Yunshui 3. User:Ymblanter (resigned...

asked by John Reid. 1. Who are you? 2. Are you 13? Are you 18? 3. Should ArbCom arbitrate policy disputes or any other matter outside user conduct issues...

decision#Running for new timeline (sort of). Last minute update: as we go to press, Arbcom voting has not completed, and the only posted Proposed Remedy is desysopping...

'anon' talkpage edits with User:Lir; Snowspinner attempted to abuse the arbcom parole ruling by arguing that the IP was either someone impersonating Lir...

meaning I see between the two with regards to arbcom is the treatment of arbcom's inaction. In one it's arbcom must act, otherwise the community's consensus...

content Three weeks in the land of featured content Arbitration report Arbcom looking for new checkusers and oversight appointees while another case opens...

replied to our questions; their replies will be added as they are received. ArbCom candidate profiles:    A-F  |  G-K  |  L-S  |  T-Z  |  All  |  (Withdrawn)...

toolset to ArbCom business only would be difficult to enforce. An overwhelming majority of editors opposed retaining adminship after ArbCom, while a closer...

period, and only twelve candidates. I wanted to ensure that we had a solid arbcom, and was worried that we would have an insufficient candidate pool. Apparently...

frameworks laid down by the foundation, the community makes policy – not arbcom. Arbcom interprets and applies. However where policy is unclear, or non-existent...

confirm this is an IP sock to confirm whether enforcement of the cited ArbCom ruling is appropriate. Suspect user has past history of sockpuppetry and...

colours their Arbcom judgements. IMO what the current Arbcom doesn't need is pomposity, self importance, aloofness and verbosity. Arbcom needs far more...

the purposes of an Arbcom case, as LHvU mentioned above. If it become apparent that it is being used otherwise, and that the Arbcom case is not going forward...

of ARBCOM who are also members of Wikipediocracy. Discussions of ARBCOM confidential business by me will not be on Wikipediocracy, but on ARBCOM channels...

because my perception is that Arbcom's remit is, very gradually, expanding, and I think there should be a discussion about Arbcom's scope and the potential...

and injunctions. A: Over the last year Arbcom has desysopped a number of admins. Generally do you think Arbcom have (a) not desysopped enough (b) got...

previous usernames at his RfA has been a matter of some contention during the ArbCom case). Other points made by parties have concerned: Fæ's uploading to Commons...

period, and only twelve candidates. I wanted to ensure that we had a solid arbcom, and was worried that we would have an insufficient candidate pool. Apparently...

argument for which he was deadmined. Based on statements from members of the arbcom, we believe that this was meant as a temporary measure, a cooling off period...

common sense). Having some experience in many wiki-roles I realized that Arbcom is very important for the project. Wikipedia is done by volunteers; if it...

– You quoted the Arbcom there. Honestly, I don't give a damn what Arbcom thinks about this. I'm perfectly prepared to IAR the Arbcom here. Fut.Perf. ☼...

goes to Arbcom. Parties of the conflict can appeal the results of RfS to Arbcom. Every administrator should enforce the same way as the Arbcom decisions...

rather than the goal. Once Arbcom was given permission to decide the case itself, I regained my adminship. I followed the Arbcom Fram case with great interest...

long-term ArbCom members? Pretty soon were going to require Bodhisattvas with Semicha from Moshe. I'd add in being saints but we need ArbCom members who...

free to ask any questions of me you'd like I've been fairly critical of arbcom on a number of levels for quite a while, and feel it's only fair to stick...

request has stemmed from a privacy rename passed to Arbcom at the end of October last year that needed Arbcom agreement. Somehow it got overlooked, and it wasn't...

problematic. Large inter-admin disputes are extended and drama-filled. Arbcom is overloaded and overworked. Concerns are sometimes raised about the status...

take the right approach. There are two important issues surrounding the Arbcom that influence why I'm running. The first is that we need more visible Arbitrators...

ArbCom case "Gamaliel and others" concludes: The final results of the heated case ← Back to Contents View Latest Issue 5 June 2016 Arbitration report Contribute  —  ...

involved" in this whole wide area. In fact, right until the very days of that Arbcom case I was frequently congratulated on how well I was doing my admin work...

without gaining consensus on the talk page (and even so, the decision of the arbcom seems to prohibit any reverts to Ashlee Simpson articles beyond those reverting...

but what would you do to improve the enforcement of ArbCom decisions? What is your take on an ArbCom decision being read or not read as a precedent for...

desysops, blocks, unbans [9][10][11][12][13] first formal apology for poor Arbcom case management, in a ruling [14] first effective system for documenting...

suitability of ArbCom candidates. Other than a general view of how responsible and well-meaning they seem, we aren't selecting ArbCom members with the...

The last thing I wanted to do is run for arbcom, but from my dealings with the system at Wikipedia:Requests for arbitration/Pigsonthewing, I feel that...

highlighted concerns that the community had including: The Arbitration Committee (ArbCom) process is unnecessarily difficult Administrators who make unpopular calls...

(All participants are subject to Arbitration Committee decisions, and the ArbCom will consider each participant's role in the dispute.) Comments are very...

As functions assigned by ArbCom, describe your view on the assignments of Oversight and Checkuser permissions, including thresholds for (or even the possibility...

arbitrator, on becoming aware of the emergency, will send a brief message to arbcom-l (a) stating the name of the account involved, (b) providing examples of...

by: applying to the Arbitration Committee by emailing the committee at arbcom-en-cwikimedia.org, which are welcomed at any point in the year; or watching...

Committee elections continue; ArbCom member resigns 16 January 2006 ArbCom candidates (part two) 9 January 2006 ArbCom candidates 2 January 2006 Straw...

If your comment has not appeared here, you can try purging the cache. Arbcom vote to take the Clean Wehrmacht case advanced after the publication cutoff;...

sometimes-overwhelming arbcom-l mailing list traffic. A: In my previous time at Arbcom I did all these extensively (at that time Arbcom handled ban appeals...

mediation case [3] and presented my first substantial arbcom evidence [4] in November 2004, my first full arbcom case in December 2004 [5], followed by involvement...

Infodump: WP:NPOV m:NPOV m:Foundation issues Arbcom precedent: Statement(s) of principle It is inappropriate to remove blocks of well-referenced information...

There seems to be a lot of complaints about arbcom and how it runs. Whether it's because the members aren't open in their discussions, preferring to hold...

are about one thousand admins, and about a dozen arbcom members, so the process to become an arbcom member may be expected to be one hundred times harder...

and any new comments in the ongoing arbcom, the arbcom forum is open and more appropriate. The creator is under Arbcom review and should not be expected...

closures, RfA, AN, ANI, Arbcom cases, policy making, etc). What's the reason for your choice? A: Before I did my stint at ArbCom a couple of years ago,...

comment has not appeared here, you can try purging the cache. So I guess Arbcom will now also declare the outcome of the review to be "not satisfactory"...

inappropriate situations after being asked multiple times by arbitrators to stop. Arbcom has requested that Mathsci drop this issue at least four times: [1] February...

their identity is very important. Does that answer your question? Which ArbCom cases have affected you the most personally as a Wikipedian, even when you...

guidelines first, and then email any arbcom member or the Arbitration Committee's private mailing list, [email protected]. Application is...

membership changes - By Arbcom decision on its own discretion, or following ratification by Arbcom of a group decision. Arbcom to be informed - The discussions...

second time this had been to arbcom and the decision was extremely weak, basically asking editors to cooperate. If arbcom takes a case, they should be...

strongest opinion on Arbcom, and my takeaway lesson from WP:FRAMBAN in 2019, is the need for a strong, active and vibrant Arbcom to ensure the community...

to see a solution that strongly enforces the principles of the existing Arbcom ruling and the basic requirements of etiquette, civility, no personal attacks...

No further edits should be made to this discussion. In that case, the ArbCom took the line that userspace is not to be used to keep "laundry lists of...

Wikipedia. Arbcom has not been helping. I ran for Arbcom before, in 2010. I didn't do so well. I was thinking sort of tactically at the time. The arbcoms elected...

opposition, etc. But as a general rule, I should think arbcom decisions should always be liftable by the arbcom as well as by the community. Phil Sandifer 18:04...

appeals to arbcom. Arbcom should give clear advice on future appeals by SightWatcher. I am surprised he did not consult arbcom privately, on arbcom-l, before...

the receiving end of various debates, enforcements etc from Arbcom, Arbcom's clerks, Arbcom's admins, it's evident to me that communication and empathy...

for most of the year and have had some pretty low opinions of serving on Arbcom in the past. Well, times change and they've certainly changed me. As to...

(All participants are subject to Arbitration Committee decisions, and the ArbCom will consider each participant's role in the dispute.) Comments are very...

be made to this discussion. User:Colonies Chris, a party to the current ArbCom "date-unlinking" case, has been blocked by the trainee clerk on the case...

productive. Nikkimaria (talk) 19:12, 18 March 2014 (UTC) User:Giano/The day the Arbcom trashed the civility policy in order to shaft Eric Corbett (edit | talk...

replied to our questions; their replies will be added as they are received. ArbCom candidate profiles:    A-F  |  G-K  |  L-R  |  S-Z  |  All  |  (Withdrawn)...

following markup: #{{ACE Question |Q=Your question |A=}} You are a 2014–15 Arbcom member, but why not attend Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December...

really. This is because by the time anything reaches ArbCom, it is already helplessly fucked up. ArbCom only gets things once everything else has failed,...

anyone else? a. Yes, to a point. Too often we've seen last-minute changes by Arbcom that are then seemingly rushed through. Some reasonable allowance should...

appeal" really does need to be arbcom or at least arbcom members, since only they have such access. I realise that arbcom wants to drop some of its many...

purpose of my candidacy is to gauge general community disaffection with Arbcom as well as with this year's list of candidates. If elected, I pledge to...

11 November 2009 (UTC) Extremely large attack page, presumably about an ArbCom case to be filed at some point. However, the page seems to consist solely...

support. Leaning towards support; Anyone who has been trying to help with ArbCom since 2011 is likely serious.--Mr. Guye (talk) 22:06, 22 November 2016 (UTC)...

year. All subcommittee memberships will be reviewed after the December Arbcom elections. ← Previous "Arbitration report" Next "Arbitration report" → In...

Marco Polo article he quite flagrantly ignored the instructions of the ARBCOM and reverted on several occasions this week (on the same article). (To whom...

Hi. Given Arbcom's importance and the small field so far, I ask for your support for this nomination. Background I joined Wikipedia in April 2007 and became...

importance of the ArbCom elections and making wise, informed decisions when they vote. Elections to ArbCom are very important because the ArbCom is very important...

11/2/2007 Hi, Arbitration cases typically do take "too long". After all ArbCom pretty much only deals with the most complex disputes that require careful...

section will include active RfAs, RfBs, CU/OS appointment requests, and Arbcom elections. StringTheory11 ← Previous "Discussion report" Next "Discussion...

Seigenthaler panel Erasing obvious vandalism from database BLP - Brian Peppers and limiting article sizes “Arbcom” equivalent for content Wikia search...

time to run for arbcom. I'm certainly well aware of what arbcom does having been involved in everything from unofficially getting the arbcom elections to...

initially wanted to run for arbcom, then decided not to, and now (at the last minute), I've decided to go for it. I've been around arbcom for a while. I've never...

asking besides that. You can't have a situation where people believe the Arbcom's completely unwilling to change its mind. 2) If a decision of yours, while...

to the Wikimedia Foundation. Applicants should self-nominate by email to [email protected] and will receive an application questionnaire which...

for the candidate • Comment on the candidate • Discuss the candidate The ArbCom has made a lot of progress the last two years, and it would run counter...

to arbcom proper. As I see it an individual arbcom member has no authority beyond that of user, parties should direct their communication to arbcom as...

discussed privately but these are always affairs for the Arbcom rather than a general admin. Regarding Arbcom deliberations many problems can be solved by common...

resysopping (or declining to resysop) at ARBCOM. Or alternatively, if a crat finds themselves before ARBCOM (yes, ARBCOM members are always going to have to...

then came back as SevenOfDiamonds (talk · contribs) and was then banned by ArbCom, and recently came back as I Write Stuff (talk · contribs) and was banned...

edit is participant's talk pages, WP:AN, WP:CSN, and various pages in arbcom's space. Some details on its workings can be seen at User:Thatcher131/Sandbox3...

present involvement in Arbcom cases he appears to be shallow and non-investigative. These are not traits we want at Arbcom. Arbcom needs people willing...

On June 6th, 2020, ArbCom opened the long awaited RfC on Anti-harassement. The questions from Arbcom deal mostly with how Arbcom should deal with harassment...

solicit clerk assistance in an on-wiki forum. An IRC channel, #wikipedia-en-arbcom-clerks connect, also exists for informal coordination and discussion of...

time to run for arbcom. I'm certainly well aware of what arbcom does having been involved in everything from unofficially getting the arbcom elections to...

individuals commenting at the request for an Arbcom case. Bri.public (talk) 17:07, 1 August 2019 (UTC) The ArbCom case request was never about the future of...

ArbCom election Contribute   —   Share this  PDF download  E-mail  Mastodon  LinkedIn  Facebook  X (Twitter)  Bluesky  Reddit By Flcelloguy Related articles...

role as a member of Arbcom. Research is allowed and encouraged. There is clear agreement that all is not well, in all ways, at Arbcom. Many users standing...

sockpuppets and trolls. But let this not blind you to the virtue of ANI, SPI, and ARBCOM as there is little more satisfying than having your opponent on that Brony...

editor by the WMF last year, the Arbitration Committee resolved to hold a Arbcom RfC regarding on-wiki harassment. A draft RfC has been posted at Wikipedia:Arbitration...

time they feel they need to intervene at this level. This whole thing put Arbcom in a very tough spot, as process-wise it needed to be completely reversed...

five "best" contributions to Wikipedia. Will you be voting in this year's arbcom elections? Why/why not? Thank you and good luck. Giggy (talk) 02:45, 6 November...

appeal to ArbCom no less than 6 months after the closure of the case." means that Ryulong has the right of appeal to Arbcom in this case. So Arbcom should...

years, and an admin for about 40 months. I've always been disturbed by Arbcom's ability to miss the point and ignore obvious implications of all issues...

both on his talk page and the arbitration noticeboard, he claimed that ArbCom has become politicised to the extent that "it can no longer do the job it...

underated topics in wikipedia and would toughened up for the arbcom workload. I read almost every arbcom case since late 2005, and I am experienced with how they...

you say that Duncharris ? The Arbcom suggested that I add to other subjects, noting to do with Vietnam. If the Arbcom suggested ALL royalty on wikipedia...

role as a member of Arbcom. Research is allowed and encouraged. There is clear agreement that all is not well, in all ways, at Arbcom. Many users standing...

Wikipedia for a few years now, but have always shied away from a run at ARBCOM. My primary joy is adding content to the project. I also get satisfaction...

similar situations in the future. On September 21, the Arbitration Committee (Arbcom) case stemming from the incident was closed. Findings reaffirmed usual policy...

neutral view. The ArbCom needs a fresh approach to things, and I feel I can bring that to the ArbCom. I'm willing to recuse from any ArbCom dispute I may...

feedback. Since 2009 appointments arose from internal vetting discussion (Arbcom affirms its trust in each resulting candidate), followed by a community...

Wikipedia: Could this be a new relationship between the Foundation and ArbCom, and between the Foundation and enwiki? ← Back to Contents View Latest Issue...

temporarily removed). If Arbcom has not come to a decision by the end of the 7 days, the adminship is temporarily restored. Arbcom then has an additional...

resigned from the Committee on 23 May by posting an open e-mail (sent to arbcom-l on 20 February) on his userpage and by posting the following announcement...

Merridew has asked the Arbitration Committee to review and lift his ban. (arbcom clarification, User:Jack Merridew, SSP case, RFCU case, Wikipedia:Administrators'...

given that Arbcom - as Arbcom - was attempting to broker a solution. While one understands its desire to do so, it is not in the remit of Arbcom to do this...

absence - after a year of almost no edits, and then straight back into an ArbCom run - and lack of recent contributions will keep me from supporting some...

and Speedy Deletion. Debate ensued, rapidly leading to the filing of an ArbCom case. As of this writing, nine of the 14 arbitrators – a clear majority...

unexpected trails of odd editing behaviour. I very rarely participate in Arbcom but I certainly follow the high profile cases; I only post when I really...

highest court and 'last line of defense', Arbcom is slow-moving and boring place by comparison. That makes Arbcom a doddle to report; the thought of having...

rather than the goal. Once Arbcom was given permission to decide the case itself, I regained my adminship. I followed the Arbcom Fram case with great interest...

Wobbly start to ArbCom election, but turnout beats last year's: At the time of writing, this year's election has just closed after a two-week voting period...

I step forward, because I think that Arbcom should be more diverse. A greater diversity at Arbcom would not save the world by itself, but could give a...

How, in practical terms, can the ArbCom support dedicated editors? Can you address the "actively cultivate, nurture, and sustain" remark in a more specific...

also); (I) Internal tasks such as coordinating the sometimes-overwhelming Arbcom-l mailing list traffic, reminding colleagues of internal deadlines, and...

contentious enough to bring before Arbcom. Whatever isn't solved by Arbcom eventually goes to Jimbo, and thus Arbcom has an important role in keeping issues...

been around the block a few times and seen at first hand how the current Arbcom ply their trade. It's unsatisfactory in several regards, and recently has...

account (remembering of course to inform Arbcom per Wikipedia:Sock puppetry#Legitimate uses by emailing arbcom-llists.wikimedia.org) Write an article that...

steadily, as User:Wyss, about 4 years ago. I've been an admin for 6 months. Arbcom is meant to deal with behavioural worries. It is in no way a means of handling...

by email to arbcom-en-cwikimedia.org. Each candidate will receive an application questionnaire to be completed and returned to the arbcom-en-c mailing...

B, violation of Arbcom ruling. IP edit-warring on Dutch language against Rex Germanus (talk · contribs) in contravention of the Arbcom revert parole on...

be, is not appropriate within the consensus-driven editing process. The ArbCom decision does not have the bias that some blogs and news sources are reporting...

Obligatory greeting. Generic roundabout statement that Isarra is running for arbcom that never actually answers the question of why and instead devolves into...

their place, and produce an encyclopaedia. I think a key for a successful Arbcom is to have a mix of interests. Some of the candidates (and the sitting Arbs)...

Salvidrim! Comment on the candidate below or by email to the Committee - arbcom-en-clists.wikimedia.org Community consultation period is 1 to 12 August...

resysopping (or declining to resysop) at ARBCOM. Or alternatively, if a crat finds themselves before ARBCOM (yes, ARBCOM members are always going to have to...

in fact, she doesn't play around at all. Red: Are you sure this is where ArbCom dropped the thermostat control? Blue: No, but look at the chilling effect...

the 18 ArbCom seats, & if everyone votes "None of the Above", the ArbCom will have no members & won't function at all. If you don't like the ArbCom, there...

blocked me for a week, saying that I violated my "arbcom-imposed parole". In fact. there was no "arbcom-imposed parole". They only thing he could have meant...

since 2011. I have helped out by working on a few articles, acting as an arbcom clerk and handling routine admin tasks as well as the occasional OTRS request...

community. Note that disclosure of your account history, pursuant to the ArbCom selection and appointment policy, must be made in your opening statement...

been there for two days, someone brought it to my attention and I filed an ArbCom enforcement request. It appears that during his Wikibreak, Mathsci investigated...

leak of information from arbcom-l, for which Elen was responsible. She has quite clearly violated the confidentiality of Arbcom's communications. I would...

ArbCom is not "claiming authority" over the ArbCom. It's simply saying that the community has no power to decide to de-admin someone and the ArbCom got...

resolve issues in good faith and this culture is overburdening the arbcom. The arbcom can discourage this by making it clear that all allegations against...

I was elected to Arbcom in 2009 on this statement, and resigned in December of the same year with this statement. Due to the timing of the events that...

process for revoking that access. At present there is no such process and ArbCom are reluctant to take on this issue, some members seeing it as falling outside...

around another admin, as opposed to acting on a principle for how I think ArbCom should act. Best, Barkeep49 (talk) 19:04, 8 March 2022 (UTC) So after thinking...

Cassianto is still on a self-imposed block set to expire in about 60 days. Will Arbcom create new policy for this apparently volatile area? Probably not if Opabinia...

I'm 27 :( 3. Should ArbCom arbitrate policy disputes or any other matter outside user conduct issues? Why or why not? I believe Arbcom should NEVER be involved...

of ArbCom]. Quite amusing, coming from a former arbitrator. Anyway, my point is, Community vs. ArbCom Decisions. Can the community overrule an ArbCom decision...

for a topic ban, should ArbCom impose one without specific findings of any violation of a policy or guideline? 1) Yes. 2) Arbcom should have the authority...

Ched :  ?  05:51, 5 November 2015 (UTC) Well that should be interesting as Arbcom handles cases which the community seems to be unable to resolve by itself...

Durova case, Wikipedia:Requests for arbitration/Durova/Proposed decision Arbcom elections: candidates must be 18 years old New Executive Director Sue Gardner...

ArbCom remedy To address the extensive edit-warring that has taken place on articles relating to The Troubles, as well as the Ulster banner and British...

Does the arbcom have this power? Should it? Various arbcom decisions (can't find a link right now - bonus points for finding a link to an arbcom decision...

community. Note that disclosure of your account history, pursuant to the ArbCom selection and appointment policy, must be made in your opening statement...

the same time I feel that the arbcom should have a streamlined system to deal with such blatant abuses and that the arbcom should be strict but fair whenever...

18 months. In that time, I've been discouraged by how many times I see Arbcom basically missing the point of the cases brought before it. I've watched...

December 2007 (UTC) Delete. this attack page against me should be deleted. The arbcom case has been settled and there is no reason for these attacks on me, most...

suggestion that "Arbcom will establish and maintain and over time improve: a policy on transparency that will provide for accountability of Arbcom members through...

free to ask any questions of me you'd like I've been fairly critical of arbcom on a number of levels for quite a while, and feel it's only fair to stick...

Be aware, those of you looking for dramatic change to Wikipedia through Arbcom, I'm not your person. I'm a firm believer in much of the foundation of Wikipedia...

anything remotely uncivil." Arbcom's actions have come under scrutiny from the outside press lately. Do you think the Arbcom has a role in educating reporters...

resolved}} If the dispute resolution proceeding does not involve Arbcom, you can use |arbcom=no to suppress the link to the Arbitration policy, and to change...

of ARBCOM who are also members of Wikipediocracy. Discussions of ARBCOM confidential business by me will not be on Wikipediocracy, but on ARBCOM channels...

with it [2]. As for my block evasion, I acted on the basis of WP:5P5, but ArbCom acted on solid legal grounds and I respect its decision. So I cleared my...

community. Note that disclosure of your account history, pursuant to the ArbCom selection and appointment policy, must be made in your opening statement...

January 2010 (UTC) What did the Arbcom do about it? Ikip 13:26, 27 January 2010 (UTC) I don't know if its been to Arbcom or who if anyone has admitted being...

I've been troubled by Arbcom for a while. This recent thread illustrates the issue [1] (also [2]). Since I've not been able to change the committee from...

were also not part of the ARBCOM. FeloniousMonk is abusing his authority by claiming everything is related back to this ARBCOM decision. Diffs like this...

section will include active RfAs, RfBs, CU/OS appointment requests, and Arbcom elections) Wikipedia:Requests for adminship/Adjwilley Start WeRelate as...

challenge to the project. Arbcom's actions have come under scrutiny from the outside press lately. Do you think the Arbcom has a role in educating reporters...

by email to arbcom-en-cwikimedia.org. Each candidate will receive an application questionnaire to be completed and returned to the arbcom-en-c mailing...

the unknown 3rd party. Vote for me if you're disillusioned. I think that Arbcom has become too slow and bloated in the last year. Cases are piling up and...

The Founder retired; if Arbcom doesn't, who will? In any case, I'm not the only one who's promoted a greater scope for the Arbcom, and there seems to me...

who bravely implement ArbCom sanctions, and are in danger of "upsetting" scores of editors. I'd much rather see a streamlined ArbCom process for handling...

text is in the original). It means what it says, but in the context of the Arbcom, no outcomes are reached by one member alone, so there would have to be...

suggestion that "Arbcom will establish and maintain and over time improve: a policy on transparency that will provide for accountability of Arbcom members through...

understand the importance of the ArbCom elections and making wise, informed decisions when they vote. This is my first ArbCom election for which I am an active...

based on. Also, I may be asking about specific things outside the scope of ArbCom; your answers would be appreciated regardless. What originally led you to...

communication, so I'd somehow enforce 'arbcom will communicate better' as policy :-) 7. Please rank these in order of whom the Arbcom serves and answers to, in order...

(UTC) Rarely accomplishes anything except increasing the probability that Arbcom will accept the case --Ryan Delaney talk 06:25, 7 February 2006 (UTC) Ambi...

WP:Synthesis. As per Arbcom rulings. Sarah777 (talk) 17:28, 22 March 2008 (UTC) What? Sorry, I don't understand this vote at all. Have ArbCom ruled that the...

(All participants are subject to Arbitration Committee decisions, and the ArbCom will consider each participant's role in the dispute.) Comments are very...

procedure to avoid a proposed or accepted ArbCom case accepting a recall procedure Ultimately Bureaucrats and Arbcom make such judgements. The key point is...

twenties.Blnguyen (bananabucket) 07:08, 30 November 2006 (UTC) 3. Should ArbCom arbitrate policy disputes or any other matter outside user conduct issues...

If your comment has not appeared here, you can try purging the cache. Arbcom always mystifies me. For example the MOS case reads "Arbitrators' opinion...

applied to two editors who posted a link on Sandstein’s talk page to an old Arbcom case that contained the previous username of Prioryman. Clarification and...

(All participants are subject to Arbitration Committee decisions, and the ArbCom will consider each participant's role in the dispute.) Comments are very...

upcoming arbitrator elections "RFC on the platform of the ArbCom Reform party for the 2013 ArbCom elections" Music genre field in infoboxes Does the Four...

community. Note that disclosure of your account history, pursuant to the ArbCom selection and appointment policy, must be made in your opening statement...

applied to two editors who posted a link on Sandstein’s talk page to an old Arbcom case that contained an editor’s previous username. A proposal has been made...

September 2. ArbCom member KrakatoaKatie, writing for the committee, and announcing closure of an 18 August 2019 request for an Arbcom case, stated "The...

current ArbCom processes in place? I don't think there's any single mechanism that would work here in all cases. I can't comment on arbcom's current practices...

form of this project. ==Moderators== There shall be three, appointed by Arbcom. What is their role(s) What are their Goals ==Members== Listed elsewhere...

section will include active RfAs, RfBs, CU/OS appointment requests, and Arbcom elections) Wikipedia:Requests for adminship/Acather96 "A new draft of the...

licensed content to the public; if I have a "platform" here, it is to center arbcom's activities on supporting that mission. I'm also a woman in a predominantly...

Wildthing61476 21:16, 27 November 2006 (UTC) As functions assigned by ArbCom, describe your view on the assignments of Oversight and Checkuser permissions...

before the candidate guide was first published, in the November 24th issue. ArbCom candidate profiles:    A-F  |  G-K  |  L-S  |  T-Z  |  All  |  (Withdrawn)...

and I have formally advocated on two Arbcom cases as well as in many other instances that didn't involve Arbcom. It's my belief that dispute resolution...

near as real time gets on wikipedia discussion regarding the recent events involving WP:ARBCOM Durova Mitchazenia Seddon69 Shoemaker's Holiday MBisanz...

preference. The letters for each link mean the following: a = experience with arbcom; c = conflict resolution; e = remarkable editing contributions; m = mediation...

discussion was no consensus at this time. Consensus may be possible once the ArbCom motion/case has run its course.--Aervanath (talk) 10:19, 24 January 2009...

no need to email me - I believe in transparency, it's very important at Arbcom. If I come across an unblock discussion I was in, I'll let you know. Kudpung...

for edits that did not violate a single term of the restrictions from his arbcom enforcement. "Broadly interpreting" [1] and [2] as substantially amounting...

This ruling also shows that is should be easier for the Community and the ArbCom, to desysop an admin after two admonishments. Reading it from the sideline...

saintly standards). No, an edit expressing widefelt frustration with an ArbCom post is sufficient to ban me. I would like to state empathically, if someone...

an administrator. I am volunteering for this role because I believe in Arbcom as a necessary part of the Wikipedia ecosystem. It helps to safeguard the...

metaphorically. Arbitration report The Tides of March at ARBCOM After a fairly tame February, ARBCOM had a lot on its plate this month. Traffic report Exultations...

staying cool despite serious tensions there. Unfortunetely, after a month, an ArbCom case was filed and checkuser revealed that one side was just meatpuppets...

Committee. Risker (talk) 16:13, 5 October 2011 (UTC) The edits graph is for all arbcom activity (Special:RecentChangesLinked/User:Jorgenev/arbcomwatchlist). "Pages...

our community are a model for how society as a whole could be run. While ArbCom is a part of our community - it is not above or separate from it, it is...

by email to arbcom-en-cwikimedia.org. Each candidate will receive an application questionnaire to be completed and returned to the arbcom-en-c mailing...

needs a strong and decisive arbcom that can solve problems quickly before they flare up into serious issues, and not an arbcom that is seen to conduct its...

myself of a general nature, before I realized that Lightmouse was under ArbCom sanctions. This is documented at: User_talk:Lightmouse/Archives/2010/October...

Sysop Tinucherian removed and admonished by the ArbCom: And don't bite those newbies! ← Back to Contents View Latest Issue 1 May 2025 File:Keep Out (9759656102)...

clarity. Having recently been involved in such an Arbcom case and incident, where one active Arbcom member voting in a case defended his right to discuss...

July 2008 (UTC) Reply to statements I can understand why folks want the ArbCom to focus on current issues instead of this, which is why I hesitated to...

arbcom. In the past, such as with NSLE and JoshuaZ, the arbcom has acted without formal public proceedings and has never indicated that past arbcoms should...

in ARBCOM elections than at RFA. Furthermore, ARBCOM is supposed to deal with Wikipedia's nastiest conduct issues; we really want people on ARBCOM who...

December 2017 (UTC) Why did you not run for adminship first before running for Arbcom given the fact except perhaps one arb long time ago was elected as a non...

Wizard Blocking IP addresses Range blocks IPv6 Open proxies Banning policy ArbCom appeals Sanctions Personal sanctions General sanctions Contentious topics...

conspiracy innuendo into Kennedy assassination related articles. From the Arbcom decision, RPJ was placed on indefinite probation. "He may be banned from...

neutrality and civility, as the prior two ArbCom cases indicate. The specifics of the initiation of this ArbCom case, ARBPIA3, were related to the use of...

31 December). Since a case on desysopping Hemanshu has been filed with Arbcom, it is desirable to have as good evidence on this as possible. Though a...

section will include active RfAs, RfBs, CU/OS appointment requests, and Arbcom elections) None as of the time of writing this report Make detailed information...

the ArbCom case to be the venue because the Clerks have both experience and appropriate authority to maintain decorum, ArbCom are involved (and ArbCom is...

of ArbCom]. Quite amusing, coming from a former arbitrator. Anyway, my point is, Community vs. ArbCom Decisions. Can the community overrule an ArbCom decision...

community. Note that disclosure of your account history, pursuant to the ArbCom selection and appointment policy, must be made in your opening statement...

ArbCom election Contribute   —   Share this  PDF download  E-mail  Mastodon  LinkedIn  Facebook  X (Twitter)  Bluesky  Reddit By Flcelloguy Related articles...

familiar with the case by now. I think Arbcom should decide on this case per arbcoms past decline rationale [3]. Arbcom should not be completely bypassed and...

You mean, without an arbcom decision that a particular user should be blocked for his/her actions? Without a ruling from arbcom, I would follow the blocking...

Hello all. I’m Worm That Turned and I thought I’d throw my hat into the Arbcom ring. As Arbitration is the final level of dispute resolution, I feel that...

candidates on the individual nomination subpages (or privately via email to [email protected]) until 23:59, 21 March 2011 (UTC). The Community...

section will include active RfAs, RfBs, CU/OS appointment requests, and Arbcom elections) None at the time of this writing Make detailed information on...

in and clarifies an arbcom ruling 13, and that appears to resolve the dispute. On the 16th, Redwolf24 requests to reopen the arbcom case, saying the dispute...

filter log · block user · block log) Previous declined Arbcom case. Most recent AN/I. Going to arbcom over this is like using a sledgehammer to crack a nut...

This is also posted to the Arbcom page. However, this case was handled so badly by the arbcom, that I would like a parallel community re-evaluation. Thank...

Sorry, I'm (deliberately) not really up to speed on the ins and outs of arbcom. There's a notice on the article's talk page that says "After a suitable...

lucky to have some talented folks working beats like News and Notes and the ARBCOM report, the WikiProject report, the top ten, etc. Just the same, I know...

activity but this does not mean that I already know everything about how Arbcom works. I've instigated some changes to Wikipedia and campaigned hard for...

section will include active RfAs, RfBs, CU/OS appointment requests, and Arbcom elections) Wikipedia:Requests for adminship/Kelapstick 2 Make detailed information...

community. Note that disclosure of your account history, pursuant to the ArbCom selection and appointment policy, must be made in your opening statement...

they are aware of specific areas subject to DS. In order for it to work, ArbCom needs to modify the DS Awareness section to include some form of mandatory...

added the Arbcom warning tag as it would appear that Dingoes Ate My Baby qualify as TV characters, therefore are subject to the current Arbcom freeze. 23skidoo...

favouritism or discrimination has made him a role model for adminship and Arbcom. I've known and collaborated with WTT since long before he was an admin...

circumstances arbcom is familiar with. Arbcom to date has not made a very serious attempt to resolve this dispute so far and I'd ask arbcom to perhaps shoot...

February 2010 (UTC) Unneeded fork of WP:IECOLL. Possibly also in violation of Arbcom decisions on the subject, but that's not clear. SarekOfVulcan (talk) 23:27...

official policy or guideline?" "RFC on the platform of the ArbCom Reform party for the 2013 ArbCom elections" Music genre field in infoboxes Proposed updates...

online battles are juxtaposed with stories about cooperation and good deeds, Arbcom hovering over it all; notwithstanding, a good action movie script is not...

James' talk page when he noted that ArbCom has not unblocked Jytdog, ArbCom has not declined the appeal, and ArbCom appeal discussions take time. I am...

Iffy posts this Arbcom request. Leviv ich 02:42, 3 May 2019 (UTC) From restoration to ANI in 45 minutes; from restoration to Arbcom in two hours eight...

observing the recommendation/suggestion/whatever-the-heck-that-was, that the ArbCom did in the Betacommand case. Bellwether BC 01:47, 12 May 2008 (UTC) Oh,...

must notify Arbcom and resolve the matters at issue. Your clarification would be appreciated. Also, what is the procedure for notifying Arbcom when I have...

true for wikipedia's ArbCom. To come directly to the point, in my opinion the biggest problem with the ArbCom is the way the ArbCom gathers information...

issue, or bring them to ArbCom. As this is a one-off (and fairly unique) situation it is too soon for either the community or ArbCom to be looking into it...

by email to arbcom-en-cwikimedia.org. Each candidate will receive an application questionnaire to be completed and returned to the arbcom-en-c mailing...

community. Note that disclosure of your account history, pursuant to the ArbCom selection and appointment policy, must be made in your opening statement...

User:Diyako) Wikipedia:Requests for arbitration/Aucaman Had 1 year ban by arbcom which recently expired on 14:01, 7 May 2007 Artaxiad (talk+ · tag · contribs ·...

replace it with another sa200nction if deemed necessary. In October 2016, ArbCom determined, among other things, that The Rambling Man had been incivil and...

2007 (UTC) The case of User:Halibutt is indeed one very important to this ArbCom case. Halibutt was once a very active member of this project, among the...

pseudo-legalistic approach arbcom has codified in ARBPOL is based on the modern legal standards of fairness and disclosure, the approach ARBCOM are taking shares...

current membership of 18, including Kirill Lokshin and Casliber of the ArbCom. See here for the membership. SlimVirgin talk|contribs 17:00, 11 July 2009...

continue edit warring on various articles and bait users restricted by arbcom parole. Here's the latest revert by anon IP without any discussion on talk...

certain circumstances, one of these being under instruction from Arbcom following an Arbcom decision to desysop. Although they possess the tool, Bureaucrats...

editing atmosphere on wikipedia. Arbcom's actions have come under scrutiny from the outside press lately. Do you think the Arbcom has a role in educating reporters...

Interface Admin policy proposal, part 2 Arbitration report A quiet month for Arbcom Traffic report John McCain's death generates over 7 million hits, followed...

dedicated body like the arbcom is able and trusted to do that. enochlau (talk) 01:56, 18 January 2006 (UTC) Arbcom, arbcom, arbcom. This has the same problems...

the intention. Sometimes people write lengthy posts at WP:ANI, or propose Arbcom cases, or use the images on this page, in hopes of defusing a situation;...

would prefer not to have to appeal this at all. There is nothing in the "ArbCom sanctions regime" that even suggests violating policy in this way. --Obsidi...

agricultural chemicals. Scr★pIronIV 20:14, 17 December 2015 (UTC) I urge ArbCom not to fall into the futility of trying to micromanage remedies. The remedy...

common sense. If you think arbcom needs it, vote for me. If you think ‘hell no,’ then vote for the other guy. I believe arbcom’s task is to create an environment...

voting to accept the case cited the lack of resolution to issues at the Arbcom case brought concerning the same administrator this past June. However,...

also appropriate under Arbcom enforcement, I suppose that is icing on the cake. · jersyko talk 17:10, 7 March 2008 (UTC) What arbcom case is this from? —...

Link is not on the whitelist. Link is not on the monitor list. I hate Arbcom (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · blacklist hits · Edit filter search ·...

thereof) in the past, on why editors must understand the importance of the ArbCom elections and making wise, informed decisions when they vote. I do not have...

discussion took place on the case pages, comments elsewhere speculated that "ArbCom wanted to punish two users from each side of the dispute to demonstrate...

section will include active RfAs, RfBs, CU/OS appointment requests, and Arbcom elections) None at the time of writing this report Trademark practices Create...

between ArbCom and the community. This proposal has been developed following a lengthy discussion at ArbCom and therefore reflects current ArbCom consensus...

since there are no active ArbCom sanctions in effect on me: all sanctions were formally lifted by a motion initiated by ArbCom in mid-December. (My self-imposed...

fluctuating IP is immediately blockable under WP:SOCK and doesn't need Arbcom sanctions to justify it. In any case, Ceedjee was notified of ARBPIA in...

evidence they have chosen to do so in this case. Arbcom cannot alter policy in general, and Arbcom deciding Arbcom policy would be particularly naughty. But...

enforcement against other problematic users, and I would be surprised if the arbcom did. A further piece of evidence as well. I encourage anybody to look at...

a Sergeant of the Wikipolice, use {{User wikipedia/Police Sergeant}}. (Arbcom only) To place this userbox to identify yourself sworn in as an Inspector...

December 2009 (UTC) Well, he certainly was upfront in citing the numerous ArbCom cases in which he's been cited, but I wouldn't consider them illustrations...

(depending on how you count), including a 1-year block approved by the ArbCom. He has now engaged in disruptive reverting here (April 30 through May 13)...

status of sanctioned parties is. There seems to be no one-stop shop from the ArbCom page, where an admin can easily look up the remedies that apply to a particular...

until December 2. The Arbitration Committee's email address has changed to arbcom-enwikimedia.org. Other email lists, such as functionaries-en and clerks-l...

participant on wikien-l, etc. If elected to arbcom, I would, I imagine, change virtually nothing. The arbcom generally makes sound decisions, and I have...

link to the arbcom decision after deletion? Enochlau 05:05, 21 Jun 2005 (UTC) Delete. Seems to me that this userpage is in violation fo a Arbcom ruling and...

them a barnstar. If the ArbCom finds their contributions helpful, the ArbCom can speak up. (Or the editor can ask the ArbCom.) If those helpful users...

by specific policies". I am not violating any general rules nor specific arbcom terms. If "reverting upto 30 articles at once" is supposed to be disruption...

Omura/BDORT articles per the ArbCom decision. Crum375 was involved in the ArbCom dispute, but no action was taken against Crum375 by ArbCom. (My involvement is...

ensues. Arbcom has the potential to deal with problems that are beyond the abilities of any one administrator. To realize that potential, Arbcom has to...

01:53, 28 Mar 2005 (UTC) ArbCom should actually cover IRC as well. JuntungWu 12:55, 16 Mar 2005 (UTC) Yeah. And give ArbCom power over the largest ten...

Clerks - a proposal for a new role to oversee the RfA process, similar to Arbcom clerks. Minimum requirement - a (perennial) proposal to put in a minimum...

appealed Octavian history's block to the Arbcom, see Wikipedia talk:Requests for arbitration/Octavian history; Arbcom elected to leave the block in place....

deletions". DC 12/9/0: "... arbcom needs a few fresh faces.... This isn't to say all current arbs should be voted out.... Arbcom needs a balance, and there...

clarification to turn into a proxy ArbCom case on the subject. Steve Smith (talk) 12:26, 18 July 2010 (UTC) It is my view that ArbCom-issued cautions are not suitable...

on arbcom itself and the smaller number of people on arbcom, I'd rather give the community a chance to discuss it before bouncing it up to arbcom. I am...

wanted outside comments from non-involved people) were harassment. The arbcom agreed and instructed me to stay away from him after the 2007 case Wikipedia:Requests...

replied to our questions; their replies will be added as they are received. ArbCom candidate profiles:    A-F  |  G-K  |  L-R  |  S-Z  |  All  |  (Withdrawn)...

much as I hope Arbcom eventually becomes obsolete. Courcelles (talk) 19:20, 27 November 2018 (UTC) What is ArbCom useful for? Arbcom has two primary...

dispute ? Nothing. Solving content disputes is not the job of Arbcom.  · What do I think, as an Arbcom candidate, about the behaviour of the various people that...

secret committee that puts articles under sanctions. By the actions of arbcom articles are put under sanctions. ARBPIA for instance use language like...

arbcom member and/or allowing more time and energy for a longer examination of a particular case? If yes, what would be the optimum number of arbcom members...

but to seek the community's views as to: Under what circumstances should arbcom remove functionary rights (checkuser, oversight, functionaries mailing list...

2004, and I thought that I might as well throw my hat in the ring here. Arbcom is an important mechanism for resolving disputes and solving problems that...

process or as a result of a ruling by ArbCom. My reasons for doing so are stated in this post. I refer this action to ArbCom for review and scrutiny. I will...

appreciate a good piece of pie from time to time. There has also been talk that arbcom needs more diverse voices - members from different backgrounds and perspectives...

request Arbcom cases, clarification and amendment. Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Enforcement: request administrator enforcement of Arbcom decisions...

(This section includes active RfAs, RfBs, CU/OS appointment requests, and Arbcom elections.) None at time of this writing Round 2 of the Wikimedia Commons...

Should Arbcom be dictating the answer to that question? In my opinion it should not, Arbcom does not create policy. As NYB comments, Arbcom has does...

regarding an administrator editing through protection on an article with Arbcom sanctions was declined, after the editor in question self-reverted the edit...

been around the block a few times and seen at first hand how the current Arbcom ply their trade. It's unsatisfactory in several regards, and recently has...

section will include active RfAs, RfBs, CU/OS appointment requests, and Arbcom elections) None active as of the time of this writing Wikivoyage logo voting...

section will include active RfAs, RfBs, CU/OS appointment requests, and Arbcom elections) None at time of this writing "A new draft of the trademark policy...

2006 Arbitration Committee elections: Candidate profiles 27 November 2006 ArbCom elections: Information on elections 13 November 2006 Arbitration election...

TDC's. About a day later, he was unblocked by an admin observing that the ArbCom remedies had expired and that a 3RR block should be twenty-four hours long...

One of the annoying things about the Arbcom Committee (there aren't many, I think they tend to do a very, very good job) is how they're all "insiders"...

replied to our questions; their replies will be added as they are received. ArbCom candidate profiles:    A-F  |  G-K  |  L-S  |  T-Z  |  All  |  (Withdrawn)...

a Signpost exclusive, Jimbo Wales has announced the results of the 2007 ArbCom elections. In an e-mail sent to us Wednesday morning, Wales named six new...

such abuses—is already a function of ArbCom. If ArbCom isn't being used effectively for that, then perhaps ArbCom needs some fixes, or at least clarification...

an Arbcom member? Any Wikipedia editor may propose policy this is generally done at Wikipedia:Village pump (policy). Being a member of the Arbcom does...

this way and operating alongside Arbcom, with the wide administrator and user support of Arbcom, would replace Arbcom entirely. It might not get this degree...

to this discussion. Closing Statement: Requests for comment which review Arbcom, project bureaucracy/governance and use of private checkuser information...

adminship, some have criticized past decisions (of various kinds, communal, arbcom etc), a few have been mediators and others "just good editors" or administrators...

affected by an Arbcom decision should have wide latitude to criticise Arbcom if they feel the need to. Anyone else should be free to criticise Arbcom too—though...

what did you learn about ArbCom over the last two years? If you were Queen of the Universe, what would you change about the ArbCom process? I learned that...

from the elections; their responses have been archived here for reference. ArbCom candidate profiles:    A-F  |  G-K  |  L-R  |  S-Z  |  All  |  (Withdrawn)...

also known as Tom in the real world. I am an newish admin and arbcom clerk. I ran for arbcom in December and came in three places behind the last arb to...

sufficiently motivated by their findings to help with the case itself via the arbcom, this is not a part of their mandate—should they do so, they are acting...

arbcom works for the editors, not the other way around. Arbcom needs the community to support and carry out its rulings, or it is powerless. Arbcom has...

Aug 2004 (UTC)] 01:28, 26 Jul 2004 I'm running now because I think the arbcom needs dedicated, serious people to shoulder serious responsiblity. I've...

regarding an administrator editing through protection on an article with Arbcom sanctions. Clarification request:Race and intelligence: A request made by...

willingness to unblock. What new evidence will the arbcom get if this was taken to arbcom? Arbcom will deliberate over the same mangled and confusing...

interacted with WMC previously. This sort of behavior is in violation of the Arbcom ruling Wikipedia:Requests_for_arbitration/Privatemusings#Sockpuppetry which...

arbitrator, on becoming aware of the situation, will send a message to arbcom-en (a) stating the name of the account, (b) briefly describing the issue...

communications as an Arbcom member—within the committee and/or with the Wikipedia community? –Outriggr § 07:34, 29 November 2007 (UTC) 1. Can/should Arbcom create wikipedia...

investigation. 08:53, 18 November 2021 (UTC) Standards for Evidence: Suppose ArbCom has accepted a case that involves two users: User A and User B. User A and...

sincerely, what the arbcom needs. Breath of fresh air. Martinp23 00:24, 3 December 2007 (UTC) For actually wanting the hellish job that is arbcom (and not being...

meaning I see between the two with regards to arbcom is the treatment of arbcom's inaction. In one it's arbcom must act, otherwise the community's consensus...

(talk) 17:38, 19 December 2012 (UTC) We delayed publication to write up the Arbcom results. Ed [talk] [majestic titan] 22:03, 19 December 2012 (UTC) And aren't...

years, and an admin for about 30 months. I've always been disturbed by Arbcom's ability to miss the point and ignore obvious implications of all issues...

opening statement and answers to questions, do you actually want to be on ArbCom? If so, can you explain why, without being as offhand as you have been so...

possibility that the excessive preoccupation of the Arbitration Committee (Arbcom) with its own rules and discipline were leading to greater and greater displacement...

authorization. What would you do about the subcommittee if you were elected to ArbCom? Thank you for these questions Guerillero. A subcommittee such as this,...

"without ArbCom". After all, in current practice it's members of the community who run for ArbCom, members of the community who elect ArbCom every year...

the list of arbcom appointees, you will find that Shell Kinney did not become an arbcom member. Therefore, her statement about what arbcom cases she would...

Hi. Given Arbcom’s importance and the fairly limited field so far, I ask for your support for this nomination. Background I joined Wikipedia in April 2007...

for most of the year and have had some pretty low opinions of serving on Arbcom in the past. Well, times change and they've certainly changed me. As to...

desysop virtually always happens through the admin's own request or by Arbcom action. Currently 146 of 512 currently-active admins, listed at Category:Wikipedia...

experience as an arbcom clerk, an editor and an administrator. From being a clerk, I bring preknowledge of how the public pages of arbcom, case pages and...

said it is under arbcom <Random832> No, you don't say "do something about this guy" <MBisanz> and the lead group contact is an arbcom member <Random832>...

need to go through the history of Arbcom. Remember that Arbcom is a community based desysopping mechanism, and past Arbcom elections are very much about who...

are incorrect on what the policy says, and invokes ArbCom as a reason for their position when ArbCom has said nothing of the sort, the place you go to...

Wikipedia. Arbcom has not been helping. I ran for Arbcom before, in 2010. I didn't do so well. I was thinking sort of tactically at the time. The arbcoms elected...

time of 3 months (Arbcom rule) 01:19, 28 Jan 2005 Snowspinner blocked "User:Baffinisland" with an expiry time of 3 months (Arbcom rule) 01:19, 28 Jan...

activity but this does not mean that I already know everything about how Arbcom works. I've instigated some changes to Wikipedia and campaigned hard for...

section will include active RfAs, RfBs, CU/OS appointment requests, and Arbcom elections) "Nominations for the 2013 English Wikipedia Arbitration Committee...

on /Proposed decision. 1) In the last Arbcom against MONGO, User:Fred Bauder wrote up the remedies for the Arbcom case, among them was: "No action is taken...

2004 (originally as User:Carrp) and an admin since March 2005. I think the ArbCom is absolutely essential to Wikipedia's success and I want to help in every...