After his collegiate basketball career ended, Bruggers turned his focus to football. Undrafted in the 1966 American Football League draft, he signed with the Miami Dolphins and played for the team for three seasons as a linebacker. He recorded six interceptions and two fumble recoveries during his time with the Dolphins.
In 1969, Bruggers was traded to the San Diego Chargers, where he played for two seasons before retiring from professional football in 1971.
Bruggers' career came to abrupt end on October 4, 1975. With Bruggers needing to drive from his home in Kingstree, South Carolina, to Wilmington, North Carolina, for an event, promoterJim Crockett Jr., who was ill with influenza, invited him to instead take his place on a Cessna 310 that he had chartered. Bruggers took a seat on the plane along with Crockett's brother David and fellow wrestlers Ric Flair, Johnny Valentine, and Tim Woods. Shortly before reaching its destination, the plane ran out of fuel and crashed. The pilot, Mike Farkas, sustained ultimately fatal injuries and all five passengers were injured, with Bruggers suffering spinal fractures and a broken ankle. After having steel rods inserted into his spinal column, Bruggers was able to walk out of hospital three weeks after the crash, but decided not to return to wrestling.[10][11][3][4]
Retirement
Following his retirement from football and wrestling, Bruggers worked as a sales manager for a tool company before relocating to West Palm Beach, Florida, where in 1978 he opened a bar using an insurance settlement he had received after the plane crash.[3][4][12] He was inducted into the University of Minnesota's "M" Club Hall of Fame in 2002, in recognition of his accomplishments as both a basketball and football player.
Bruggers died in Florida on May 10, 2024, at the age of 80.[13]