As a freshman at Shepherd in 2019, Anthony played in ten games with five starts where he notched 14 tackles, three pass deflections, and two interceptions. In the 2020 season, Shepherd University cancelled its season due to the COVID-19 pandemic, resulting in Anthony not playing.[2] After the conclusion of the 2020 season, Anthony entered his name into the NCAA transfer portal.[3]
Anthony transferred to play for the Liberty Flames.[4] In week nine of the 2022 season, Anthony recorded an interception off of quarterback KJ Jefferson, as he helped the Flames upset Arkansas.[5] During Anthony's two year career with Liberty in 2021 and 2022 he appeared in 21 games where he notched 41 tackles with one and a half going for a loss, six pass deflections, and three interceptions.[6] After the conclusion of the 2022 season, Anthony again decided to enter his name into the NCAA transfer portal for the second time in his career.[7]
Anthony transferred to play for the Ole Miss Rebels.[8][9] In week two of the 2023 season, Anthony was graded as one of PFF's highest graded safeties, finishing with two tackles and two pass deflections in a win over Tulane.[10] Anthony finished the 2023 season making 61 tackles, eight pass deflections, three interceptions, and a forced fumble.[11] After the conclusion of the 2023 season, Anthony declared for the 2024 NFL draft.[12][13] Anthony was also invited to participate in the 2024 NFL Combine.[14]
In Week 2 against the Kansas City Chiefs, the Bengals were leading 25–23 with 48 seconds remaining on a crucial 4th-and-16. Anthony was covering Chiefs receiver Rashee Rice when he made contact prior to the catch, resulting in a pass interference call allowing the Chiefs to kick a walk-off game winning field goal as time expired to win 26–25.[18]