The film sets up the 2011 season by showing how the knuckleball saved both pitchers from obscurity.[1] Dickey moved his family 37 times before landing with the New York Mets.[4] The film presents Wakefield's chase of his 200th win as a member of the 2011 Red Sox and Dickey's make-it-or-break-it season with the 2011 Mets.[3] It demonstrates the fraternal nature of knuckleball pitchers who trade tips of the trade via various meetings with the likes of Phil Niekro and Charlie Hough.[1][3] Dickey won the Cy Young Award in November 2012.[5][6]
Neil Genzlinger of The New York Times, noted that the film's release coincided with Dickey's Cy Young run, which made the "first-rate sports documentary" especially sweet.[1]The Boston Globe'sTy Burr said "The movie's a must for baseball fans in general and Red Sox fans in particular".[3]
Even the film's harshest critics such as Time Out's David Fear says "Viewers who can’t get enough of ESPN's "30 for 30" docs will lap up this dual portrait", but continued to say that "Nonfans, however, are about to find out exactly what the phrase inside baseball means."[8]