https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/grims-toy-show/images/9/9e/Image-0.png/revision/latest?cb=20170623164349

James Cinatra

October 7, 1995 (age 29)

James Romer

Jimmy The Gerbil

Jimmy Controversy

Willo

Tito The Clown

JNC Neutron Neutrition

Danny Dildo

Vendetta

The Nun

El Jefe Greenball

Pimp Cara

Creepy Clown/Clown Corp

Charlie Quinn

Tony Emerald's Lion

Captain America

McTesticles Twins

Nickelwise The Klown

Medical Motherfucker

Jimmy Jesus

Red Rump Ranger

Krampus

The Green Orkel

The Young Fuck

Co-Kane

Grim

2014

Anything

Controversy Causer

Mossy Moose Knuckle Shuffle

Moose Knuckle 19

Phenomenal Foreskin

5'9"

150 lbs

MORE

James Cinatra is an American professional wrestler under the ring name Jimmy Controversy. He was originally portrayed as a psychotic teenager who used to call himself "Willo" and speaks in a fake monster voice. After a long hiatus he then dropped the Willow persona and is went to simply Jimmy Controversy. He sometimes carries a Kendo stick into the ring or as well as a crowbar or a staple gun. Controversy is a former Intercontinental Champion, Hardcore Champion and Loser Belt Loser. He played Jimmy The Gerbil on BFCW Wrestling, the parody of GTS.

Jimmy Controversy first appeared in a video in which Ebenezer Mittlesdorf visited his house, as he claimed himself the #1 fan of SillySuperPop. Jimmy then feuded with D-Generation Fat, mostly Grim, Duhop and PITA Kid/Chris which is Grim's nephew. He once jumped 20 feet off of his tree house and landed onto PITA Kid through a table. Jimmy unsuccessfully challenged Max Frost to a match for the GTS Championship belt only to get distracted and lose.

On August 28, 2016 episode of Grim's Toy Show, Controversy successfully captured the GTS Intercontinental  Championship, becoming the second GTS Intercontinental Champion on the show, and the youngest champion in GTS history at the age of 20. Controversy later lost the belt in a fatal four way match by getting taken out by killer clowns. However. he recently became face by almost defeating Grim in a match for the YouTube Championship. Jimmy struck gold when he defeated Manabo for the GTS Championship and held it for 29 days until he lost it to Kama Kozzy at Fatlame 2017.

Recently, Controversy is trying to get out of being Joe Wolf's retainer (or "virgin"). He successfully defeated Wolf at the first GTS indoor Pay-Per-View, making him free from being his "Virgin". On June 1 he became the No.1 Contender for the GTS Intercontinental Championship. On June 22,2017, Controversy was fired by Grim after accidentally costing him the Youtube Title against Jay 'The Cringe Key' Evans. On the same day, Grim wanted to rehire Jimmy but he couldn't find him after Jimmy stormed off out of the Warehouse. Later that day Grim found Jimmy and rehired him and made him the number 1 chicken tender for the GTS Title.

At Giant Sack of Heat, he beat Kleetus and became GTS Champion once again. Most recently, Controversy won the YouTube Wrestling Figures Heavyweight Championship at Quadruple Crown Tournament PPV on August 5, 2017. He later attacked Rhett Titus after losing the GTS Tag Team Championship, then Rhett revealed He is Jimmy's Father. Jimmy soon won Food in The Fridge and cashed it in to win the GTS Championship, losing it to Sprinkles the Clown a few days later. Jimmy cashed in the rematch claws to regain his title. At Clash Of CockWagons, Jimmy turned heel in the process for the first time since 2016 by attacking Titus on purpose this time & quitting DF to join J.O.B Security (similar to how Roderick Strong would later join the Undisputed ERA). Controversy attempted to make his new ring name his real name, but before he can finish his sentence, Grim interrupted him, saying 'James, you just made the menu!' At Christmas Chaos, Controversy lost his title to Kurt Bale, but Jimmy won the tag titles with Ronnie Moses days later.

Jimmy turned face in the process for the first time since 2017 after hugging Grim and officially reuniting with DF by teaming up with Grim and Bale in a 3-on-1 handicap match, but in a losing effort. The moment Jimmy won the GTS Intercontinental Championship from Lucha La Raza. he turned heel once again and lost the title to Blaxstrom in an Open Challenge Match. Near the end of 2018 Jimmy joined Bale's heel group Non Yarders and injured Lance Scaper at Grim's new house by throwing a glass table at him and severed his jugular vein. On January 21, 2019, in a real-life civil conference between Bale, Grim, Scaper (with his daughter Luna), Nightmare, and Duhop. Jimmy Controversy went after Luna Scaper after the GTS representatives does not want to meet Bale's demands and requests, Jimmy went after Luna and threw her through a wooden door, thus knocking her out. Scaper went after Jimmy and attacked him in vengeance for what he did. Jimmy would later make an attempt to apologize for his actions, but the GTS roster demanded that he take his apologies back, and Jimmy faced the jury, judge, and executioner. Jimmy was later saved by his Non Yarders group.

In February 2022, Controversy feigned a face turn with Grim before leading a new group similar to J.O.B Security, known as the 'Program.'

Love him or hate him, there is little doubt that Jimmy Controversy is one of the most greatest and successful GTS competitors of all time.

• Controversy Causer (2016-present)/Whisp of Fate/Twist of Fate (2014-2016) (Front facelock cutter) (2014-2017; Used as a Signature move thereafter) Parodied from The Hardy Boyz
  • Moose Knuckle Splash (Diving splash) (2016-present)
  • Phenomenal Foreskin/Controversial Forearm (2017-present) (Apron-to-Ring Springboard Forearm Smash) Parodied from AJ Styles

• Signature Moves
  • Acid Drop (Running bulldog, sometimes while using the turnbuckle for leverage) Adopted from Spike Dudley
  • Diving Elbow drop
  • Moose-Knuckle-1-9 (Tiger Feint Kick) Parodied from Rey Mysterio
  • Multiple Dropkicks
  • Multiple Punches
  • Mossy Moose Knuckle Shuffle (Running delayed falling fist drop, with theatrics)
  • Multiple Stomps to the shoulders of an opponent seated in the corner (Adopted from Spike Dudley)
  • Obese mode! (Stinger Splash with theatrics) (adopted from Grim)
  • Running headscissors
  • Moose Knuckle Sault (Second-Rope Moonsault)

• Nicknames
  • Shit-Cricket
  • Virgin (Usually called by the roster, mostly Joe Wolf)
  • Tiger
  • Moose Knuckle
  • Check
  • Piss-Biscuit (Called by Grim)
  • Super Cena Jr. (Called by Tommy Salami)
  • Tito the Fucking Clown
  • Sgt. Controversy (says on his Twitter account)
  • Jimmy Controvirgin (Called by Grim)
• Championships/ accomplishments

• BFCW
  • BFCW Championship (2 Times, inaugural)
• GTS Wrestling
• GTS YouTube Wrestling Figures Heavyweight Championship (7 Times)
• GTS Championship (6 Times)
• Heavyweight Wrestling Championship (1 Time)
• GTS Tag Team Championship (5 Times)- with Rhett Titus (1), Ronnie Moses (1), Duhop(1), Mike Goldstein (1), Jungle Jim (1)
• GTS Intercontinental Championship (6 times)
• GTS Hardcore Championship (5 times)
• GTS Loser Championship (12 Times)
• GTS Legendary Championship (1 Time)
• GTS World Trios Tag Championship (1 Time) With Jungle Jim & Mikey Anarchy Current
• Food in the Fridge (2017)
• Ninth GTS Triple Crown Champion
• Eighth GTS Grand Slam Champion
• SWF Wrestling
• SWF Cruiserweight Championship (1 Time)
• Pro Wrestling Venom
  • PWV World Championship (1 Time)