DOKUMEN123.COM

be supportive of a topic being worthy of notice. Shortcut WP:REBUTWP:REBUT To rebut the presumption, an editor must contest the presumption, and prove the...

need fair use rationales. --lightdarkness (talk) 05:02, 14 June 2006 (UTC) Rebut - All images are screenshots from public portals that are free for all researchers...

references from three different time periods, would in general successfully rebut notability challenges. References from three different time periods would...

apply consensus to other articles. Rebut claims of non-neutral language in my post to Talk:Ottoman Empire. [182] Rebut MarcusBritish's accusation of canvassing...

consider it a fringe belief, and for the most part disregard it except to rebut or disparage the claims. Despite the scholarly consensus, the controversy...

why (or why not) shouldn't require an essay, let alone multiple essays rebutting every post any editor makes on the subject. Example: Delete Non-notable...

to rebut the substantive arguments that notability is satisfied, and fail to advance a solid and consensus-supported policy argument that would rebut the...

NGRIDIRON only establishes a presumption of notability, which can therefore be rebutted. That's the argument the "delete" side makes: they argue that since no...

shows he meets this standard. While this creates a presumption that can be rebutted, I do not think a simple assertion of '[a]rticle subject is a non-notable...

to rebut the substantive arguments that notability is satisfied, and fail to advance a solid and consensus-supported policy argument that would rebut the...

presumption is that they do exist because WP:NBOX is met. If someone wants to rebut that presumption, then by all means go to Poland and do first hand research...

musings - Peripitus (Talk) 10:08, 9 March 2007 (UTC) Uncertain. I'd like to rebut the previous comment while abstaining from a position on the question, the...

June 2011 (UTC) Sorry, but even in your repetition, you have still not rebutted the reasonable presumption toward notability that she has through having...

presumption of non-notability for bootlegs. There is nothing in this article to rebut the presumption. - DustFormsWords (talk) 00:34, 20 October 2009 (UTC) Relisted...

creator is welcome to list best three sources in the discussion, if wants to rebut the claim. Zoodino (talk) 18:20, 26 August 2020 (UTC) Note: This discussion...

The result was delete. I don't find that the keep arguments successfully rebut the detailed source analysis. ♠PMC♠ (talk) 18:02, 17 October 2022 (UTC)...

I have another obligation at UCLA at 11 am, so you'll have all day to rebut me in my absence) Trackinfo (talk) 21:28, 15 March 2018 (UTC)   Sherry esp...

are 21 unique Google hits, none of which provide a verifiable source to rebut the WP:OR-ness of the article. Erechtheus 19:50, 8 September 2006 (UTC)...

page.‎ The result was Keep. Late additions of reliable source references rebut the delete arguments. Consensus is that the topic does meet the general...

represent OR. The page appears to have been created solely as a POV fork to rebut the descent hypothesized in the Britain's Real Monarch documentary (itself...

keep/no consensus. Would have been a no consensus, but no one bothered to rebut the sources Oakshade or Trevj provided thus Keep/No Consensus. Secret account...

User:Redfarmer said. This one's not ripe yet. P.S. Maybe this is what they call a rebut album! --DachannienTalkContrib 08:28, 19 January 2008 (UTC) Delete per WP:CRYSTAL...

this page.‎ The result was delete. The one keep !vote provides nothing to rebut the point that notability has not been established. Qwyrxian (talk) 04:12...

attributed to either a brief caching problem, or human error. I will not rebut some of the other points, but thank you for clarifying that Flow is not...

"presumed": NFOOTY notability is a rebuttable presumption. In this discussion, the nominator has not tried to rebut that presumption, but nor have other...

well-known? I just knew someone would copy Trojanian's comment if I didn't rebut it straight away. Epbr123 09:49, 31 August 2007 (UTC) Delete. While she...

voice Primary sources to rebut secondary sources: e.g., citing a primary source, such as the text of a law, in an attempt to rebut or provide false balance...

"everyone should have the chance, in public, to face their accusers and rebut claims". I have never had that chance. I state: I have never wikihounded...

this page.‎ The result was delete. The arguments to keep have failed to rebut User:Winged Blades of Godric's analysis of the sources. A Traintalk 07:57...

subject fails WP:GNG. No sources appear to have been provided which properly rebut that consensus, despite significant discussion. TigerShark (talk) 14:18...

there's no voting on AfD. It's based on a consensus. Second replying to rebut someone's post is perfectly acceptable as far as I know. I might have changed...

from at any given moment. But the edit summary here is too much not to rebut it. Thatcher 02:43, 12 June 2008 (UTC) The above discussion is preserved...

"I think this is a big accomplishment", and ipse dixit is not enough to rebut the deletion arguments presented. postdlf (talk) 18:59, 10 September 2014...

the reviewer's suggestions with an open mind and not to rush to defend or rebut. It seems possible to me that the fair-use rationale issue might be resolved...

filed against me was not only entirely without merit - I systematically rebutted every single one of his complaints, but it was only endorsed by his group...

sometimes distinguish between rebuttable and irrebuttable presumptions. Rebuttable presumptions, as their name suggests, can be rebutted by presenting evidence...

‎ The result was delete. WP:NCRIC creates a rebuttable presumption of notability, which has been rebutted here because nobody has found WP:GNG-compliant...

any policy more specific than the general one. Please ping me if you can rebut my arguments with evidence. Bearian (talk) 18:59, 21 November 2019 (UTC)...

keeping are stronger: the "keep" opinions do not substantively address or rebut the other side's arguments that there is not substantial coverage in reliable...

sources provided are insufficient, and the "keep" side does not attempt to rebut this. Sandstein 10:28, 21 July 2020 (UTC) [Hide this box] New to Articles...

your submission to arbitrators, not to other participants. If you wish to rebut, clarify, or otherwise refer to another submission for the benefit of arbitrators...

article by. SNG's are fine to presume notability. Presumed notability can be rebutted with facts. --ARoseWolf (Talk) 17:04, 15 January 2021 (UTC) What "facts"...

made to this page.‎ The result was delete. The one "keep" opinion does not rebut the principal argument for deletion, which is that the article does not...

only fair to give users a chance to defend or explain their actions or rebut comments about them, if possible. In all cases the incentive of allowing...

sources provided are insufficient, and the "keep" side does not attempt to rebut this. Sandstein 10:28, 21 July 2020 (UTC) Wessex Bristol (group) (edit |...

are independent of the subject"). However, I believe that presumption is rebutted as the coverage relates only to a non-notable subpoena to which they were...

purpose of rebutting another essay does not make for a well-written essay". Maybe I misunderstood you, but you seemed to be saying that rebutting an essay...

(UTC) Ah, I see we're discussing this in two places. Apologies. Right, to rebut all three of you points: 1.) You don;t need consensus to create a dab page...

significant treatment of the topic in reliable sources has been adduced to rebut the "delete" arguments. Deor (talk) 14:21, 26 June 2014 (UTC) Réseau des...

keep. Off-wiki comments notwithstanding, those wanting deletion didn't rebut about passing WP:ENTERTAINER to swing consensus. \ Backslash Forwardslash...

research by synthesis appears persuasive, and the "keep" opinions do not rebut it, with the exception of the opinion by VisitingPhilosopher, who however...

this page.‎ The result was DELETE. The one valid keep argument did not rebut the arguments that this was just a transient news story. postdlf (talk)...

notable. As our article about presumptions in law explains, there are rebuttable and irrebuttable presumptions. NFOOTY is silent about what kind of presumption...

they cite no policy or guideline that says so. They also do not attempt to rebut the argument for deletion that there is insufficient reliable coverage in...

one is a borderline No Consensus but the arguments to keep do nothing to rebut the principal problem with the article: it has no apparent criteria for...

a whole, particularly as viewed by disinterested commentors, failed to rebut the assertion that the subject is not notable. Xymmax So let it be written...

WP:OR - this essay seems at heart to want to use the writings of one man to rebut another Wikipedia article ("When the above indications of Rudolf Steiner...

problem (note Mbeki's remarks) needs to be comprehensively discussed and rebutted in the open. There are a vast number of significant AIDS conspiracy theories...

strong argument, and one that I don't personally buy, these editors also rebut the claim that these articles are indiscriminate. There seems to be some...

Wikipedia:Planned films#Coverage of planned films (WP:PRESUMPTION, WP:PRESUME, and WP:REBUT) but is relevant to any situation concerning the notability of a subject...

coordinates is known to exist". The "keep" opinions therefore would have had to rebut that argument by referencing such information, but they have not done so...

made to this page.‎ The result was Keep. There hasn't been any attempt to rebut the sources given below as evidence of notability, and we don't delete articles...

Tools Both editors using similar if not identical language when trying to rebut deletion of MarkMeets Magazine: SunloungerFrog (talk) 09:44, 30 April 2025...

effectively rebutted. Aside from the concerns over poor sourcing, there appear to be BLP concerns which also do not appear to have been effectively rebutted. 28bytes...

outweight the arugment for retention here; nothing has come forward to rebut the article's lack of notability via sourcing. –MuZemike 17:38, 29 November...

couldn't find any evidence that anyone has taken him seriously enough to rebut his claims. RJC TalkContribs 15:49, 6 December 2008 (UTC) Weak delete. A...

alone notability, and so the extreme lack of sources in this case would rebut the presumption of notability and fail the general notability guidelines...

rather trivial shorthand doesn't seem like sufficient justification to rebut my deletion proposal. Fram (talk) 12:35, 21 October 2015 (UTC) Delete. It...

than keep ones, but since none of the deletes has attempted to refute or rebut the GNG-based keep arguments this looks more like a keep consensus than...

the policy WP:BLPCRIME ChicXulub (talk) 21:17, 18 September 2014 (UTC) REBUTAL: This individual was fired by the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Philadelphia...

reliable sources. Because I find the rationale so weird I am unable to rebut it. Thincat (talk) 08:42, 30 August 2021 (UTC) Obvious Keep. The topic is...

21:45, 13 November 2007 (UTC) Keep - per Sladen, Burgundavia above. To rebut JzG/Guy, it might be tricky to find "non-trivial sources"; at this point...

consensus to delete before the relist, and the only argument since has been rebutted convincingly. Vanamonde (Talk) 20:43, 23 January 2023 (UTC) [Hide this...

it is alleged that the cited sources do not support the article text. To rebut that allegation, the "keep" side would have to show how the sources do in...

once again, the same people have used the same arguments and failed to rebut or even talk about the concerns of the nominator. Ironholds (talk) 11:55...

coverage on forums and QA sites, but the sources we are supposed to use mostly rebut these claims. Marketing budget is a great tool for gaming the system without...

that notability was established were without any support or sufficiently rebutted. postdlf (talk) 22:44, 27 December 2012 (UTC) Mujeeb Zafar Anwar Hameedi...

deletion discussions. shoy (reactions) 18:40, 12 October 2017 (UTC) To rebut the keep !votes below, here is a breakdown of the sources in the article:...

claims of the nomination are not supported by evidence and are easy to rebut. Finding sources is easy - just click on the search links provided above...

years old. WP:PROD of 2009-12-05 was removed by DrGottlieb, but no valid rebut, case, or enhancement followed. Reference was made to DrGottlieb's book...

organization and thus meets WP:NMMA. Unless a compelling rationale is given to rebut this fighter's presumption of notability and establish that WP:GNG is not...

"keep" opinions must be disregarded because they do not address, let alone rebut, the policy-based deletion rationale that there are no reliable sources...

those of the nominator and Atlantic306. Atlantic306's argument presumes to rebut that of the nominator, both the "no evidence" and the "not a lead actress"...

include newspapers from Commerce, Hamilton, Dallas, or Toronto. In order to rebut the presumption flowing from passing the SNG, something more is needed than...

page.‎ The result was no consensus. The delete opinions don't convincingly rebut the notability-based argument put forth by Doncram, so we have no consensus...

only way to discern between the two possibilities. CU, Please confirm or rebut. Cabayi (talk) 09:29, 28 February 2020 (UTC) Clerk note: If the allegation...

2019 (UTC) Comment: @Sportsfan 1234: It would be helpful if you were to rebut apparent claims against an SNG's items up-front. For instance with RNK,...

sure what register to respond in. If you're saying tu quoque, that doesn't rebut that Wikipedia is abominable. Are you actually making a pure, true, logical...

speculation that reliable sources could be added by someone is insufficient to rebut the claim that no such sources can be found. postdlf (talk) 15:24, 6 June...

your submission to arbitrators, not to other participants. If you wish to rebut, clarify, or otherwise refer to another submission for the benefit of arbitrators...

made to this page.‎ The result was delete. The keep arguments have not rebutted the synth concerns. Spartaz Humbug! 07:20, 25 July 2020 (UTC) [Hide this...

list's deletion. As it happens, the "keep" opinions mostly do not address or rebut this argument; at most, they broadly assert that sources must exist, without...

09:18, 20 February 2006 (UTC) forgive the interspersed responses, easier to rebut that way.  ALKIVAR™ 01:59, 16 February 2006 (UTC) Maybe you could state...

result was delete. The article has seen none of the necessary improvement to rebut the "delete" !votes. As a courtesy to the page creator, I will proactively...

further edits should be made to this page.‎ The result was keep. Attempts to rebut the subject's presumed notability via criterion 1 of WP:PROF appear to have...

the discussed character wouldn't be primary sources have already been rebutted in Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Death watch beetle (Dungeons & Dragons)...

cannot all decide policies, we need leadership." Dev920 also attempted to rebut the common objection from the first MfD discussion, that Esperanza's programs...

Daniel's page ☎ 02:24, 21 August 2006 (UTC) I hope this is the right place to rebut this... How is this not "verifiable"? Yes, you're right, e-feds are a dime...

importantly for me, is that a response is only required if it is likely to rebut the need for arbitration. I would agree to (further) delay if I could imagine...

(not "Do not space em dashes"). It is perfectly open to a nominator to rebut a complaint by saying "well I like them". The weakest form of recommendation...

controversy is before rebutting it? This reads like a navy press release :\. Not only that but the rest of that paragraph continues to rebut an argument that...

off requests. If you can identify the subject and cite sources, you can rebut the arguments here, of course, and multiple editors all trying to do that...

presumption of notability. The presumption is rebuttable. In assessing whether the presumption is rebutted it's appropriate to look at secondary policies...

way of establishing notability. Specific references would be required to rebut the delete arguments successfully. Spartaz Humbug! 21:53, 19 September 2009...

considerable detail at Wikipedia:Neutral point of view/BCE-CE Debate, trying to rebut the arguments of the BC/AD side. The broader proposal grew out of a debate...

http://www.rileyandson.co.uk/html/45407.html.). The "keep" opinions don't rebut this, but appear to argue that such locomotives are inherently notable,...

reliable) that demonstrate his previous notoriety, which would effectively rebut the WP:ONEEVENT deletion arguments. A Traintalk 12:13, 3 January 2018 (UTC)...

fan following and its albums are widely lauded I don't see any reason to rebut that presumption. - DustFormsWords (talk) 02:36, 2 October 2009 (UTC) Keep...

Durre Najaf - Spreading gems of Hikmah and discuss reality of Islam Please add reliable sites to this list. http://www.amislam.com/dhahabi.htm rebutal...

are likely to be in a language I don't speak. But I wanted to chime in to rebut a bad argument. Notability is not inherited; no matter how large or important...

should be made to this page. The result was keep‎. Nobody has attempted to rebut the sources added since the nomination. Sandstein 20:04, 9 August 2025 (UTC)...

criteria for a stand-alone article." Such sources were not brought forth to rebut the argument that the article fails the WP:GNG. Mackensen (talk) 00:22,...

was being contemplated. Conference organizer Laurent Haug responded to rebut the rumors. Haug, who conducted a Q&A with Devouard as part of the presentation...

category and see if you recognize some of these English words. That is not to rebut your argument vis-a-vis this AfD which is a total non-sequitur. __meco (talk)...

votes are numerically even, the "delete" !voters have made no attempt to rebut the arguments of the "keep" !voters. King of ♥ ♦ ♣ ♠ 14:10, 30 June 2020...

football essay WP:FOOTYN, and that thus we should redirect. I'd also like to rebut the argument made for keeping the article in edit summaries, which was Multiple...

relisted twice, and the keep !votes where either by sockpuppets or were rebutted by those chossing to delete, which had stronger arguments. The fact we...

recentism acknowledged by both sides, but the delete !voters were unable to rebut the presumption of notability that accompanied the coverage in the various...

2016 (UTC) Right, I'd read that and it slipped my memory. But you didn't rebut my other point about notability. The article's subject is too run of the...

WP:OSE (or even OTHERSTUFFDOESNTEXIST) but there is generally a failure to rebut the argument that we are talking about WP:NOTNEWS and WP:EVENT here. However...

subject fails this guideline and therefore the presumed notability is rebutted as per WP:N. --ARoseWolf (Talk) 21:33, 8 January 2021 (UTC) I would also...

notability for high-level players. But this presumption is rebuttable, and it has been rebutted here: the "delete" side argues that the subject fails WP:GNG...

are limited to arguing that the nomination occurs too soon, but do not rebut the arguments advanced for deletion. Inclusion policy is concerned about...

page. The result was delete; those arguing for "keep" have been unable to rebut those arguing for "delete" (although, take note Barkeep - a reliable source...

involved in another mediation effort regarding his action on MARTA. I've rebutted their postions on the Talk pages. The location of MARTA HQ is never given...

notable. However, presumptions can be rebutted by certain facts. In footballer articles, the presumption may be rebutted by the failure to have achieved professional...

ricochet it is also a French loanword. The final t in the otherwise similar "rebut" is not silent. 2601:648:8200:970:0:0:0:23D0 (talk) 11:57, 2 July 2021 (UTC)...

appreciate a rebuttal if Raevaen can offer one. Comments There is nothing to rebut. Your point (1) has nothing to do with slights, (2) seems a common subject...

for deletion seems to be a clear application of NOTNEWS. Those seeking to rebut this argument repeatedly pointed to the likelihood that sources confirming...

beliefs occupy a wide range." "Some propose" X, "while others believe" rebut X, affirm Y (and alternatives Z through RR are not remarked upon) "Even...

edits should be made to this page.‎ The result was delete. Nobody has rebutted the assessment that the sources proposed are of poor quality or depth....

opinion that Savage Sun passes WP:BAND. Your opinion isn't valid unless you rebut his/her statements. Goodvac (talk) 18:31, 1 January 2012 (UTC) Thank you...

made to this page.‎ The result was delete. The "keep" opinion does not rebut the assertion that he has only been quoted as a spokesman, not covered as...

rebuttal; I'd find it hard myself to rebut an argument I couldn't figure out.  Ravenswing  09:51, 22 July 2009 (UTC) Rebutting everything is not necessary. We...

locally, but he really didn’t do anything extraordinary. Alexfope, can you rebut what appears to be a fairly strong case for deletion? Bearian (talk) 02:41...

and the exhaustive analysis of the sources in the article has not been rebutted. Vanamonde (Talk) 18:08, 26 August 2020 (UTC) AfDs for this article: Articles...

but the sources uncovered later in the discussion have largely not been rebutted, so we have a weak consensus to keep here. Vanamonde (Talk) 04:49, 29 January...

(Talk|Contrib's.) 04:21, 3 September 2021 (UTC) Delete: I uploaded the file to rebut a stubborn editor who questioned my vote in an AfD a few years ago. I see...

00:25, 30 November 2010 (UTC) The problem is that only a few sources do rebut this. Most of the roughly two centuries worth of sources just plain repeat...

xfD...being wrong isn't a crime...but any other editor has the right to rebut your argument if they feel it is bad. I am simply pointing out that the...

to this page. The result was delete‎. Keep !voters have been unable to rebut the sourcing concerns brought by delete !voters. asilvering (talk) 22:52...

insufficiently rebutted by these editors, and one (WP:AUTHOR #3) involves seven reliable independent sources that have not been rebutted at all. To delete...

Cavarrone's evidence of persistent, significant coverage has not been rebutted. postdlf (talk) 16:15, 28 August 2013 (UTC) Murders of Byrd and Melanie...

delete. The WP:BLP1E argument does not appear to have been substantially rebutted. T. Canens (talk) 04:56, 3 October 2010 (UTC) Roger Craig (Jeopardy! contestant)...

WP:NOTINHERITED.As to the rest, there's no substance in your aspersions, to rebut. ~ Winged BladesGodric 02:15, 11 May 2018 (UTC) Delete or Redirect to Meher...

cannot all decide policies, we need leadership." Dev920 also attempted to rebut the common objection from the first MfD discussion, that Esperanza's programs...

The result was delete. The keep rationales do not appear to adequately rebut the concerns about lack of sourcing that would show notability per WP:GNG...

Relisting comment: Relisting. It's not enough to say "Keep", you should rebut the nomination statement. Please add new comments below this notice. Thanks...

agreed that it provides a presumption of notability - just that it can be rebutted, as I think it should be in this instance. Jogurney (talk) 22:16, 6 February...

The result was delete. The source assessment by IceWelder has not been rebutted. Sandstein 09:14, 31 May 2021 (UTC) [Hide this box] New to Articles for...

page.‎ The result was keep. Evidence-based argument to keep has not been rebutted. Vanamonde (Talk) 21:00, 7 October 2022 (UTC) [Hide this box] New to Articles...

is limited by the subject's nationality is well-taken and difficult to rebut, given the interest of the encyclopedia in avoiding geographic bias. While...

consensus. Consensus to delete this article is lacking, as the sources located rebut the BLP and V concerns. Still, there is a split as to whether the encyclopedia...

article that was not of apparent professional quality." Krowne set out to rebut McHenry's commentary point by point, and the arguments were further aired...

contributions present greater analytical depth in regards to sources and rebut sources presented by keep contributors, with no counter-rebuttals. Goldsztajn...

establish notability. Attacking one source does nothing; You'd need to rebut every single one of them to start making a dent here. This kind of referencing...

to this page.‎ The result was keep. Sources have been provided, and not rebutted; promotional material seems to have been dumped. Vanamonde (Talk) 23:36...

The detailed source analysis is persuasive and has not been convincingly rebutted. Vanamonde (Talk) 17:26, 5 August 2021 (UTC) AfDs for this article: Articles...

should be made to this page.‎ The result was delete. Nobody has attempted to rebut the surce analysis by Kelob2678, which is therefore given more weight than...

user conduct, but in reality I used it as a lever to beg for sympathy and rebut false statements that other users made at my RFAs. For better or worse,...

Wikipedia is struggling with issues involving women. We may have successfully rebutted the media narrative about Wikipedia's instability and unreliability with...

consensus that the sources are adequate and not out of date has not been rebutted. As usual, editors are free to improve the article if new sources crop...

Arbitrators on the Analysis page and to submit evidence whose purpose is to rebut evidence already submitted. The expectation is that evidence will be submitted...

that his coverage amounts only to directory-type listings has not been rebutted. Sandstein 08:55, 27 January 2021 (UTC) [Hide this box] New to Articles...

discuss the subject in detail. Those recommending the article be kept fail to rebut these claims, and, as such, fail to persuade within the discursive requriements...

page.‎ The result was delete. Scope creep's source analysis has not been rebutted. Sandstein 10:32, 12 January 2020 (UTC) [Hide this box] New to Articles...

deletion discussion. Burden of proof in a deletion discussion is subject to rebuttable presumption. It is entirely reasonable for an editor proposing deletion...

presumption of notability governs and results in "keep" absent a consensus to rebut that presumption. postdlf (talk) 18:32, 22 July 2013 (UTC) Talia Castellano...

bit here. The nom is a good one, and neither of the Keep votes adequately rebut it. Given that the AfD has already been relisted twice, the obvious "compromise"...

to List of Houston Astros broadcasters. redirect is fine but noone has rebutted the lack of proper sourcing. Spartaz Humbug! 17:00, 1 July 2013 (UTC) Francisco...

most certainly so. The nom is so off-base ("just short of A7") it seems to rebut an initial assumption of good faith. Carlossuarez46 (talk) 17:38, 4 June...

FBI for "knowingly distributing" such matter. (These allegations were rebutted by the Foundation's legal counsel at the time and do not appear to have...

scholarly sources that have significant coverage of this topic. No one has rebutted that these sources are not reliable. (non-admin closure) (t · c) buidhe...

result was delete‎. The Keep view, and its accompanying per !vote, fail to rebut the deficiency in notability, resulting in a rough consensus to delete....

point of view that it is too early to decide failure or success. After rebutting the arguments, we place the indications of Wikipedia's success and failure...

argument has been put forward that the subject meets GNG, and has not been rebutted. Vanamonde (Talk) 16:49, 9 January 2023 (UTC) [Hide this box] New to Articles...

played in seven. Presumed notability applies unless the presumption can be rebutted because the topic is found to be (or have been) an exception to the rule...

(UTC) I don't want to be one of those annoying nominators who tries to rebut every !vote. But just a quick note here if I may: I can see the guy's name...

Lightburst (talk) 13:11, 26 July 2019 (UTC) ...and that presumption is rebutted by the lack of GNG sources. – Levivich 05:34, 28 July 2019 (UTC) Keep Obviously...

delete. The sources put forward by User:The C of E have been convincingly rebutted. Malcolmxl5 (talk) 01:14, 18 December 2017 (UTC) Maeve Liston (edit | talk |...

that WP:PUFF may happen in good faith. Incidentally, a good way to further rebut WP:HOUND is to identify yet a third article that you followed me to. THF...

argument that this content is WP:OR is compelling, and not successfully rebutted. Creating a similar article that is based on reliable sources is however...

from reliable sources. Brian O'Conner 23:35, 25 March 2022 (UTC) I wish to rebut this: the published articles are all SIGCOV. They are published by Yigal...

does not confer notability; even if it did, that would be a rebuttable and now rebutted presumption. Sandstein 16:30, 8 October 2021 (UTC) Delete One...

made to this page.‎ The result was keep. As the more recent !votes have rebutted the sourcing concerns, without any disputes being raised, notability appears...

result was delete‎ . The WP:PERX comments do not adequately address or rebut the WP:BLP1E or WP:CRIME concerns or arguments; BLP articles must be held...

"keep" opinions make notability arguments, but do not address (let alone rebut) the verifiability problem, which as a core policy issue must take absolute...

being an essay), this presumption of notability in line with the above is rebuttable and not a guarantee of notability. Winners of sub-national level pageants...

viable if the term is fabricated, and the argument that it is hasn't been rebutted. Vanamonde (Talk) 11:18, 17 August 2022 (UTC) [Hide this box] New to Articles...

should be made to this page.‎ The result was keep. The delete vote was rebutted and the merge vote isn't as strong as the keep. (non-admin closure) Szzuk...

"keep" opinions must be given less weight because they do not address or rebut - by citing appropriate sources - the reason for which deletion is sought...

merge to Hindu astrology. The most substantive "keep" opinions have been rebutted, and the others offer scant evidence of notability, only assertions. Vanamonde...

demonstrate its real-world notability. A prima facie claim of notability is a rebuttable presumption. — Preceding unsigned comment added by KDS4444 (talk • contribs)...

based on the presumption that there could be sources, and several editors rebut this squarely. Tridentman123's drive-by "keep per" argument is not particularly...

be legit, and some loose claim to notability. Nothing has been said to rebut it...JJJ999 00:48, 1 October 2007 (UTC) Comment - I think you need to look...

WP:OSE (or even OTHERSTUFFDOESNTEXIST) but there is generally a failure to rebut the argument that we are talking about WP:NOTNEWS and WP:EVENT here. However...

canvassed finished. Very interesting that Discasto does not attempt to rebut the substance of the deletion argument. Kahastok talk 09:36, 15 March 2015...

and/or guidelines, agreeing with someone else's citation of a policy, or rebutting someone else's citation of a policy, your comments will have little if...

‎ The result was delete. Extensive analysis of sources is only partly rebutted, and that rebuttal was in turn countered. Subject is deemed not to pass...

page.‎ The result was delete. WP:V is not negotiable. And it's not been rebutted that much of this content is not verifiable. Sandstein 19:25, 22 January...

material is encyclopedic. Andrewa 23:54, 14 Jan 2005 (UTC) I intended to rebut the presumption that someone bothering to create an article is some evidence...

obvious, and it kind of is. --Hanging Jack 18:34, 30 August 2007 (UTC) rebut: WP:NOTFILM. The film hasn't received significant coverage. It hasn't been...

to this page.‎ The result was delete. The BLP1E arguments ahve not been rebuted. Consensus to delete has been established. Courcelles 18:19, 26 October...

acquisition rather than about the company itself has not been successfully rebutted. As usual, anyone wishing to recover the content to write a draft can use...

is not met and it also seems that any claim to passing NFOOTY is also rebutted, whilst the player may have made preliminary squad, the is no evidence...

have standalone articles should be included), or otherwise substantively rebutted by the keep !voters. The nom should also be advised that continuing to...

delete. Policy based consensus is clear here, SPA sources successfully rebutted. Secret account 04:57, 22 March 2013 (UTC) ReSharper (edit | talk | history |...

result was delete. The assertion that the articles fail WP:BASIC was not rebutted during the discussion. Mackensen (talk) 02:12, 12 December 2016 (UTC) Iurie...

for a discussion where admin Theresa knott accuses me of stalking and I rebut the accusation. I stand to my actions and words in that case and I have...

this page.‎ The result was delete. Concern about failing WP:GEOLAND not rebutted. Mojo Hand (talk) 15:51, 14 February 2021 (UTC) [Hide this box] New to...

referenced to TMZ, and no other RS source could be found to confirm or rebut it although there is plenty of gossip. The rest is not very well referenced...

votes, sometimes showing up in the code for our signatures. If you want to rebut our arguments, do it succinctly with an edit that is clearly your own, and...

coverage for WP:GNG or WP:BIO. Largoplazo (talk) 03:13, 6 December 2018 (UTC) Rebut This is still a new resouce as it stands, this artcle fits the notability...

that this list is by its structure and content mostly OR have not been rebutted or in most cases even addressed by the "keep" opinions. An attempt by an...

should be made to this page.‎ The result was keep. Concern about sources rebutted. Secret account 02:02, 4 September 2013 (UTC) Plaza Carolina (edit | talk |...

keep‎. Keep !votes are policy-based and the two delete !voters did not rebut their arguments/sources. (non-admin closure) Dclemens1971 (talk) 02:57,...

that can fit on that page. Note to the closer that the delete votes do not rebut the argument to redirect. ミラP@Miraclepine 05:17, 24 November 2025 (UTC)...

13:39, 24 August 2020 (UTC) Comment. Without a rationale we have nothing to rebut: thank you for providing one. Her "non-notable" book received at least three...

in the case of AlessandroTiandelli333's opinion, have been convincingly rebutted. Sandstein 14:06, 10 November 2018 (UTC) [Hide this box] New to Articles...

took part in a protest/concert in 1987. I've added that in. This further rebuts the "one event" thing. Of course the other events are minor, lacking significant...

should be made to this page.‎ The result was delete. noone hasd clearly rebutted the argument that this is synth and OR and the vast majority of the keep...

matter about OtR, either to close the door to further sockpuppetry or to rebut the allegation of tainted edits. Alansohn (talk) 18:23, 4 November 2015...

has been put forward of the subject meeting NAUTHOR, and has not been rebutted. Vanamonde (Talk) 19:28, 26 October 2022 (UTC) [Hide this box] New to Articles...

mirrors or print on demand books with wikipedia content. However, this is a rebuttable presumption that can be overcome by evidence of independent notability...

haunt my dreams" would get tagged as patent nonsense, and someone would rebut and say "it parses in English! it's not nonsense!" However, read the second...

was keep. The sources that have been provided have not been adequately rebutted, and nobody has demonstrated sufficient problems with the article to require...

footballer who so narrowly passes the bright line of NFOOTBALL is sufficient to rebut that presumption (not to mention that the sourcing for the inclusion of...

directory of schools. You say you can only rebut the claims I make, but you are doing a much better job of rebutting claims I haven't made. Are you saying...

this page.‎ The result was keep. Nomination rationale has been clearly rebutted by Nick Moyes. A Traintalk 13:03, 5 January 2018 (UTC) Condosity (edit |...

was delete. The arguments to keep are substantially stronger; nobody has rebutted the challenge to the sources provided, and meeting NSPORTS isn't enough...

keep has been provided, and the argument to merge has been convincingly rebutted. Vanamonde (Talk) 20:19, 18 April 2021 (UTC) [Hide this box] New to Articles...

delete. The arguments that the cited sources are unreliable have not been rebutted. Sandstein 06:57, 6 September 2021 (UTC) [Hide this box] New to Articles...

not settle that score today. While ordinarily a SNG's presumption can be rebutted by showing that the GNG is not met, there is also no consensus here about...

OR. The keep side mostly relied on assertion and failed to effectively rebut the deletion arguments and where they did refer to policy misinterpreted...

this page.‎ The result was keep as the reasons for deletion have been rebutted with the improvements as noted in the reasons for retention. –MuZemike...

arguments are either ill-based in policy or has been quite-satisfactorily rebutted. (non-admin closure) ∯WBGconverse 10:20, 31 July 2018 (UTC) [Hide this...

a policy compliant article so the rebuttable presumption of notability given by passing NACTOR is, well, rebutted due to lack of actual coverage. (I...

confused the nominator, who has not followed up for six days, nor replied to rebut or acknowledge my comments in support. Articles regarding individual shows...

but even if it does, I think here any presumption of notability would be rebutted by the complete lack of any coverage in reliable sources that I can find...

preferably on ABC talk. "Primary sources should rarely if ever be used to rebut secondary sources. When WHO, ACOG, &c. all take the same stance on an issue...

votes did not provide sufficient evidence that the subject passes GNG to rebut that argument. However, many of the keep voters and the nominator offered...

3/07/02/dem-lepak-boyz-dan-firdaus-rahmat-tersingkir-6-peserta-berentap-rebut-gelaran-juara-big-stage-2023 Sinar Harian coverage: https://www.sinarharian...

think that "homogenous page design" is desirable consistency. Go for it! rebuts: "There are always a few people who complain. But there are far more people...

automatic notability without significant coverage. A "presumption" can be rebutted by the lack thereof. If you're attributing notability purely on this one...

14 May 2021 (UTC) Delete I don't see any arguments that can be made rebutting those above. There isn't even much to WP:PRESEVE in case I am wrong, so...

fact that there were 2 previous AfD's required a long nomination, imo, to rebut some of the arguments there that later proved to be untrue. KeptSouth (talk)...

or niche publications of dubious reliability have not been convincingly rebutted. Sandstein 08:06, 3 May 2020 (UTC) [Hide this box] New to Articles for...

governments and by the electorate they served." I cannot conclude without rebutting Evans' repeating the zombie myth that 18 to 20 divisions from Siberia...

potentially only of local interest.) I'd note that were the local interest issue rebutted, he otherwise has signficant coverage in reliable independent sources and...

this is a verifiable subject, its notability is questioned, though not rebutted conclusively. There is significant disagreement as to whether the coverage...

Criterion. A valid counterargument, that actually would hold water and rebut the nominatino, would be citations of such sources. There are none in the...

WP:NSPORTS establishes only a presumption of notability, which can be rebutted if people look for and do not find substantial coverage, as in this AfD...

record. The result of the debate was - kept, Josh Lee's argument never rebutted. - SimonP 02:40, Jun 15, 2005 (UTC) Looks like a WP:BJAODN candidate to...

opposition on deletion grounds he doesn't like, while making no attempt to rebut the others.) Ravenswing 08:06, 14 January 2012 (UTC) Delete WP:NOTTVGUIDE...

edits should be made to this page. The result was delete‎. It's hard to rebut a thorough source review that finds the references lacking. Liz Read! Talk...

(UTC) Delete. Absolutely no evidence has been advanced at this time to rebut the nominator's assertion that this article fails to meet the general guideline...

better to me, but given your ¡vote, can you tell me about which part of my rebut to Atsme, you do not agree with? ∯WBGconverse 20:53, 23 November 2019 (UTC)...

was keep. The reasons for retention after the first relist have not been rebutted. –MuZemike 01:35, 7 July 2010 (UTC) Myth Men Guardians of the Legend (edit |...

result was delete. The sources put forward by GRuban were convincingly rebutted by Dom Kaos and LuckyLouie. Malcolmxl5 (talk) 03:21, 15 December 2017 (UTC)...

WP:FORUMSHOP to me.--Paul McDonald (talk) 19:12, 9 May 2018 (UTC) Feel free to rebut my arguments but with substance.And, kindly read the policies, you're citing...

18:41, 9 April 2025 (UTC) Snow Keep in the absence of new arguments to rebut the keep rationale of the first AfD nom, as per Frank Anchor and Cbl62 (in...

The argument that there are no such sources in this case has not been rebutted here. Sandstein 09:22, 20 February 2020 (UTC) [Hide this box] New to Articles...

delete. Freshacconci reevaluation of the sources Yngvadottir gave, wasn't rebutted and consensus shows she doesn't meet the criteria for ARTIST or GNG yet...

whether the coverage provided is significant and (b) whether there's a rebuttable presumption of notability based on her position. The lack of English language...

redirect to USL League Two. I find the first keep has been adequately rebutted, and the second makes no argument whatsoever. ♠PMC♠ (talk) 23:12, 10 July...

page.‎ The result was Draftify. Some of the Keep rationales have been rebutted here, especially on the quality of the sources, and one of them even suggests...

gender-neutral) presumption that this player is notable. Is there enough here to rebut either or both of those presumptions? I suspect maybe not. Macosal (talk)...

necessary as there's no policy requiring them. But, because it's so easy to rebut these fatuous nominations, let's have another. This work, for example, tells...

your submission to arbitrators, not to other participants. If you wish to rebut, clarify, or otherwise refer to another submission for the benefit of arbitrators...

applicability of BLP1E in this context for various reasons, keep arguments did not rebut the concerns raised regarding depth of available independent coverage in...

result was delete. It looks like all keep arguments have been effectively rebutted. Jo-Jo Eumerus (talk, contributions) 06:07, 4 September 2018 (UTC) AfDs...

these create a presumption for inclusion, and I haven't seen anything to rebut that presumption. Being a single from a significant artist is also strongly...

per the excellent work sourcing done by @Clearfrienda. Also to directly rebut the nomination – school sports is actually very notable in the field of...

parties is an explicit discussion of points made on WO. Whether it's to rebut or to dismiss it from evidence, I don't know, and isn't especially relevant...

office", and is thus "presumed notable". I don't think that presumption is rebutted, given news coverage; see, e.g., here, here, here, etc. AleatoryPonderings...

was delete. The WP:V argument doesn't appear to have been successfully rebutted. T. Canens (talk) 14:38, 30 January 2017 (UTC) Nyala Rinpoche (edit | talk |...

for cannabis. The argument(s) to merge and keep have been excellently rebutted. (non-admin closure) ∯WBGconverse 13:05, 28 June 2018 (UTC) [Hide this...

non-independence or non-substantiveness, and these contestations have not been rebutted. Jo-Jo Eumerus (talk, contributions) 20:17, 24 February 2018 (UTC) Zainab...

independent ref with in depth coverage is The Age which pretty much completely rebuts the articles' claims for scientific advance. Fails WP:PROF, WP:FILMMAKER...

points to some notability, which those supporting for deletion have not rebutted nor responded to. –MuZemike 23:52, 21 December 2011 (UTC) Yaesu FT-1000MP...

simply saying something is trivial doesn't make it trivial. I'd like to rebut your comment but you didn't say anything objective, you've incited subjectivity...

creates a presumption in favor of notability, but that presumption has been rebutted here since, as appears to be uncontested, he fails the GNG. Perhaps that...

result was keep. None of the post-relist arguments for retention have been rebutted. --MuZemike 20:47, 2 January 2012 (UTC) Jets to Zurich (edit | talk | history |...

specifically for the geological and astronomical arguments and how they are rebutted. See Wikipedia:Splitting etc. Should have "main article" links from creation...

targets are dependent on a number of factors out of our control. You can rebut that we should pick better KPIs, but the problem is deeper than picking...

this page.‎ The result was keep. WP:SNOW. A frivolous nomination, easily rebutted by the discussion participants and by express guidelines. postdlf (talk)...

editing and disruptive behaviour as other editors have then to spend time rebutting any arguments you put forward. HighKing++ 21:56, 8 November 2020 (UTC)...

retention, accompanied by said article's improvement, which has not been rebutted. –MuZemike 22:46, 5 July 2010 (UTC) SubAudible Hum (edit | talk | history |...

of this discussion is that he is not (with reasons given), and no one's rebut those arguments. Mackensen (talk) 21:19, 20 January 2015 (UTC) Comment If...

election, 2011. The BLP1E argument does not appear to have been substantially rebutted. T. Canens (talk) 11:11, 24 May 2011 (UTC) Yam Ah Mee (edit | talk | history |...

discussion. The article fails WP:NEO and WP:NAD. Nothing you have said rebuts that. -- Wikipedical (talk) 02:52, 26 December 2015 (UTC) Keep per Legacypac...

keep. Based on GNG, note that sources provided during discussion were not rebutted j⚛e deckertalk 17:14, 12 April 2013 (UTC) Matt Leto (edit | talk | history |...

consensus against a standalone article; the only argument to keep has been rebutted by the argument that the content can adequately be covered elsewhere. The...

notability for a South African musician of some years back, it is a reasonable rebuttable test for existence of a well-known person in a country such as South Africa...

sources of the event within a few weeks of it occurring, with none of them rebutting the stronger delete rationales that this event fails WP:EVENT with no...

not met. The arguments for keeping the article do not address, let alone rebut, FOARP's convincing analysis. It is argued that there must be better sources...

was delete. Issue of lack of independent sourcing per Whpq has not been rebutted by the keep side. Sjakkalle (Check!) 12:27, 9 June 2013 (UTC) Canada Post...

delete. WP:NFOOTY establishes a presumption of notability that can be rebutted by showing that there is not in fact sufficient coverage to meet WP:GNG...

result was keep. Disregarding the earlier confused yelling, nobody has rebutted the later NPOL argument. Sandstein 19:01, 10 July 2018 (UTC) [Hide this...

existence of the subject is not verifiable ([[[WP:V]]), and they have not been rebutted here with references to reliable sources. Sandstein 06:56, 2 May 2020 (UTC)...

consensus. Relisting comment: Bold third relist to give the opportunity to rebut HighKing if desired, whose contributions I find (currently) the most persuasive...

The later arguments to keep are substantial enough and have not been rebutted. Jo-Jo Eumerus (talk, contributions) 07:41, 13 June 2019 (UTC) AfDs for...

why the proffered sources aren't adequate than the keep side does at rebutting that, and some keep !votes do not offer any evidence. Jo-Jo Eumerus (talk...

Gaknowitall's argument is not policy based and Doncram's argument is effectively rebutted by NYA. As this is a close call I'm happy to reconsider on request. A Traintalk...

to this page.‎ The result was delete. The one "keep" seems to have been rebutted. Sandstein 21:56, 5 February 2018 (UTC) List of Kung Fu cast members (edit |...

this split, and the fact that the now blocked (but non-sock) position was rebutted without response, and lacked any reasoning on why the sources would be...

low number of edits. But the arguments presented to keep have not been rebutted and the only argument given to delete is an assertion of non-notability...

Significant and persistant coverage demonstrated and not substantively rebutted; insistence that it must also demonstrate "significant impact" is not supported...

websites do this ... you'd think we'd know if it was illegal" - nicely rebutted in this article from the NYU Law Review, which begins by stating "Copyfraud...

The argument that there are no independent reliable sources has not been rebutted. WP:V is not negotiable. Sandstein 22:53, 16 December 2017 (UTC) AfDs for...

is not grounds for deletion in itself, it is grounds for skepticism or rebuttable presumption. In this case, the principle claim for notability ("ranked...

make statements and the closing admin weighs them. There is no need to rebut every statement. Abductive (reasoning) 20:00, 20 April 2010 (UTC) Keep....

because of the unreliable sources) have not been substantially contested or rebutted. Sandstein 08:34, 24 January 2022 (UTC) [Hide this box] New to Articles...

manifested itself in edit-warring and other combative behaviour. Collect rebutted that the case request was vexatious and grounded in a minor content dispute...

arguing for keep is IAR and COMMONSENSE. There is no policy based rationale rebutting nominators argument for deletion. In absence of evidence the subject meets...

deletion are either not reasons for deletion but cleanup and/or have been rebutted by those wanting to keep the list. Thryduulf (talk) 23:21, 1 January 2014...

edits should be made to this page.‎ The result was delete. No-one has rebutted the deletion rationale. Black Kite (talk) 00:18, 12 November 2018 (UTC)...

NFOOTY (in addition to the above being a vague wave), which is only a rebuttable presumption, is not a valid argument if the subject actually fails GNG...

enough content to necessitate a split is persuasive, and has not been rebutted. Vanamonde (Talk) 13:15, 20 August 2021 (UTC) [Hide this box] New to Articles...

noted that the claim was a literary reviewer's opinion, and that Roth had rebutted the claim—the article never stated the genesis of the book, leaving the...

detailed and specific rationales than the other side, and these haven't been rebutted. Hut 8.5 21:23, 22 May 2018 (UTC) Katrin Alvarez (edit | talk | history |...

have proved criterion #1 of WP:ENT. Because the comments have not been rebutted, I'm closing as keep. – GorillaWarfare talk • contribs 14:51, 7 February...

becomes available. Meio2934 (talk) 04:56, 30 July 2025 (UTC) I will have to rebut the based on these findings specifically in relation to this article: The...

argued that the two are different, or that WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS failed to rebut this claim. Owen× ☎ 08:18, 19 February 2025 (UTC) [Hide this box] New to...

into more detail as to why WP:NBAND is met than the delete camp has in rebutting the keep claims Jo-Jo Eumerus (talk, contributions) 07:51, 8 May 2019...

that the subject meets our notability guidelines or have been effectively rebutted. Consequently I have to give those reduced weight. Hut 8.5 22:15, 7 March...

The result was keep. Keep both. Two arguments in favor of deletion were rebutted by WP:NOTDUP, many concerns also appear to have been addressed via normal...

should be made to this page.‎ The result was no consensus. Deletes were rebutted, sources are possible Secret account 16:23, 12 December 2008 (UTC) Indians...

contribs) You've all heard someone say "RfA is a vote" and then 10 angry users rebut it with "RfA is not a vote; the latter 10 are wrong, even though their stance...

and the sole WP:LISTN argument is without other support (and arguably rebutted by Arxiloxos). postdlf (talk) 16:39, 22 January 2014 (UTC) List of National...

that they generally do not support the content. His argument has not been rebutted.  Sandstein  15:58, 26 August 2016 (UTC) Ashanti cuisine (edit | talk |...

result was delete. The argument that any coverage was local has not been rebutted. Deletion in the Polish Wikipedia is also an indicator of insignificance...

is now blocked as a sock and the other's argument appears to have been rebutted.  Sandstein  09:38, 10 November 2016 (UTC) Brad Delaney (edit | talk |...

page.‎ The result was delete. All agree subject isn't notable, no one rebutted that the salvageable content already had been merged. Xymmax So let it...

the redirect-rather-than-delete !votes makes good case which was not rebutted, and policy favors retention of content. The article history remains intact...

common occurrence. Imzadi 1979 → 07:42, 30 January 2014 (UTC) A point to rebut a flawed part of the above analysis of the sources: a and c are the same...

topical one in Malaysia and clearly encyclopedic (nobody's even attempted to rebut that presumption here). As a content issue, my suggestion is to strip the...

QEDK and Eloquai, please read WP:INHERITED) but no one has specifically rebutted Thinker78's sources (or the last-minute additions from CASSIOPEIA) which...

Hutton describes the term and provides specific examples about its use would rebut the argument in its entirety. The reliable and verifiable sources provided...

reasonable arguments for the topic's notability that were not substantively rebutted in the discussion. postdlf (talk) 18:50, 1 March 2014 (UTC) AfDs for this...

be made to this page.‎ The result was delete. Atlantic306's argument is rebutted by Tony; Peterkingiron's "probably keep" argument sure reads like a delete...

"presumed notable", the argument that the subject meets WP:NPOL has not been rebutted, nor has the existence of verifiable information (which may nonetheless...

was keep. The sources that have been provided have not been adequately rebutted, and nobody has demonstrated sufficient problems with the article to require...

keep comment regarding the original concerns of the nominator that wasn't rebutted in the end (while disagreeing with other keep commentators). Secret account...

this, there do not appear to be any substantial arguments to keep that rebut the nomination or the arguments to delete that followed. The crux of this...

founder of the group, Vinesh Patel (User:Vinnypatel) was interviewed and rebutted a number of the criticisms of Wikipedia frequently raised by the academic...

only thing NCRIC (being a subject notability guideline) creates is a rebuttable presumption of meeting the general notability guideline (and therefore...

in multiple reliable sources does not appear to have been successfully rebutted. T. Canens (talk) 02:55, 21 September 2010 (UTC) Tony Sokol (edit | talk |...

why the proffered sources aren't adequate than the keep side does at rebutting that, and some keep !votes do not offer any evidence. Jo-Jo Eumerus (talk...

their claims of notability, and I cannot see that the delete side have rebutted those arguments. Sjakkalle (Check!) 20:06, 19 February 2013 (UTC) 274th...

claims based on galleries in which his work supposedly appears have been rebutted. Sandstein 20:21, 22 October 2018 (UTC) [Hide this box] New to Articles...

the GP Academy website signifcant coverage? You haven't done enough to rebut the comments as per the nom. Either the notability is there or it isn't...

place any presumption of notability established by sources would be easily rebutted. - DustFormsWords (talk) 23:15, 11 October 2009 (UTC) Merge into Croxley...

references from three different time periods, would in general successfully rebut notability challenges. References from three different time periods would...

deletion rationale, the only remaining delete opinion has been adequately rebutted. (non-admin closure) Steven Crossin Help resolve disputes! 02:26, 19 August...

should be made to this page.‎ The result was no consensus. No one really rebutted nominator's point that the subject failed to appear in multiple notable...

actual sources for this specific episode the delete arguments have not been rebutted. (hint, if you find me some detailed specific sources I can review this...

an accuser, and thus the bio article functions as a way to bring up and rebut his accusations without having to address their validity - which would have...

not given an opportunity to FIX or REPLY on these pages and thus cannot REBUT. When I tried to dispute this with editors via another IP (as I cannot login)...

seems like not all the sources presented as proof of notability have been rebutted, although it's a weakish "keep" conclusion. Jo-Jo Eumerus (talk) 11:08...

covering this topic, which none of the delete !voters acknowledged, yet alone rebutted. postdlf (talk) 03:20, 28 March 2011 (UTC) Engender (edit | talk | history |...

but analysis of actual mentions by multiple delete commenters adequately rebuts the possibility of significant coverage in reliable sources. No other keep...

result was keep. Sources have been provided for over a week, no one has rebutted that they amount to significant coverage in independent reliable sources...

be made to this page.‎ The result was delete. Nothing in this discussion rebuts the nominator's assertion that there is no nreliable third party coverage...

argument that the creator needs to be given time to develop this was not rebutted and is consistent with Wikipedia:User pages. -- Jreferee (talk) 15:42,...

aware of Vaknin's legal threats. (Some other of Vaknin's claims are also rebutted there, such as those about his involvement in Nupedia.) According to the...

subject, creating a presumption of notability that's on the nominator to rebut. SportingFlyer (talk) 03:50, 13 February 2018 (UTC) Comment Sources one...

to this page.‎ The result was delete. Nobody has seriously contested or rebutted the argument that there are insufficient reliable sources for inclusion...

the Philippines per WP:CLN. WP:VAGUEWAVEing at NOTDIR doesn't remotely rebut that, nor does pointing to bad edits made to the page (as you will probably...

whole, more compelling, and many of the delete arguments were effectively rebutted. Sarcasticidealist (talk) 16:58, 11 March 2008 (UTC) Donald Roden (edit |...

can assure George Ho that I have fully taken into account his attempts to rebut the arguments favouring keeping, the consensus here is clear. Stifle (talk)...

(talk) 02:28, 25 May 2010 (UTC) Keep. While unreleased demos are presumed (rebuttably) to be nn under WP:MUSIC, this is a released collection of demos from...

you presume notability but the risk is that presumed notability can be rebutted with evidence and facts. --ARoseWolf (Talk) 15:52, 14 January 2021 (UTC)...

The result was delete. Search for any reliable sources was successfully rebutted. Secret account 04:13, 9 April 2013 (UTC) Jordan Kitts Music (edit | talk |...

2020 discussion that preceded it both explain that sparse coverage can rebut the general presumption of notability. Every SCOTUS decision (regardless...

or are otherwise not sufficient to meet WP:GNG. The "keep" side has not rebutted that analysis.  Sandstein  10:44, 31 October 2017 (UTC) Scholars for Peace...

entirely. When a cleanup tag is no longer applicable, we remove it; we do not rebut it on the article page. Chris Cunningham (user:thumperward) - talk 10:02...

arguements for the keep side is basically non-existent, potential GNG source rebutted. Secret account 05:48, 19 March 2013 (UTC) PARSIFAL (edit | talk | history |...

made a strong arguments that others have agreed with and has not been rebutted. As noted, it is enough to prove the sources exist, they do not have to...

agreeing with one view and superficially agreeing on their reasons so that rebutting the reasons is futile despite sourcing and logic Building an off-wiki...

explain why this user is notable. Nearly all the sources and arguments were rebutted by those wishing to delete, and there was not nearly enough material to...

found non-notable and deleted"). The prone to OR argument has also been rebutted. While this article is not in good shape currently, there is not nearly...

I opened a couple of the refs in the article itself to corroborate the rebut of the sources above and it appears correct. Szzuk (talk) 20:36, 23 February...

edits since the past MfD are generally of a trivial nature has not been rebutted, and renders the "two months" argument of substantially lesser weight....

removed - most of its material is already in the article, there's no need to rebut propaganda distributed by Nazis in 2009 and it's a NPOV violation as it's...

arguing delete have referenced established guidelines and do not seem to be rebutted by the keep arguments with anything similar. RL0919 (talk) 19:56, 2 May...

result was keep.Mainly based on BillHPike's !vote, which has been hardly rebutted.(non-admin closure) ∯WBGconverse 13:15, 28 June 2018 (UTC) AfDs for this...

decision to keep or delete. If someone else wants to write another essay to rebut this one, that's probably the best choice. But no valid, policy-based reason...

state-level legislators. The "delete" side would need compelling arguments to rebut this presumption, which they don't provide; instead we get lengthy quibbling...

It is not a directory.  Your argument for LISTN is not so easy for me to rebut, but the nominator didn't mention that, so maybe there is a sense here that...

to this page.‎ The result was keep. SilkTork's argument (which was not rebutted) provides the most clear and concise explanation as to why this is not...

due dfiligence by the delete side on teh sourcing and this has not been rebutted effectively Spartaz Humbug! 04:19, 9 September 2010 (UTC) Golfo Azzurro...

warranted. The argument that there's no merge-worthy content has not been rebutted, and as such deletion is the only possible outcome. If the creator or someone...

coverage in reliable sources." There do not appear to be any sources rebutting this presumption of non-notability. - DustFormsWords (talk) 06:33, 11...

2006 (UTC) Delete per User:Heilme. It's a shame that the article tries to rebut the argument with some reasonable points instead of ignoring the preposterous...

the current sources prove notability? None of the comments so far seem to rebut the concerns The Gnome raised above, they're basically ITEXISTS and argument...

exist), argue this out. In either case, the onus is on the "keep" side to rebut deletion arguments or prove them false due to the method of opening the...

Myanmar’s image It is time to compile [a] mass of literary works designed to rebut various forms of accusations and made-up stories created at home or abroad...

used enough as a source in en-wiki). But NFILM and WP:GNG guidelines are rebuttable presumptions of notability, to be proved with enough sources for the policy...

evidence this is a valid, notable concept defined in reliable sources to rebut that plain English read of it. Shelbystripes (talk) 18:54, 30 January 2020...

result was draftify‎. No argument for notability has been presented to rebut the well-supported nomination statement; moving to draft instead of deletion...

topic-specific notability guidelines, only creates a rebuttable presumption of notability. This presumption can be rebutted if, as here, a thorough discussion does...

this did not happen. ... discospinster talk 18:32, 14 December 2007 (UTC) Rebutal There are no other reliable third party source according to Wiki's version...

(UTC) No one else attempted any independent reporting on it, not even to rebut it. Trump never said anything about it as far as I'm aware, but Conway did...

xiku 21:55, 2 September 2021 (UTC) Delete. None of the keep !votes have rebutted the lack of GNG sources. Claims that all Olympians are notable are completely...

There are two types of presumptions: rebuttable presumptions and irrebuttable (or conclusive) presumptions. A rebuttable presumption will either shift the...

recently nominated but only two participants + nom commented and none rebutted the argument put forward by the nom. For example, it may have subsidiaries...

of information. >Radiant< 16:08, 4 January 2007 (UTC) Comment: I have rebutted this 96% inaccurate observation here. AndyJones 12:07, 6 January 2007 (UTC)...

WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES, there is a "challenge-able consensus" (in legal jargon, a "rebuttable presumption)" that all accredited degree-awarding tertiary institutions...

here, but those in favor of keeping do not appear to have successfully rebutted the charge of indiscriminateness and/or unclear scope (and indeed have...

meet Wikipedia standards for reliable sources to prove notability was not rebutted. Xymmax So let it be written So let it be done 13:46, 18 September 2009...

article meeting reliable sourcing weren't properly met in the AFD, or was rebutted. Being kept once before isn't a reason for keeping if the article doesn't...

is not substantial enough for WP:GNG, and these arguments have not been rebutted by the "keep" side. Sandstein 07:49, 7 April 2021 (UTC) AfDs for this article:...

the GNG is met, I think the reasons stated in the nom are sufficient to rebut the presumption of article-worthiness for the case as such. But I wonder...

that there are insufficient sources for these characters have not been rebutted by citing relevant sources.  Sandstein  20:07, 27 November 2016 (UTC) Wilfred...

separate article, and the majority of !votes that favored merge weren't rebutted. Given preference to maintain information, the merge is more favored position...

of information. >Radiant< 16:09, 4 January 2007 (UTC) Comment: I have rebutted this 96% inaccurate observation here AndyJones 12:07, 6 January 2007 (UTC)...

game is not played by anyone else than a small circle of people was never rebutted. The keep votes provided no real arguments. Sjakkalle (Check!) 07:51, 24...

as to why the sources do not establish notability, which have not been rebutted. The sock's argument - aside from now being blocked - hasn't convinced...

lacks references altogether. Presumed notability under WP:NSPORT is a rebuttable presumption, and I have not been able to identify the necessary non-trivial...

that this alleged statement by Johnson is reliably sourced haven't been rebutted. Sandstein 06:34, 7 May 2021 (UTC) [Hide this box] New to Articles for...

The keep commenters are a numerical minority, and have not substantially rebutted in argument the notion that this sets a bad precedent. Xoloz 15:56, 12...

I consider they are sufficiently serious to have required a statement rebutting them of which this is a trimmed version. He attempts to state that I do...

the WP:SNOW results, the serious WP:BLP concerns (which have not been rebutted and in fact were reinforced by some comments), and the fact that at least...

they fail to cite these sources in this AfD, and they do not address or rebut the convincing source analysis indicating that the WP:GNG requirements are...

viewpoints of the sides involved. When evidence was put forth tending to rebut this charge and prove my original point (that the removal was viewpoint-based)...

encyclopedic content. However,some of them, such as the award, do serve well to rebut what i said at the AfD that the article itself was not notable, only the...

admins who approved the return of this article to mainspace, I feel I should rebut the "nothings [sic] changed" part of the nomination statement. The article...

independent of the person himself—does not appear to have been successfully rebutted. Deor (talk) 11:29, 15 January 2015 (UTC) Seth Andrews (edit | talk | history |...

15:09, 31 July 2019 (UTC) Delete – the NFOOTY presumption of notability is rebutted by the lack of WP:SIGCOV. The "Uzbek Mystery" article is a routine new-guy...

also note that none of the early deletion supporters (other than the nom) rebuts any of the later keep arguments.Mojo Hand (talk) 03:38, 3 July 2014 (UTC)...

creation process, I will not dispute this, but that notability can be rebutted if it does not pass the basic notability criteria found in WP:N and WP:GNG...

1874, but the SNG creates a presumption of notability that should not be rebutted absent compelling evidence that hard copy newspapers of the era have been...

methods; historical moments of barcodes usage and their influence; rebutting with facts, esoteric theories about barcodes, like “Mark of the Beast”...

coverage in reliable sources, we are entitled to, and in most cases should, rebut the presumption. That’s why we have AFD: to discuss; not to rule. —Mkativerata...

redirect to FK Mladost Lučani. Claims of significant coverage clearly rebutted in the discussion. As noted by a number editors, WP:GEOFEAT requires significant...

contribs)'s comments to the effect that the subject meets WP:ACADEMIC were not rebutted, and this information appears to have been unknown at nomination. The subject...

voters have offered sources that were not addressed by the nominator or rebutted by anyone else. (non-admin closure) Jovanmilic97 (talk) 08:48, 18 January...

a strong consensus primary and secondary rationales for deletion were rebutted adequately. Xymmax So let it be written So let it be done 18:58, 12 February...

page.‎ The result was no consensus. The original nomination's premise was rebutted, and there is no consensus that the article should be deleted. A merge...

that "a quick Google search did not show anything" I felt it necessary to rebut that assertion. Is it really the case that google searches can be used as...

publications and authorship. That argument for notability has never been rebutted except by assertions of non-notability. Sjakkalle (Check!) 07:52, 30 September...

biographies of living persons policy. Not only does the latter argument rebut the former, but the weight of numbers across the whole course of the discussion...

being sources out there. Arguments are weak at the moment and have been rebutted by a single editor. No harm extending for a weak given minimal involvement...

Those arguing to keep have put forward such sources, which have not been rebutted. All other concerns, such as specific unverifiable content, or whether...

they have a staff profile), regardless of coverage. This is adequately rebutted by the users in the "delete" position. Exemptions from the General Notability...

(talk) 02:22, 25 May 2010 (UTC) Keep. While unreleased demos are presumed (rebuttably) to be nn under WP:MUSIC, this is a released collection of demos from...

at Demographic Research. That is enough evidence of scholarly impact to rebut “no indication” and favor improvement over deletion. NewTommy100 (talk)...

based on the argument that it did not violate policy, except that Calton rebutted most of them, as well as the argument of multi-million google hits.Blnguyen...

that the bolded words "rebuttal" should be removed, and the lists for rebutting the topic should be converted directly into prose and added into the section...

child, which is referenced but requires at the very least a suitable rebutting reference. DrKiernan 23:02, 19 May 2007 (UTC) Remove. Article needs rewriting...

made to this page.‎ The result was delete. Sources have been successfully rebutted that she doesn't meet GNG yet. Potential is not a policy based reasoning...

evaluated the discussion in that light. The proposed redirect was fairly well rebuted as well, so I accorded that argument less weight. What was left was a rough...

presumed to be notable per GEOLAND, this presumption is rebuttable, and it is being rebutted now that we're actually looking at the sources. A line in...

guideline, like other topic-specific notability guidelines, only establish a rebuttable presumption of notability. The "delete" side makes persuasive arguments...

readers. Furthermore, I submit not to interfere with this process by rebutting additions or subtractions made by editors 'without political agendas....

initially mentioned. Sometimes a one-phrase extreme claim could only be fully rebutted by several sentences, and so an equal word-count view, of the overall balance...

Late discussion inclusion of reliable source material for the article rebutted the no reliable sources assertions. Jreferee t/c 05:14, 9 October 2007...

delete. Largely per User:JamesBWatson, who lays out an argument that is not rebutted and appears to have the support of many editors. Obviously this discussion...

the finding of sources to satisfy notability, none of which have been rebutted by those supporting deletion. –MuZemike 21:43, 21 December 2011 (UTC) Stark...

argues that the battle is nowhere described in any detail, has not been rebutted. A redirect is a reasonable alternative to deletion that takes into account...

‎ The result was delete. Given that the second 'Keep' vote was clearly rebutted, there appears to be consensus to delete here. If there are other athletes...

October 2015 (UTC) Keep - nom to consider WP:BEFORE in future. Also trying to rebut every !vote = embarrassing Carlos Kickabaw (talk) 22:10, 20 October 2015...

theory is based on your original research. You've offered no sources to rebut the claim that this is a real technique used by the Mossad. Even if it did...

nominator favored deletion, and his invocation of WP:DICTDEF was sucessfully rebutted. Even if the word were now totally obsolete, Wikipedia covers the politics...

"it's an attack page" / "it's a BLP violation" opinions because they do not rebut the counterargument that these problems can be remedied through editing...

the keep votes are explicitly listed in WP:ATA. I'm gonna pre-emptively rebut all the terrible arguments made in the previous thread: "It's been around...

WP:GNG due to lack of coverage in secondary sources were successfully rebutted by the evidence provided by James500. A merge to Road Traffic Act 1988...

However, neither does the nominator, Shearonink, who is attempting to rebut arguments with stuff like the Christianity Today review...that was a 2-star...

stand-along page. Redirecting, as the usefulness of that WP:ATD has not been rebutted. A redirects for discussion nomination can be opened if desired. Hog Farm...

or delete. It's a philosophical talking point on articles typically to rebut a stubborn minority of supporters unable to fall back on anything else and...

the legislature, he clearly is notable per WP:POLITICIAN. Unless you can rebut that claim? --Philosopher Let us reason together. 18:09, 4 February 2010...

matter here is that the initial arguments are robust and have not been rebutted in any way. There is no evidence that any of these seasons have received...

vote, the argument that this article doesn't meet WP:NALBUM has not been rebutted. A pragmatic solution here is to redirect it to the article about the band...

 — SMcCandlish ☺ ☏ ¢ ≽ʌⱷ҅ᴥⱷʌ≼  07:04, 24 October 2014 (UTC) @Andy Mabbett: Can you rebut these claims? • • • Peter (Southwood) (talk): 08:26, 25 October 2014 (UTC)...

ForrestLane42 04:16, 3 January 2007 (UTC)ForrestLane42 You seem to have declined to rebut my supposition in regard to your motivations for the nomination. — goethean...

There is some substantive source analysis that has not been convincingly rebutted, and for both these reasons, the arguments to delete are considerably stronger...

I might provide more if any of claims are rebutted. For those saying it's a witch hunt, can anyone rebut this evidence and that evidence and that evidence...

nominator, and there is one support for keep. The rationale for keep has been rebutted, and a search for reliable sources finds the same promotional coverage...

creation but even it says notability is presumed which means it can be rebutted. This is the fact here. The subject does not meet notability criteria found...

sources were provided in this discussion, those sources were convincingly rebutted. Some "keep" !votes were also particularly weak, as they did not address...

nomination is a very good one and High King's argument to keep has been rebutted by K.e.coffman. A Traintalk 07:48, 4 August 2017 (UTC) Equilar, Inc. (edit |...

keep. The one dissenting !vote (other than the nom), appears to have been rebutted by another editor. (non-admin closure) Onel5969 TT me 21:06, 18 June 2017...

much was rebutted, in both its erroneous claim and its nonexistent policy basis. It just has been, yet again. The first time it was rebutted was about...

WP:GNG presumes notability ... that presumption must be (significantly) rebutted. Which it has not been. Thanks. Joseph A. Spadaro (talk) 18:25, 12 June...

puts alot of work into. The first nomination mentioned notable and I was rebutting that. I still think that it deserves a weak keep.Chris Kreider 22:38,...

The result was Keep. The issues raised by the nomination were adequately rebutted by the subsequent discussion and improvements to the article. Merge discussions...

fans. The abundant keep positions are very WP:GNG weak and have failed to rebut the strong "lack of sufficient reliable source coverage" argument presented...

notability and is used for article creation. Such presumptions may be rebutted and brought before AfD which we are then instructed to use our notability...

provided by the editors favoring deletion find them unsuitable was not rebutted. Xymmax So let it be written So let it be done 19:09, 16 March 2019 (UTC)...

of information. >Radiant< 16:09, 4 January 2007 (UTC) Comment: I have rebutted this 96% inaccurate observation here. AndyJones 12:07, 6 January 2007 (UTC)...

is consensus that the sources are not sufficient and this has not been rebutted. Stifle (talk) 09:15, 20 January 2026 (UTC) [Hide this box] New to Articles...

sources conclude that they are not sufficiently in depth, and nobody has rebutted that analysis. Sandstein 07:50, 22 September 2018 (UTC) [Hide this box]...

from the tournament they participated readily available online which could rebut the #2 argument for deletion. So IAR keep from me, which will be discarded...

that this RfC was improperly formatted and thus invalid. It was correctly rebutted that this format has been widely used and is the standard on RFC/Us, and...

result was delete. Not a hoax, but one evaluation of the sourcing was rebutted, BlueRoll18 keep doesn't go into more detail with the sourcing, and commentators...

rebuttals on True.origins. True.Origins houses articles specifically written to rebut Talk.Origins written by members of the major creationary groups. It also...

the place as a "flag stop", and nothing on the topos or aerials serves to rebut this; indeed, the topos indicate this was likely the name of the junction...

notability for article creation not article retention as presumptions can be rebutted. --ARoseWolf (Talk) 20:32, 19 January 2021 (UTC) Delete. Subject trivially...

January 2008 (UTC) I "loled" when you used Environment portal as your rebutal because it was me who built that portal. You beat me in this argument and...