Preceded by the singles "Personal Jesus" and "Enjoy the Silence" (a top-10 entry in both the United Kingdom and the United States), the album propelled the band into international stardom, and also yielded the singles "Policy of Truth" and "World in My Eyes". Violator reached number two on the UK Albums Chart, and was the band's first album to chart inside the top 10 of the Billboard 200, peaking at number seven. The album was supported by the World Violation Tour.
Background
Depeche Mode had supported their previous album, Music for the Masses (1987),[2] with the Music for the Masses Tour, which ran from late 1987 through mid-1988, which itself was supported by the live release 101, released in March 1989.[3] A few months later, Martin Gore released his first solo album, Counterfeit EP.[4] By the middle of 1989, the full band was recording together, and they released the single "Personal Jesus" in August, a full 7 months before the album itself.[5]
Recording
Violator was recorded in 1989 in Milan, Italy, and Denmark.[6] On the album, Depeche Mode worked with Flood as producer for the first time, and François Kevorkian was responsible for the sound mix.[6] Compared to previous albums, the band decided to try a new approach to recording. Alan Wilder said, "Usually we begin the making of a record by having extensive pre-production meetings where we decide what the record will actually sound like, then go into a programming studio. This time we decided to keep all pre-production work to a minimum. We were beginning to have a problem with boredom in that we felt we'd reached a certain level of achievement in doing things a certain way."[7]Martin Gore elaborated, "Over the last five years I think we'd perfected a formula; my demos, a month in a programming studio, etc. etc. We decided that our first record of the '90s ought to be different."[7]
With co-producer Flood, Wilder began a complementary working relationship, with Flood able to provide the technical know-how and Wilder working on the arrangements and song textures.[8] "That's how we made the group work at that time", clarified Wilder, "by accepting that we all had different roles and not actually all trying to do the same thing. So we ended up with this unwritten agreement in the band, where we'd all throw together a few ideas at the beginning of a track. Then Fletch and Mart would go away, and they'd come back after we'd worked on it for a while to give an opinion."[8]
There was also a notable change in Gore's demos. After the rigid, limiting effects of almost-finished demos for Music for the Masses, Gore, agreeing to Wilder's request, kept them less complete this time around. Several of the basic recordings consisted of vocals over a simple guitar or organ part, with the odd percussion loop, but less sequenced material. The sparse demos allowed the band to take creative liberties with the songs. For instance, "Enjoy the Silence" started out as a slow ballad, but at Wilder's suggestion became a pulsating, up-tempo track.[9]
The band convened to work on the record with Flood at Mute's WorldWide programming room in London for three weeks after which they flew to Milan for the new sessions at Logic studios. According to Flood, they did not do a substantial amount of work in Milan, except for the song "Personal Jesus", which was crucial in setting the tone and spirit of the album. "Everybody was feeling each other out, because they wanted to try working in a different way. The idea was to work hard and party hard and we all enjoyed ourselves to the full." After Milan the band relocated to Puk studios in northern Denmark, where most of the album was recorded.[10]
Composition
Musically, Violator has been described as synth-pop,[11][12]electropop,[13]alternative rock,[14]dance,[15] and gothic rock.[15] Gore called the track "World in My Eyes" a very positive song: "It's saying that love and sex and pleasure are positive things."[7] The song "Blue Dress", which Gore called "pervy", is simply about "watching a girl dress and realising that this is 'what makes the world turn.'"[7] With "Halo", Gore said, "I'm saying 'let's give in to this' but there's also a real feeling of wrongfulness [...] I suppose my songs do seem to advocate immorality but if you listen there's always a sense of guilt."[7] The closing track, "Clean", was inspired by Pink Floyd's song "One of These Days", from their 1971 album Meddle. Said Wilder, "they [Pink Floyd] were doing something very different to anyone else at that time – you can hear electronics in there, and the influence of classical music. It's got a very repetitive, synthesised sound, and the bass riffs with the echo have a very hypnotic groove that underpins it. We basically nicked that idea [for 'Clean']".[16]
Regarding the album's title, Gore said, "We called it Violator as a joke. We wanted to come up with the most extreme, ridiculously Heavy Metal title that we could. I'll be surprised if people will get the joke."[7]
In a contemporary review for Melody Maker, music critic Paul Lester called Violator "Depeche Mode's most arresting work to date."[27] Tim Nicholson of Record Mirror was enthused by the stripped-down quality of the songs and called the album a "compromise between pop music and something a little more sinister", adding: "There are no noises out of place in this perfectly formed void."[28] Ian Cranna of Q found the music subtly clever and deemed Violator "a fine record which may not set the world on fire but deserves to singe it a bit."[29]NME writer Helen Mead felt that the album "seems almost a step back, in that it's cleaner, sparser, more clinical" than Music for the Masses, but concluded that "there is security in the knowledge that everything is very clear cut in Depeche Mode's blue and white world."[30]
In a less enthusiastic review, Robert Christgau said that Depeche Mode conceded to fickle teenage demographics on Violator.[19]Rolling Stone magazine's Chuck Eddy said that, despite the album's "ambient charm", Gahan sounds "slimy and self-involved", and in their attempt to make listeners dance, Depeche Mode "revert to morose pop psychology and then never tell you how come they're so sad."[31] For Entertainment Weekly, Greg Sandow wrote that that the songs "hint at unspecified meanings, in a mannered way that might well be called pompous".[32]
Among retrospective appraisals, AllMusic critic Ned Raggett viewed Violator as "song for song... simply the best, most consistent effort yet from the band",[17] while Blender's Dennis Lim deemed it Depeche Mode's "career peak" and "justifiably their biggest critical and commercial success".[18] Barry Walters of Rolling Stone identified the album as one of the "key stages in the band's evolution", citing its emphasis on "heavier hooks, cinematic arrangements and sleek sonic detail."[24] In Mojo, Danny Eccleston wrote that Violator found Depeche Mode merging "European and US paradigms much as U2 had done in the mid-'80s",[21] transforming them "from an arena-level electro-pop unit into a global stadium rock band".[33] Writing for Q, John Aizlewood singled out Flood's production on the album for praise, saying that the resulting "warmth" of the music "has helped Violator to age with consummate grace."[23] Sal Cinquemani of Slant Magazine called the album "a quintessential benchmark of pop, rock, and electronic music".[15]
Violator was ranked number 57 on Rolling Stone's 2010 list of the 100 best albums of the 1990s.[34] It was ranked number 342 on the 2003 and 2012 editions of the magazine's list of the 500 greatest albums of all time,[35][36] and number 167 on the list's 2020 edition.[37]Violator has also featured on lists of the greatest albums of all time made by publications such as Q and Spin,[38][39] and is included in the book 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die.[40]
Commercial
As a sign of their rising popularity when Violator was released, a signing party for fans at a Wherehouse record store in Los Angeles that was expected to draw only a few thousand fans ended up drawing around 17,000. The band were forced to withdraw from the event due to security concerns, and their early exit nearly caused a riot.[41]Violator reached number 17 on the Billboard 200-year-end chart of 1990,[42] and was the first Depeche Mode album to sell a million copies in the United States.[41]
The success of Violator introduced the band to a wider audience, and this increased exposure led to their 1993 follow-up album Songs of Faith and Devotion debuting at the top of the charts in both the United States and United Kingdom.[43] "Before this, we'd been going along quite nicely," recalled Andy Fletcher. "Then when it came to Violator we inexplicably went huge. It was just incredible, and in many ways we never really recovered from that. After that, we just felt like we wanted to muck it up a bit."[44]
As part of Mute's 2006 reissue schedule, Violator was re-released as a hybrid Super Audio CD + DVD-Video package on 3 April 2006 that included two-channel and 5.1 surround mixes of the album. The six B-sides to the Violator singles—"Dangerous", "Memphisto", "Sibeling", "Kaleid", "Happiest Girl", and "Sea of Sin"—also appear, albeit without the surround sound treatment. The reissue did not reach the US until 6 June 2006. The US version lacked the hybrid SACD and instead included a separate CD and DVD. The DVD was identical to the European DVD but in NTSC format instead of PAL. The lack of SACD is due to the titles being distributed in North America by Warner, who do not support the SACD format.
A 32-minute short film, titled Depeche Mode 1989–90 (If You Wanna Use Guitars, Use Guitars), featured interviews with the band, Daniel Miller, Flood, François Kevorkian (who mixed the album), Anton Corbijn (who directed the music videos and did the album's photography/cover), and others. It also includes news footage from the infamous "riot" in Los Angeles, which gave the band media publicity the day before Violator came out. The band were scheduled to do autographs in an LA music store, and the line became extremely long, stretching towards twenty-thousand people, and the event had to be cancelled shortly after it began due to problems keeping them in order. There is also footage from Strange Too, notably clips from the music videos for "Halo" and "Clean".
The remastered album was released on "deluxe" vinyl on 2 March 2007 in Germany and on 5 March 2007 internationally.
^Both the original US and the original UK vinyl editions have a shorter version of "Personal Jesus".[45]
^According to the band's website, the original title for "Waiting for the Night" was "Waiting for the Night to Fall" and the rest of the title was omitted due to a printing error.[46] However, during an online Q&A session, Alan Wilder claimed that the story was "incorrect."[47]
^"Blue Dress" includes hidden track "Interlude #3" at 4:18[45][48][49][50]
Japanese first pressing
A double-disc version was released in March 1990 in Japan.[51] It comes in a thick double CD jewel case with the twelve-page lyric inlay booklet, sixteen-page Japanese insert, "Enjoy the Silence" insert, and forty-page 1991 wall calendar. The second edition double CD was fixed and included "Enjoy the Silence" (Hands and Feet mix) instead of the edited Ecstatic dub mix.
Japanese limited edition bonus CD
No.
Title
Length
1.
"Enjoy the Silence" (single version)
4:17
2.
"Enjoy the Silence" (Ecstatic dub)
5:54
3.
"Enjoy the Silence" (Ecstatic dub edit)
5:45
4.
"Sibeling" (single version)
3:13
5.
"Enjoy the Silence" (Bass Line)
7:42
6.
"Enjoy the Silence" (Harmonium)
2:42
7.
"Enjoy the Silence" (Ricki Tik Tik mix)
5:28
8.
"Memphisto" (single version)
4:01
Total length:
86:04
2006 reissue
Disc one is a hybrid SACD/CD with a multi-channel SACD layer, with the same track listing as the 1990 release. Bonus tracks are in PCM Stereo (48 kHz/16bit).
Disc two is a DVD which includes the documentary Depeche Mode 1989–90 (If You Wanna Use Guitars, Use Guitars), Violator in DTS 5.1, Dolby Digital 5.1 and PCM Stereo (48 kHz/24bit), in addition to the following bonus tracks:
* Sales figures based on certification alone. ^ Shipments figures based on certification alone. ‡ Sales+streaming figures based on certification alone.
References
^Smith, Robin (17 February 1990). "This Week - The Next Seven Days in View: Releases". Record Mirror. p. 28. ISSN0144-5804.
^Cranna, Ian (April 1990). "Insidious". Q. No. 43. London. p. 77. ISSN0955-4955. Archived from the original on 12 September 1999. Retrieved 5 August 2023.
^Mead, Helen (17 March 1990). "Violators Are Blue". NME. London. p. 37. ISSN0028-6362.
^Wilder, Alan. "Violator". Shunt - the Official Recoil Website. Retrieved 24 July 2020. Is it correct that the right title was 'Waiting For The Night To Fall'?" "Incorrect.
^"Classifiche". Musica e dischi (in Italian). Retrieved 2 July 2022. Select "Album" in the "Tipo" field, type "Violator" in the "Titolo" field and press "cerca".