The Nintendo 64 version received favorable reviews, while the Game Boy Color version received mixed reviews, according to the review aggregation website GameRankings.[16][17] The staff of Next Generation said in their July 1999 issue that just as they were about to give the former "a perfect rating", they noticed some gameplay bugs and AI glitches, but ultimately called it the best baseball game for Nintendo 64.[13]
^McNamara, Andy; Anderson, Paul; Reiner, Andrew (May 1999). "All-Star Baseball 2000 (N64)". Game Informer. No. 73. FuncoLand. Archived from the original on 21 October 2000. Retrieved 6 July 2020.
^Higgins, Geoff "El Nino"; Mowatt, Todd "Video Cowboy" (May 1999). "All-Star Baseball 2000 (N64)". GameFan. Vol. 7, no. 5. Shinno Media. pp. 58, 61. Retrieved 7 July 2020.
^"All-Star Baseball 2000 (N64)". Nintendo Power. Vol. 120. Nintendo of America. May 1999. p. 124. Archived from the original on 7 July 2020. Retrieved 6 July 2020.